3 ms·
> The best thing Cycorp could do now is open source its accumulated database of logical relations... This is unpersuasive without laying out your assumptions a
by xpe 3y ago
> The best thing Cycorp could do now is open source its accumulated database of logical relations...
This is unpersuasive without laying out your assumptions and reasoning.
Counter points:
(a) It would be unethical for such a knowledge base to be put out in the open without considerable guardrails and appropriate licensing. The details matter.
(b) Cycorp gets some funding from the U.S. Government; this changes both the set of options available and the calculus of weighing them.
(c) Not all nations have equivalent values. Unless one is a moral relativist, these differences should not be deemed equivalent nor irrelevant. As such, despite the flaws of U.S. values and some horrific decision-making throughout history, there are known worse actors and states. Such parties would make worse use of an extensive human-curated knowledge base.
- skylyzz 3y agoAn older version of the database is already available for download, but that's not the approach you want for common sense anyway, no one needs to remember that a "dog is not a cat".
- xpe 3y agoYou are probably referring to OpenCyc. It provides much more value than your comment suggests. I'd recommend that more people take a look and compare its approach against others. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CycL https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CycL is compact and worth a read, especially the concept of "microtheories".