6 ms·
Spirituality of Science: Implications for Meaning, Well-Being, and Learning
- swayvil 3y agoScience is one method for getting knowledge. Other methods are "see for yourself" and "get it from an authority". All have their pros and cons. One downside of science is its reliance upon communication. It shares its faults. This becomes especially glaring when addressing uncommon perspectives. I think it's the wrong tool for that job. Like "spiritual" stuff. The perspective is often so uncommon that any discussion may as well be fiction.
- HPsquared 3y agoAlso "deduce it for yourself"
- haswell 3y ago> Like "spiritual" stuff. The perspective is so uncommon that any perspective under discussion may as well be fiction. This highlights the range of interpretations of “spirituality”. There is the explicitly religious kind. The “woo woo” non-religious but still metaphysical kind. As far as I can tell, this paper is focused more on the kind of spirituality that has nothing to do with either of those. The kind that comes from the realization that for all of the scientific progress we’ve made, none of it actually explains what anything is. I think it was Roger Penrose who said something like “I’m a materialist, but dislike the word because we have no idea what material actually is”. False dichotomies between science and spirituality are common in pop culture, probably because of the massive amount of baggage brought by untenable religious and metaphysical beliefs. But for many scientifically minded people, “spirituality” is both an outcome of their growing depth of knowledge, and the force driving them to dig deeper. To me, spirituality is about pausing the labeling and interpreting part of my brain, and realizing how intrinsically connected I am to the first moments of the universe. Appreciating the absolutely ridiculous improbability of my existence. In essence, leaning in to the awe and wonder experience that’s available and magnified by a growing scientific understanding. Reducing existence to a series of increasingly more granular labels that still barely scratch the surface of what’s going on is its own form of fiction. It’s incredibly useful fiction that helps us understand and navigate ever more complex aspects of reality, but is still fundamentally just a simplified map of an indescribably complex territory.
- swayvil 3y agoSo you think the article uses the term "spiritual" differently? I confess, did not read. I'm getting kinda alienated from reading. Anything more than a sentence and I drift. But ya. You know what helps you understand the taste of a lemon? Here's a clue, it ain't a deep complex story about a lemon.
- haswell 3y agoFrom the abstract: > Scientists often refer to spiritual experiences with science. This research addresses this unique component of science attitudes — spirituality of science: feelings of meaning, awe, and connection derived through scientific ideas. Three studies (N = 1,197) examined individual differences in Spirituality of Science (SoS) and its benefits for well-being, meaning, and learning.
- swayvil 3y agoGimme the short version.
- nprateem 3y ago> To me, spirituality is about pausing the labeling and interpreting part of my brain, and... No need for "and", just stick with that.
- serialNumber 3y agoThis comment is a beautiful example of just that - if I read this correctly, you're already judging them for their take on spirituality . Please correct me if I'm wrong - but personally, approaching new ideas with an open mind, instead of a mind that has already come to a judgement, has served me very well .
- nprateem 3y agoNot judging, just pointing out it's possible to go further and just hang out in the present moment. That can bring the experience to daily activities, which can bring about surprising changes. In fact, it's not even necessary to switch off thinking. The key is to give no value to thoughts that come up (unless you're actually engaged in focussed thinking, eg intentional planning, problem solving, etc), or emotions. It changes everything. An example: I've been suffering from melancholic thoughts for some months, carrying a heaviness with me I couldn't shed. I recently decided I'd had enough and I didn't want them any more. I decided they were nothing to do with me, much in the same way as I'd treat a fart - some process that occurs but which passes and I forget about. This has resulted in a subtle but significant transformation. The melancholy has been replaced by something difficult to describe but no longer heavy and depressing, and at times elating.
- thenerdhead 3y ago"authorities" are experts at best. Famously said by just about every science educator.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- epgui 3y agoUhh no… Almost by definition, science encompasses all (valid) methods for getting knowledge.
- swayvil 3y agoJust out of curiosity, what's an example of an invalid method for getting knowledge?
