14 ms·
Can an artificial kidney finally free patients from dialysis?
- msie 3y agoThe Kidney project has been at it for at least 8 years. Maybe they’ll have something in 10 years. I am not optimistic about anything coming out of it soon. It’s like the Moller Skycar.
- ephaptic089 3y agoYes, I've been following this line of research since 2004. This may predate the Kidney project: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1523-1755.2004.00923.x https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1523-1755.2004.00923.x I'm glad there are still new developments and I hope something comes of it (I have known people who needed to go through dialysis). It is definitely in the realm of the high-and-lofty.
- zaitsev1393 3y agoNo idea why i can't access this website from Ukraine.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- oneshtein 3y agoSite owner blocked the site for Ukrainians. :-/ Error 1009 Ray ID: 80075b57bf1f2301 • 2023-09-02 17:08:45 UTC Access denied What happened? The owner of this website (www.ucsf.edu) has banned the country or region your IP address is in (UA) from accessing this website. Use this link: https://web.archive.org/web/20230829172126/https://www.ucsf.edu/news/2023/08/426056/can-artificial-kidney-finally-free-patients-dialysis https://web.archive.org/web/20230829172126/https://www.ucsf....
- tptacek 3y agohttps://archive.ph/ba9Cw https://archive.ph/ba9Cw Presumably it's just an overbroad filter responding to some random attack in the past. Either way: best not to pick it apart on this thread, which isn't about web filtering, but rather artificial kidneys.
- Tagbert 3y agoOddly, I'm getting a server not found for archive.ph.
- AnnikaL 3y agoCloudflare DNS does not work for archive.ph and its other domains.
- msla 3y agoTry: https://archive.is/ba9Cw https://archive.is/ba9Cw Also, try turning off DoH on Firefox: https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/dns-over-https https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/dns-over-https (Except for me it wasn't server not found, it was an SSL error about no cipher (or "cypher" in SSL-speak) overlap.)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- phibz 3y agoAs someone on dialysis, this would be amazing to see. I wonder if the same immunoresponse issues would happen with this like with a transplant. The holy grail of transplant medicine for years has been acquired immunity, where you convince the immunesystem not to attack the transplant. Still hoping we see progress there, but this looks like a viable alternative to a donor transplant.
- candiddevmike 3y agoWould teaching the immune system to "forget" cover this situation (along with other autoimmune diseases) too?
- blorenz 3y agoAs someone totally unqualified to make an assessment about this, I feel selectively forgetting is much harder than generalized forgetting. This would make the person vulnerable to multitudes of vectors.
- robbiep 3y agoYou’re basically right, we have no idea how to do this - we can help the immune system remember new things (ie we’ve started teaching it how to attack cancers that it has been ignoring) but when the body wants to go at something, the only way we’ve been able to get it to sort it’s shit out is to wipe out all the agents of the adaptive immune system and implant a new one (give someone a bone marrow transplant). This has resulted in cures for patients with MS, but is really risky and doesn’t scale.
- justinclift 3y agoDoesn't catching measles somehow reset the immune system as well? As per articles a while ago like this: https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20211112-the-people-with-immune-amnesia https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20211112-the-people-with-...
- f6v 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- srameshc 3y agoI truly hope this is could be the solution. Dialysis is live saving , yet very difficult. I always hoped there was an easier solution to hemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis.
- ck2 3y agoAmerican health insurance is allowed to refuse to pay for any treatment considered experimental so the correct question is "will anyone be able to afford it" and the answer is "not the masses not anytime this decade".
- porkbeer 3y agoI bet its cheaper than the alternative, expensive treatment for life...
- f6v 3y agoI see this argument very often in relation to various medical interventions. First off, insurance anywhere isn’t going to just pay for experimental treatment. Second, a great deal of inventions were not available to the masses at first. So should we stop inventing things? Or wait for a new worldwide socialist revolution first?
- esotericsean 3y agoThis probably isn't a viable solution for my father who has been on dialysis for 2 years and is in ESRD. I am a candidate for a kidney transplant for him (I went through the whole process), but he has other issues that have been preventing him from having another surgery. I'm pretty scared to do the procedure, too. But really glad to see progress being made here. Hopefully, also, the world works toward improving diet and starts eliminating metabolic diseases like Type-2 Diabetes and Heart Disease.
