6 ms·
Csound is... "interesting" and not necessarily in the good way. If you want to play with something similar, but more modern, have a look at https://supercollide
by viraptor 3y ago
Csound is... "interesting" and not necessarily in the good way. If you want to play with something similar, but more modern, have a look at https://supercollider.github.io/ https://supercollider.github.io/ instead.
- AceJohnny2 3y agoSupercollider! Haven't heard that in a long time. This 2009 article on recreating the THX sound with Supercollider sticks with me: https://earslap.com/article/recreating-the-thx-deep-note.html https://earslap.com/article/recreating-the-thx-deep-note.htm...
- bmitc 3y agoHow would you say Supercollider is more modern? To my knowledge, the fidelity of the sounds you can get with Csound far exceed Supercollider. Also, Supercollider has a very restrictive license, preventing its use in basically anything besides small side and school projects, whereas Csound has a very permissive license. I have been doing a fair amount of research along these lines, and although Csound is definitely interesting in the sense of its syntax, it is, as far as I can tell, the most powerful programmatic sound system. Csound has introduced more real-time features, and you no longer have to rely on a score to make sound. For example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eacyGKRBpwA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eacyGKRBpwA
- spacechild1 3y ago> Also, Supercollider has a very restrictive license, What? SuperCollider is GPL, so it's 100% Free Software. > preventing its use in basically anything besides small side and school projects Typically, people use it to create music, so the restrictions of the GPL are no concern.
- bmitc 3y ago> > Also, Supercollider has a very restrictive license, > What? SuperCollider is GPL. Exactly. That is a restrictive license, and no one is going to use it (it being Supercollider) in anything resembling a commercial product. A lot of these programmatic audio systems make their way into things like installations and video games. Supercollider can't be used in commercial instances except when you're just releasing music.
- xcv123 3y ago> Exactly. That is a restrictive license, and no one is going to use it in anything resembling a commercial product. GPL software is used commercially. Have you heard of Linux?
- bmitc 3y agoIf you can convince Sony, Nintendo, Microsoft, or any of the game studios to release the code for their games or systems, just so that they can use Supercollider for an audio subsystem, go for it.
- pjmlp 3y agoIf you could convince Sony and Nintendo to upstream everything they customised from FreeBSD (Sony), and clang/LLVM (both), the upstream projects would appreciate, given how they lag behind in GNU/Linux adoption, and GCC in standards compliance and architectures.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- xcv123 3y agoWhy would they have to release everything else if the Supercollider server is running as a separate process? Just fork it on Github.
- bmitc 3y agoIf it's packaged with a game, even though it's running separately (is that even possible in a game console?), you would still have to distribute the binaries, would you not? And doesn't that break GPL?
- spacechild1 3y agoSuperCollider is targeted at composers/musicians/artists, not video game developers, so I don't see how that is relevant.
- viraptor 3y ago> How would you say Supercollider is more modern? Reasonable syntax, naming, errors, etc. Csound feels like programming assembler. Yeah, you can macro and it's powerful, but... it was far from fun for me.
- bmitc 3y agoYea, the Csound syntax does take some getting used to. But I just haven't found a demo of Supercollider that I feel sounds good. It all sounds pretty glitchy and digitally, for lack of a better word. But the interaction of Supercollider does seem nice. They're certainly both very cool, as well as their other brethren like Pure Data, Max, Audiomulch, Faust, ChucK, etc.
- viraptor 3y agoI'm not sure I understand. An oscillator in csound should sound the same as one in supercollider. The rest (what you build) is up to you. What do you mean by glitchy in this case?
- rollcat 3y agoI've never used either Csound or Supercollider extensively (more of a PD guy), but having tried to write a simple oscillator in pure C, even that turns out to be non-trivial. The naive approach of sin(t * pi2 * freq) produces pops when varying the frequency - you need to keep track of current phase. And from there it begins, the further you dig the more things you find you thought were trivial. I wouldn't be surprised if this or that synthesizer got something wrong.
- zebproj 3y agoIf you compare codebases, SuperCollider is definitely the more "modern" of the 2. SC is written in a reasonably modern version of C++, and over the years has gone through significant refactoring. Csound is mostly implemented in C, with some of the newer bits written in C++. Many parts of Csound have been virtually untouched since the 90s. Syntax-wise, Csound very closely resembles the MUSIC-N language used by early computer musicians in the 60s. "Trapped in Convert" by Richard Boulanger was written in Csound in 1979, and to this day is able to run on the latest version of Csound. Both Csound and SC are both very capable DSP engines, with a good core set of DSP algorithms. You can get a "good" sound out of both if you know what you are doing. I find people who are more CS-inclined tend to prefer SuperCollider over Csound because it's actually a programming language you can be expressive in. While there have been significant syntax improvements in Csound 6, I'd still call Csound a "text-based synthesizer" rather than a "programming language". That being said, I also think Csound lends itself to those who have more of a formal background in music. Making an instrument in an Orchestra is just like making a synthesizer patch, and creating events in a Csound score is just like composing notes for an instrument to play. FWIW, I've never managed to get SuperCollider to stick for me. The orchestra/score paradigm of Csound just seems to fit better with how I think about music. It's also easier to offline render WAV files in Csound, which was quite helpful for me.
- bmitc 3y agoI have programming experience, but that's actually why I prefer Csound. Since Csound's engine is effectively oriented around building up instruments in a modular way, I feel it can simply be wrapped up into more general purpose programming languages to get a language with the power of the more modular synth engine.
- braislen 3y agoNone of these languages have ever been on the level of Reaktor IMO and I started in csound quite awhile before Reaktor. You don't gain almost anything with these languages in their current forms because they end up not being much different than modular patch cord synthesis with a less intuitive interface. The amount and variety of interesting sounds I have heard from Reaktor is several orders of magnitude beyond csound to a degree it isn't even comparable. I might even rate these early versions of AudioLM as already more interesting than csound. The whole idea of music programming languages is a dead end IMO.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]