5 ms·
I'll just cherry pick this gem here: "What would happen if creators couldn’t charge for their creations? The same as if you couldn’t charge for lines of compute
by InclinedPlane 15y ago
I'll just cherry pick this gem here: "What would happen if creators couldn’t charge for their creations? The same as if you couldn’t charge for lines of computer code: there’d be less of it."
Spotted the massive, gaping flaw in the argument yet?
It's 2012, if you make this argument then I am done with you. Linux is how old? How much of the internet runs on it?
Done.
Edit: Wow, really? Why is this still a necessary argument?
The linux kernel is utterly free. Yet it's still developed. It's still a state of the art product. And people still make money off of linux and linux-based products.
Do I honestly have to connect the dots here?
Spoilers: if you can't or don't want to charge for the code directly then maybe you find some alternate way to charge for something else or you use another form of supporting development.
The analogy to the creation of music and movies should be so frelling obvious I shouldn't even need to make it.
- seunosewa 15y agoWhere would Linux be without Windows and Mac OS X to borrow ideas from?
- jjtheblunt 15y agoI'd argue Linux is an open source reimplementation of Solaris more than of OSX or Windows.
- steve-howard 15y agoMoreover, much as I love it, most free software usually has a huge gap in usability and QA, because those are the boring parts of writing software.
- tikhonj 15y agoProbably somewhere more efficient but with less useless (but admittedly cool looking :)) eye-candy. The main reason common distributions have features similar to Windows and OS X is to make transitioning easier. Really serious people using e.g. Arch with XMonad are more efficient with very little Windows/OS X influence. And hey, Linux could borrow those features even more easily if Windows or OS X were open source. Windows being open source would be complicated, but Apple is a hardware company and would work well enough with an open source OS at its heart.
- Androsynth 15y agoOn the other hand, how many iOS apps would there be if Apple wouldn't allow you to charge for them? It would still be an ok ecosystem, but not great like it is now.
- anonymoushn 15y agoCertainly people are certainly attracted to iOS dev because it produces money, but iOS users do not have to pay for apps. It is easy to get apps without paying for them, but Apple has made it very easy to pay for them. I doubt that the absence of copyright would significantly change the proportion of iOS users who use apps without paying for them.
- andylei 15y agoyou're totally missing the point. the question is whether the ability to charge money incentivizes programmers to produce code. androsynth argues that the app store shows that it does. there are hundreds if not thousands of apps that would not exist if all apps in the store had to be free.
- anonymoushn 15y agoThe OP strongly implies that "The presence of copyright" is the same as "The ability to charge money," and much of the discussion here also assumes that. It is simply not true, though. I would rather discuss what the OP is actually about than the thing that the OP would prefer to substitute for its subject matter to make its case seem better than it is.
- tadfisher 15y agoThat the majority of Linux contributions are made by employees of companies that sell Linux nullifies your argument. Take that away, and Linux would not be near the state it is in today.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- guard-of-terra 15y agoBecause they needed that code in the kernel. Now, there would always be people who want to have that music recorded, so it would still flow.
- alexgartrell 15y agoLinux is subsidized by large players who need an open platform on which to provide other services. This includes companies like Google who provide advertising based upon things that run on linux and companies like IBM who sell proprietary software that runs on Linux and support contracts for those products. There are very few viable, large-scale open source projects that are run on developer free time alone.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- angersock 15y agoTell that to the GCC folks, GIMP developers, Blender developers, Tremulous developers, Firefox developers, Mono developers, Rails developers, Python developers... (we all know GTK is a labor of love, 'cause you couldn't expect people to pay for it.)
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- zasz 15y agoCan you prove that those projects wouldn't be healthier if people were happy to pay money for them?
- kenmazy 15y agoCan you prove they would be? How many closed-source, for profit software projects were rescued after the supporting company went under? (I am intentionally conflating closed-source and for profit as the majority of financed projects are closed source). What you have to consider here is the rate of progress, as well as the length of development time. Open source projects have essentially infinite development time, whereas closed-source, for profit projects have a finite development time (whenever the company decides further development isn't worth it anymore)+. However, open source projects tend to have a slower rate of progress versus financed projects. After 6 months or 1 year, sure, the financed project will probably be ahead. How about the 5 year mark? 10 year? It becomes much less clear which project will have accumulated more man-hours. +very rarely, closed-source projects are released as open source (e.g. Doom 3), but I think we can all agree that that is the exception to the norm
- sheraz 15y agoYou cannot simply substitute software for music, literature, or film. It does not work that way.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- notJim 15y ago> How much of the internet runs on it? How many of the sites on the internet are open source though? A quick glance through the top 100 according to Alexa gives me 2 or 3 (wordpress and wikipedia, and really wordpress is more about the content, which is not open source, generally speaking.)
