3 ms·
How exactly would you be able to "filter" LGBT content? I don't think you understand how this system would've worked.
by robertoandred 3y ago
How exactly would you be able to "filter" LGBT content? I don't think you understand how this system would've worked.
- olliej 3y agoHypothetically you have hashes for two people of gender X (lets be honest, based on popularity of different types of porn two men). This is not meaningfully different from opaque hash of "CSAM". But you're missing the point: Step 1. generate some opaque hash of the "semantics" of an image Step 2. compare those hashes to some list of hashes of "CSAM", which again fundamentally cannot be audited Step 3. report any hits to law enforcement Step 4. person X is being investigated due to reported violations of laws against child abuse. Basically: how do you design a system in which the state provides "semantic" hashes of "CSAM" that cannot be trivially abused by inclusion of non-CSAM as "CSAM", or by laws mandating inclusion of things that are objectively not-CSAM. Hypothetically: hashes that match christian crosses, star of David, muslim star and/or crescent, etc. Or in the US DNC, RNC, pride, etc flags. Recall that definitionally no one can audit the hashes that would trigger notifying law encforcement.
- robertoandred 3y agoExcept this system wouldn't have looked at "semantics". You can't simply match a hash of a cross or star or flag, you have to match a specific photograph. Which photograph do you use?