- rocky1138 3y agoAs a living kidney donor, I can tell you that it's not all that scary. It's much scarier to be ESRD and suffering the hellish purgatory of dialysis. The operation is quick and recovery isn't too bad. As long as you have support at home from friends and family it's not terrible. What struck me, though, was how weak it made me. Walking for the first time in a week was very slow, very sweaty, and put me into a state of extreme exhaustion.
- idontunder 3y agoare you feeling okay now? have you had other consequences from donating your kidney?
- DennisP 3y agoAlso they say it'll be available by 2030 at the earliest: https://pharm.ucsf.edu/kidney/device/faq https://pharm.ucsf.edu/kidney/device/faq
- jacquesm 3y agoI've looked at this from a fathers perspective and have made the decision that no matter how much my kids may be a good match I would never want to be a donor recipient from them. That short-circuits a lot of ethical dilemmas around such a decision and making that decision well before it would ever come into play makes it a lot easier. My eldest one day said he'd gladly give up a kidney for me and it caused me to think about that at a time when it wasn't even on the horizon (fortunately it still isn't). That doesn't mean I do not appreciate the sentiment (and that I think you are tremendously brave) but it wouldn't sit right with me as a parent. A big part of that is that they would be giving up something that they may very well need later in life and I may be condemning them to a reduced quality of life at some point in the future (possibly long after I've passed away but that doesn't really matter). Another part is that I don't want to see my children in any way diminished or at risk because of me, they're not 'spare parts'. On the reverse I would do in a heartbeat. These are tricky problems.
- piyushpr134 3y agohope as much money & marketing is poured in cure, is also poured into prevention as it is better to prevent than to cure. I believe that many types of kidney diseases are linked to metabolic syndrome. Hope media and doctors highlight this to all and sundry that eating less, moving more, keeping weight and blood sugar in control can stop disease progression.
- porkbeer 3y agoI respect what you are saying, but both people I know suffering through it are type 1, and are just struggling to stay alive in a way where they want to continue living.
- RetroTechie 3y agoKidney problems can also be acute. Resulting from some kind of poisoning, out-of-control infection, or some situation where immune system attacks the body itself. Husband of an friend of mine (~75y old at the time) got unwell during a heatwave. Kidneys gave up, resulting in blood poisoning & that was the end. I hope for the grow-spare-from-own-body-cells method to become a practical option. That would do away with donor shortages & immune system rejection problems. Kidneys & liver would probably rank high as desired replacement organs.
- DennisP 3y agoThere's also polycystic kidney disease, which is a fairly common genetic condition.
- ma55ypi3 3y agoWill this be abused whereby peoples are coerced into trading their kidney for an artificial one for a price?
- n3storm 3y agoI saw that movie too. I think is based on a book though.
- bmicraft 3y agoIf this doesn't get rejected by the patient, how would that even make economic sense?
- gjm11 3y agoWhat does that scenario look like in practice? Suppose I'm the evil coercing person. I have an artificial kidney and $X, you have (still in your body) a real kidney, and you're short of money so you prefer (artificial kidney + $X) to (real kidney). We make the trade. Why would I do that? Presumably so that I can (evilly) treat someone with kidney disease by giving them a real kidney, which they prefer to an artificial one. In fact, to make it worth my while they must also be paying me at least $X more for the real kidney than they would have for the artificial one. So the incentives work out provided my patient prefers (real kidney) to (artificial kidney + $X), and my victim prefers (artificial kidney + $X) to (real kidney), and what I'm doing is (evilly, coercively) enabling them both to get what they prefer. It's hard to see how I can be doing anyone very much harm here. Presumably the idea is that the victim is worse off, having been persuaded to give up their precious real kidney for an inferior artificial kidney in exchange for mere money, but also-presumably they are poor enough not to have the luxury to use phrases like "mere money" and $X is a life-changing amount for them. Which probably means their situation at the outset is very bad, but that isn't my fault. I expect there are possible situations where the existence of artificial kidneys enables some things to happen that look good to all participants but end up being bad ideas in the long run. But it seems super-implausible to me that these could outweigh the benefits of being able to make functioning artificial kidneys.