- superq 3y agoScience is, by definition, based on observation and proving hypotheses through that observation. That's literally what the scientific method is all about and how a hypothesis, supported by evidence, becomes a theory, and thereafter a law, based on observable and measurable phenomena. We all have our pet theories (read: ideas and biases) on the distant past, where we have an infinite number of possibilities; in this universe of possibilities, there is only one possible truth. Some of these observations and theories we might not have even tripped over yet as we literally stumble around in the dark. Anything beyond that, even to a large extent cosmological theories such as the existence of a multiverse, let alone observations of the distant past, is, by definition, less about science and more about philosophy or even religion. This knife cuts both ways and we should remember our own biases. In what way would you live your life differently if you believed the opposite of what you believe right now?
- slushh 3y ago>Science is, by definition, based on observation and proving hypotheses through that observation. Technically, hypotheses cannot be proven because it's possible that all measurements were outliers.
- mistermann 3y agoAlso, defining something as <X> doesn't necessarily cause it to be that, but with adequate ~training[1] (basically, cultural beliefs and behavioral norms) it can make it appear as such. This phenomenon surrounds us constantly, and is filtered out from our experience. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illusory_truth_effect https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illusory_truth_effect
- haswell 3y ago> Science is, by definition, based on observation and proving hypotheses through that observation. That's literally what the scientific method is all about and how a hypothesis, supported by evidence, becomes a theory, and thereafter a law, based on observable and measurable phenomena And yet these laws, for all of their increasing accuracy at labeling and predicting phenomena, emerge from subjective human understanding, which itself we have no ability to explain. The maps we build are ever more intricate, but I think we tend to overestimate the role of those maps in getting closer to truly understanding what’s going on. This is not in any way an endorsement of metaphysical beliefs, but points at why “spirituality” (not the religious or woo woo kind) emerges from and drives science forward. I think of it as a kind of humility and willingness to embrace awe and wonder, and a recognition that science is only one pillar of understanding, and is ultimately just an increasingly intricate map of the territory. This isn’t to say that we won’t eventually find bigger answers, but we’re certainly not close. > In what way would you live your life differently if you believed the opposite of what you believe right now? I do think this is an interesting thought experiment, but I don’t think there needs to be any opposition here. Believing in science has sometimes become synonymous with believing that science somehow is the stuff of base reality. While it’s certainly closer than older beliefs about spirits and gods, there is still underneath it all a primordial and mysterious quality to everything that science has no answers for. To me, this points not at the need to adopt a specific belief, but to hold space for the fact that we still understand so little. > Anything beyond that…is, by definition, less about science and more about philosophy or even religion. Philosophy and religion are just other language games that explore other aspects of the same territory. Over time, religion has proven to be less useful, and certainly isn’t backed by empirical evidence. Philosophy points to the unknowability of things, but even a scientific stance is in some sense a philosophical stance. Often these approaches are pitted against each other, but with the exception of religion, I think they are all necessary pillars of a broader understanding. Science without a philosophical understanding of science is arguably just another form of religion. This is not to say that science is invalid or not useful, but rather that it is not sufficient. Maybe that will change as our scientific knowledge grows.
- photochemsyn 3y agoThe underlying concept here is that religious-like faith/belief has a utilitarian value regardless of the actual truth or verifiability of religious claims, and that this utilitarian value can be ported over the non-religious secular society by introducing 'faith in science' and in particular 'awe of science'. I think this a profoundly misguided notion that is highly detrimental to the actual practice of scientific investigation and discovery, and it's a bit telling that none of the promoters of this concept, characteristic of the 'New Atheism' are working scientists in any active field. The problem is that our scientific understanding of the world is continually evolving and developing as new discoveries are made and old concepts are overturned. Clearly, developing a sense of faith in some scientific paradigm as the basis of some utilitarian 'psychological benefits of belief' project will lead to grief if that scientific view is upset by new data. The notion that one's cherished views of reality may be overturned by new knowledge (particularly if that leads to things like a loss of funding in some field) is already hard enough for working scientists to come to grips with (e.g. plate tectonics etc.) without adding in the fact that psychological despair may be induced by such new revelations. Furthermore, science has very little to say about morality or justice, other than providing factual forensic data which people may use in a legal context. For example, all science has to say about cannibalism is that eating brain tissue from one's own species may lead to degenerative prion diseases. Genocide of human populations, well, scientifically there's nothing wrong with that, it's just natural selection and competition for resources. Religion, regardless of the factual reality of it or not, is probably a somewhat better guide to the kinds of moral behavior, although in modern society it's all codified in legal structures. I suppose the secular view is that science and law are the twin pillars of modern civilization, but the notion that 'faith' in such structures has some necessary psychological benefit smells of a manipulative controlling approach to human relations. If people really want something supportive to believe in, they're better off sticking to their favorite literary/religious texts, even if they're just products of human imagination.