- guard-of-terra 15y agoSite on the internet is something like a live performance. You can't have copies of it because of its transient nature. Sometimes you do have a bootleg but your mileage may vary still.
- notJim 15y agoI mean the code. The argument was “there would be less code if you didn't have the right to own code”, and I'm saying that although the internet runs on open source software, the vast majority of popular internet sites run closed-source software.
- gnaritas 15y agoOn top on an infrastructue of open source software.
- ams6110 15y agoCode creators can charge for their creations, though. They don't have to, but they can. And some significant portion of open contributors are paid for their contributions, if indirectly, by working as employees of organizations that contribute to or allow employees to work on those open source projects. If nobody could get paid for writing code, there would be less of it. No question.
- tikhonj 15y agoYes, if nobody could get paid for writing code, there would probably be less of it. (Barring some sort of post-scarcity economy, I guess.) However, your original assumption does not flow from the premise--just because selling software becomes impossible does not mean programmers won't get paid. I recall reading somewhere (too lazy to find the source) that the majority of programmers work on bespoke, in-house software rather than consumer-facing proprietary software. Even if it is not a majority, it still shows that there are viable ways for programmers to get paid outside creating scarcity with copyright. Just because people contributing to the kernel get paid does not mean they would not get paid without copyright. Companies like Google and Red Hat do not really rely on copyright for money.
- kahirsch 15y agoHe said "there’d be less of it", not "there'd be none of it".
- VMG 15y agoOut of interest: are you in the software industry? How much of your work is open source?
- haberman 15y ago> Linux is how old? How much of the internet runs on it? Done. The argument is that there would be less computer code, not no computer code. Saying that one specific project would still exist is not a counterexample.
- Tloewald 15y agoAnd it's an argument, but it's not necessarily true. Consider the costs of production and distribution. Production. Frank McCourt's memoirs were the end result of a life of telling stories socially and on stage. People who heard him tell the stories would say "you should write a book". Today his listeners wold have videoed his performances with a camera phone, posted them on YouTube, and he would be a viral star before he knew it. Distribution. Suppose I have a head mounted camera that simply records everything I see — it's part of version 5 of the android glasses google is working on. Then along comes a third party and releases an app that simply recognizes anything I look at that's a printed page and captures it. If I read a book, I have an digital image of its pages and an OCRed text for indexing. The cooking smells analogy is actually more accurate than the writer realizes, because all this technology makes production easier too.
- zasz 15y agoOP said that there would be less of it, not that it would be nonexistent. Linux is probably an exception, and not the rule, and it is such an exception that large companies are willing to subsidize it. I've been looking for some good sound editing software, and the only solution I could find that was good at altering tempo without creating weird artifacts was closed-source and proprietary. I've also rarely played any open-source games that were as good as the closed-source ones. The point is, if someone does something that creates value, they should get compensated somehow. Asking musicians to produce music for nothing more than the sheer joy of it is exploiting them, and impolite, besides. If someone gives you value, you ought to give value back. I don't agree that the RIAA's way of getting back that value is correct, but that doesn't mean that copyright is a bad idea.
- InclinedPlane 15y agoApache, Wordpress, nginx, node.js, coffeescript, ruby, rails, python, django, chromium, firefox, webkit, drupal, varnish, memcached, 7zip, postgresql, mongodb, php, clang, wine, dosbox, vlc, virtualbox, truecrypt, calibre, audacity, openoffice, cygwin, flac, ogg, perl, synergy ...
- newsoundwave 15y agoI'm both enjoying and cringing at all of these HNers indicating that Linux is the only major exception they can think of(thus open/free source is obviously a novelty), when many of our livelihoods likely depend on these products.
- InclinedPlane 15y agoIt just feels like fighting the same battles from 15 years ago. How long will it take? Before people stop trotting out the argument that "you gotta charge for everything! otherwise how does stuff get made eh?" It's old guys. It's been debunked a billion times over. Open source ain't communism, nor is it doomed to failure. Even if you bind your hands to make it legally impossible for you to control the distribution of your work that doesn't mean that you can't make money off of it or that you must stop working.