- Plasmoid 3y ago
- thr0waway001 3y agoThat would be cool as a kidney disease patient.
- tomcam 3y agoFive years away, I’m sure! The really good stuff is perpetually five years away…
- quasarj 3y agoYep, this has been 5 years away for the past 20 years.
- munchler 3y ago[flagged]
- brokenmeds 3y agoUsing throw-away as this sounds dismal, BUT: who makes money from this and who loses money? That will tell you whether this can happen or not. Dialysis is big business. Technicians. Consumables. Doctors. Repeated Vi$it$. Real estate (often owned by the Nephrologist $.) More saliently, Nephrologist also control the standard of care. Do they stand to gain more from artificial kidney surgery/maintenance, or do they stand more to lose from dialysis going away?
- DennisP 3y agoOn the other hand, the government spends a huge amount on dialysis. Medicare pays for it regardless of your age. Removing the need for dialysis simplifies life for politicians by putting off the day they need to raise taxes or cut Medicare services. Dialysis is also a lot crappier than this would be. My mom was on dialysis and quality of life is not great. Neither is the expected lifespan. Free markets have their flaws but their big advantage is competition. If the government approves this device, and it provides significantly better outcomes, then nephrologists who use it will take patients from those who don't.
- tialaramex 3y agoMy understanding is that the firms who provide Medicare patient dialysis are very loathe to have patients exit their system, if they spend say $1000 on patient care and bill Medicare, the US government, for $1200 that's $200 of very safe profit. If that patient gets a transplant that's $200 of lost profits, regardless of how much healthier the patient is, and so they have no incentive to help patients get a transplant. So for technologies, either xenotransplantation (GM pig kidneys) or artificial kidneys which eliminate dialysis, expect some push back from those firms, certainly expect them to have a more negative outlook on any safety studies etc. than you might expect if you think of them as neutral health professionals who are focused on patient outcomes. Which of course doesn't magically mean these alternatives end up safer and healthier, they might turn out cheaper but worse, whereupon pushing to keep dialysis makes sense and you'd find yourself on the same side as the profiteers, but this happens, just like if you thought Prohibition was wrong and you found yourself alongside people whose businesses prey on problem drinkers...
- xwdv 3y agoI wonder if someday technology like this will advance to a point where we can create entirely new organs that can do things that weren’t possible before.
- xyst 3y agoThe day artificial organs replace the need for donation organs, it will save millions of people (today and future)
- wernercd 3y agodoesn't even need to be "organs" plural... a single organ could probably do that - although one would no doubt include information to help others. For all the bad things going on in the world... always good to see options like these becoming possible.
- NotACop182 3y agoI might got to hell for this: Can an artificial kidney finally free patients from kidney stones?
- Turing_Machine 3y agoI don't think there's anything bad about wondering that at all. While people generally don't die from kidney stones nowadays (although sometimes they still do), they are widely acknowledged as producing some of the most severe pain that humans can experience (sometimes they're not bad, or even painless, but when they are painful, boy howdy does it hurt). Just speculating, I'd guess that while artificial kidneys might possibly develop stones, they wouldn't be painful, as the artificial kidney probably wouldn't be connected to the patient's nervous system.
- iancmceachern 3y agoThis would be awesome. I helped architect and design the Outset Tablo hemodialysis machine, have designed several LVAD/Artificial hearts and a few other dialysis related systems. This is the ultimate goal, would be amazing improvement for patient quality of life. God speed to this team!!
- Dwedit 3y agoDialysis itself is the original artificial kidney. It's just not inside your body.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- majido 3y agoMy friend’s startup is working to make the dialysis itself more portable and accessible by dramatically relaxing the water and other operational requirements. They are now running a human trial in Canada. A device that can be in the body feels like the ultimate holy grail in this area. Medical advances like this take a lot of effort and time. https://qidni.life/ https://qidni.life/