- zmgsabst 3y agoTherein lies the problem with Trust the Science (TM): All the awe, worship, and adherence to priests with none of the moral precepts.
- nathan_compton 3y agoI think talk of spirituality is just as asinine when scientists do it as when anyone else does. I can respect the demented insights of the true believer or zealot, but when most scientists (or even regular people) talk about spirituality its usually just performative word salad.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mistermann 3y agoDo you care if your impression is accurate, or is that woo woo?
- nathan_compton 3y agoFrankly, I've never even understood what people are talking about when they talk about spirituality except some vaguely soothing bullshit only tenuously connected with any kind of actionable or knowable reality. The defining trait of "spiritual" people, in my experience, is the capacity to be satisfied with vague and sloppy thinking, at least in the realms they want to be "spiritual" about.
- mistermann 3y agoMy practice of spirituality mostly involves studying phenomena like the one you were experiencing as you wrote this comment. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maya_(religion) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maya_(religion) Perhaps now you can respond with some memes, then I can check where they fall in the distribution of responses from prior applications of this prompt.
- wuqtas 3y agowhat else could be more spiritual and concise than science? “The cosmos is within us. We are made of star-stuff. We are a way for the universe to know itself.” ― Carl Sagan
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- thenerdhead 3y agoThis seems like a no-brainer to me. Every book I've read on popular scientists showed their spiritual side. Carl Sagan's "The Demon-Haunted World" goes through this in-depth. One of my favorite quotes in it is: “Science is not only compatible with spirituality; it is a profound source of spirituality.” - Carl Sagan Surprised this quote wasn't included but another quote was.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- akomtu 3y agoScience is already very spiritual in principle. GR teaches how pure energy without shape or form on its own appears as material objects. QM teaches that all things evolve as one mysterious wave function and what we see is small local parts of it. Finally, each thing or force, no matter how big or small, is governed by the same law that the science is trying to learn. In spiritual lingo, it's the "all is in one and one is in all" concept. The above even shows the threefold nature: action (GM), perception (QM) and will (the law). What's non spiritual, and frankly non scientific, is the religion of materialism: that all things are made of small mechanistic particles, and consciousness somehow arises from interactions of those particles. The idea of a mechanistic universe, in other words.
- vjerancrnjak 3y agoIt is quite amazing how far we’ve got. Bell’s theorem, the free will theorem, local or non local universe, real or non real, coobservers, superdeterminism. We’ve gone from modeling results of our observations to trying to figure out what exactly observation is. Neuroscience with its split brain experiment, showing how the brain deludes itself, how there is no self, no central spot. How the nonspeaking part that controls one side of the body never rebels hearing the delusions of the speaking part. So many mysteries that were fully uncovered and many more waiting to be uncovered. What a ride being conscious is.
- pdonis 3y agoYou do realize that the "spiritual in principle" science you describe is "materialism", right? The "small mechanistic particles" are the quantum wave function; they're the same thing. And according to the sciences you refer to, consciousness does arise from the same things you describe as part of GR and QM.
- akomtu 3y agoAn electron may localise in any of the points as described by the wave equation, but it may also exist in its non local form. It may also transform into something else, like a photon, or vanish entirely by giving a bit of kinetic energy to a bigger object. The lowest common denominator isn't those localised particles, but the energy they are made of. There is really no reason why consciousness needs to be based on this particular level of abstraction that we call particles.
- amitkgupta84 3y agoIf our current scientific understanding of cosmology, quantum mechanics, biology, etc. doesn't fill you with awe and humility, I don't know what will. If it doesn't fill you with gratitude that we have even the slightest ability to exist, and to experience and understand any of this, I don't know what will.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]