4 ms·
Really sad actually. The only reason why Zynga bought them is because Draw Something is so high profile, that there was no way Zynga could steal it. As I said
by samstave 15y ago
Really sad actually.
The only reason why Zynga bought them is because Draw Something is so high profile, that there was no way Zynga could steal it.
As I said over on Quora, this really sucks as Zynga is a despicable company.
Surely, the folks at OMGPOP had been worried that Zynga would try to steal this game, as they have done every one else -- and I would be interested to know what they thought of Pincus' character prior to the purchase.
At least they get to stay in NYC and be no place close to Pincus.
- joejohnson 15y agoWhy do you think Zynga is a despicable company?
- fletchowns 15y agohttp://www.hnsearch.com/search#request/comments&q=zynga&sortby=points+desc http://www.hnsearch.com/search#request/comments&q=zynga&...
- ChrisNorstrom 15y agolol, because Zynga stole nearly all of their game ideas from other poeple. Graphics and all. http://www.businessinsider.com/how-zynga-is-just-like-microsoft-2010-1#before-zynga-came-out-with-mafia-wars-1 http://www.businessinsider.com/how-zynga-is-just-like-micros... Don't forget Tiny Tower http://www.forbes.com/sites/insertcoin/2012/01/25/everything-wrong-with-zynga-in-one-image/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/insertcoin/2012/01/25/everything... If Mark Pincus was more open about it and said "We're better marketers, business builders, and job creators than the original game creators. Yeah we copy their games, we might not be original and creative but we're a lot more valuable for the market, and for the consumer." we'd see Zynga in a different light. It's the fact that he's completely delusional about it. Here's a quote from Mark Pincus, "I am proud of the ethical and fair way that we've built this company.". That's what makes Zynga despicable. And Pincus a scary person. He's obviously an intelligent businessman but he's so caught up in his own bullshit that he actually believes it. That's what makes it frightening.
- the_mat 15y agoWell, let's be fair. OMGPOP is hardly a bastion of game design originality. For example, dinglepop is a 100% complete rip-off of Puzzle Bobble / Bust a Move, which Taito released in 1994. There have been countless clones since then, and there's nothing distinguishing dinglepop from any of them.
- joejohnson 15y agoI guess I heard about that Tiny Tower thing... my takeaway is that nearly everybody borrows ideas from one another. Ideas are cheap, it's the implementation that really matters. Zynga has the means to move on things faster than a lot of competitors. >>Here's a quote from Mark Pincus, "I am proud of the ethical and fair way that we've built this company.". That's what makes Zynga despicable. That Mark Pincus claims his company operates in a fair and ethical way (which you disagree with) makes Zynga despicable? I feel like the Zynga bashing is a product of the feedback loop that is tech news. Just a few years ago, Zynga was lauded as a great company, and Pincus as a great CEO: http://crunchies2010.techcrunch.com/ http://crunchies2010.techcrunch.com/ How quickly popular opinion can change. I wonder if a lot of the hate stems from Zynga's success in a space where many entrepreneurs had invested heavily and ultimately failed.
- ChrisNorstrom 15y agoThis isn't "borrowing". This is IP theft. And these aren't "ideas" these are full blown products. "Ideas are cheap, it's the implementation that really matters." The games that Zynga copies were not "ideas" they were IP. And Zynga wasn't inspired by them. Zynga flat out, straight up, cloned them. When you work your ass off, sacrifice time with your family, your savings, and invest it into building a profitable flash game online, iterating week after week until you get the formula just right. Only to have a bully come by and clone it. That my friend, is NOT borrowing. That's NOT implementing an idea differently. That is theft. Those are unfair business practices. People like me are angry at Pincus because his method, if it becomes popular, could completely fuck up the startup ecosystem. What if ALL of silicon valley starting acting like Pincus? Instead of acquiring sites and IP fairly, they simply cloned them. What if Google simply cloned YouTube div for div, color for color, feature for feature? What if Amazon cloned the technology used in Kiva's robotic logistics system instead of acquiring the company? What if Microsoft cloned skype and its algorithms instead of acquiring it? This isn't Github where you can fork someone else's work. These are companies that people put their lives and savings accounts into. Here's how it works: 1: Crazy young entrepreneurs risk everything to find a new profitable business or build a new product. Because they're small they can easily pivot and reiterate day after day and evolve their product/solution/business faster than a big company. 2: They find something that works, VCs jump on board to grow the business/product/service and the crazy young entrepreneurs who worked their asses off expand their business/service/product. 3: Big players like Microsoft, Apple, Google, Facebook, Amazon can use their muscle and dollars to acquire the startup and assimilate it into itself and offer this unique new service/business/product to their established customers. Thus benefiting the entrepreneurs who try new things, the investors who help grow new things, the big players with lots of established customers, and the end users. So many people benefit from this ecosystem. What Zynga does is dangerous. It basically gives the little guy the finger, steals their hard earned IP and doesn't give anything back. This is what makes it despicable. Most entrepreneurs keep their voice down about it because they don't want to look like angry disgruntled losers who are envious of a successful entrepreneur. But if you don't call it out and say anything about it and on top of that give Pincus a CEO of the year award... That hurts all of us. On top of all this, Zynga sees nothing wrong with what it does. Again, if they were open about the whole thing they'd be seen in a slightly better light. Still unethical copycats that hurt an ecosystem but at least honest about it. If they did the right thing and properly acquired the games they clone, we'd all be cheering Pincus on.
- danssig 15y agoDid you just discover the internet today? The list is endless. They hired people when they were small at lower wages with stock options. Then when they made it big they took those options away! The scumbag CEO claimed he was right because if he didn't do this a cook might become rich, as if a cook has no right to get FU money for taking a risk. Every game they have is a rip off of other people's. The CEO has said in interviews that he's done ever evil thing there is to do to gain success. If you don't think Zynga is a despicable company than I can't imagine you believe this is such a thing.
- furyofantares 15y agoI hate Zynga games because of how buggy and slow they are. But it's not like Zynga doesn't add value. The examples I've seen of Zynga copying the base of other games also have them making significant adaptations to better fit the market. Zynga really understands the market a lot better than many of the little guys, and they add lots of value to lots of users that way. I'm curious if there are counterexamples.
- bobbles 15y agoThis is really disappointing for me.. (well.. from a games on my phone perspective) I used to really like Words with Friends. Then zynga did an app update where the icon was more about the zynga logo than the Words with Friends logo. (reverted after user backlash) Then it was more and more 'buy our other games!' notifications. Then the facebook integration slowed the app down so much it took 3-4x as long to actually play the game. Yesterday I was saying to myself. Draw Something is so much better than Words with Friends, because it doesnt throw ANY of the zynga shit at me. Now I wake up and see this on HN... so upsetting.
- gurkendoktor 15y agoI actually found Draw Something to be pretty bad even before reading this. The whole game seems to be written in a too portable manner, ie., all UI elements self-written and noticeably different from UIKit, no GameCenter, the sizes are all weird... I hope somebody does the reverse thing of Zynga and builds a LIGHTER, Apple-like version of it, I'd jump ship in an instant. Especially after going through the painful WWF fiasco. It might even be possible to get an App Store spotlight by being more "loyal" to Apple's way of doing things, and obviously not being portable.