- martey 15y agoReading the article now (15 minutes later), the objections seem to be addressed in the next sentence. Was the essay edited after publication because of InclinedPlane's comment? If so, I wish writers wouldn't make "phantom edits" that add or remove substantial content, as it makes it difficult to engage with their writing.
- vladd 15y agoNaming an example (Linux) doesn't contradict "there's be less of it".
- jfoutz 15y agoThat's right. Charging for software was microsoft's big invention. It took, what, 30 years to realize that the software had enough value beyond the hardware. I guess the flip side is, if there was no free software, there would be no pay software.
- sp332 15y agocouldn't charge for their creations but of course people do charge for open-source code to be made. IBM, RedHat, the US National Security Agency, Canonical, DARPA, Google, etc. all pay for open source code to be written. If the programmers weren't allowed to charge for their code, a lot less code would be written.
- davidw 15y ago> IBM, RedHat, the US National Security Agency, Canonical, DARPA, Google, etc. all pay for open source code to be written. IBM: sells tons of proprietary software. Redhat: genuine open source deal. Legit example. Government: money comes from taxes. I don't think I fancy a world where information goods are mostly paid for through taxes. Google: makes most of their money from the proprietary bits of their software.
- sp332 15y agoMy point isn't that IBM etc. make money from open-source software. My point is that they are all charged money by people writing open-source software.
- davidw 15y agoI don't think they're actually charged much - more that they employ some experts who work on the software. It's pretty difficult to charge for goods that are not scarce.
- sp332 15y agoI don't get the difference? The NSA hiring experts to work on SELinux extensions is the same as the NSA paying some experts for the SELinux extensions.
- davidw 15y agoThe scarce good in this case is the experts' time. In some cases, this works out well as a way to create open source software: if there's a big entity with lots of cash, who really needs that thing and can pay for it in its entirety. But what's being charged for is generally the developer's time, not the software. This is easy to see because, whereas the NSA may pay for SELinux, the next person down the line does not pay for it - they're getting it for free. This has important implications in terms of the ability to spread the costs around. With proprietary software, it's possible to do so: charge 100 people $10 instead of charging one person $500 and letting the other 99 people copy it for free. You make more money, and in some cases, the market will clear when it wouldn't for the single-payer model. I think this actually shows up fairly clearly in what's open source and what isn't: stuff that would be a one-off consulting job in any case may or may not be, stuff that's more consumer-oriented is more often proprietary, and stuff that's used by lots of developers as infrustructure is quite often open source.
- andylei 15y agoyou're logical reasoning is incredibly flawed. please stop arguing by way of pleading obviousness ("OMG ARE YOU SERIOUS, MY ARGUMENT IS SO OBVIOUS THAT I WONT EVEN MAKE IT!!!11") > What would happen if creators couldn’t charge for their creations ... there’d be less of it the claim here is that if you disallowed charging for software, there would be less software. > Linux is how old? How much of the internet runs on it? great, linux exists and is awesome. nobody disputes that. this fact does not contradict the claim in question. the existent / awesomeness of linux contradicts claims such as: "people who don't get paid will not create things" and "unpaid creators cannot create great things". however, the original claim is none of those statements. the original claim is merely that when you don't let people charge for software, fewer people will write it. > Do I honestly have to connect the dots here? i honestly have no idea what you think the connection between the dots is.
- leon_ 15y ago> Linux Only most lines of linux code are written by people who are paid for doing so. If it wasn't for companies that put money into linux development linux would be a lot less useful.
- gaius 15y agoIt's 2012, if you make this argument then I am done with you. Linux is how old? How much of the internet runs on it?\ I guess you don't know much about either Linux or business. Let me give you an example. Red Hat pays people to work on Linux, because that increases the market for people who will buy Linux support. IBM pays people to work on Linux, because that increases the market for people who will buy servers. Linux even only has a GUI because a bunch of old Unix companies sat down and formed the X consortium and paid people to write it, which they did because a common GUI would mean more software got written for Unix in general. So go and head and make your point but do it with a Linux made ONLY of hobbyist code. If you can even compile such a thing (don't forget Cygnus funded a lot of GCC development so they could sell embedded hardware!).