5 ms·
Regardless of what rules we choose, one thing I don't see here in the comments much is the practice of setting a good example for your kids. Kids can easily ide
by ryandrake 3y ago
Regardless of what rules we choose, one thing I don't see here in the comments much is the practice of setting a good example for your kids. Kids can easily identify hypocrisy. A parent can't tell their child to not get addicted to a smartphone if the parent himself is addicted to a smartphone. So as parents we set ground rules for our own conduct before even thinking about policy for the child: We should not sit there mindlessly scrolling, especially in front of the child. If we need to use the phone for some task, take it out, do the task, and show the child that you're using the smartphone as a tool to accomplish something, not for passive consumption.
If you limit your kid's screen time to some arbitrary amount that you yourself cannot even achieve, you're transparently sending the message that you're full of shit and kids know when you're full of shit.
- jonny_eh 3y agoOn top of that, if kids think you're a hypocrite, or even judgmental, they won't be transparent with you. They'll go behind your back and you'll lose the majority of your influence on them.
- apsurd 3y ago+1. "because I said so" and "when you're an adult..." are short-sighted non-fixes. I'm an uncle to a 5 and 7 year old. They call you on your bullshit all the time! And even as a non-parent I get that it's hard to always have to debate a 5 year old, but they DO recognize and intake consistency, even if they don't have the capacity to understand logic and rationality. yet. You gotta set a consistent and reputable example. Or else you're just making a human that understands power.
- gotoeleven 3y agoHow about "I'm already a mindless consumer drone addicted to tweet dopamine but it's not too late for you" ?
- steve_adams_86 3y agoThe honesty might have some value but ultimately I think it might not suffice
- floren 3y agoThis is something I think about a lot, whenever I'm holding my infant and trying to maneuver my phone into my other hand -- what behavior am I modeling? It's made me more cognizant of how I'll pull out the phone at any free moment, even just for 20 seconds, so I can occupy myself by opening the browser and seeing something, anything.
- waprin 3y agoI have a 2 year old daughter and even though I intuitively know it's important to set a good example, I've already been shocked to the extent this is true. My daughter loves grabbing our phones and watching whatever she can pull up on them, dialing people. If you take it away she gets upset. At first I was thinking, wow phones are very addictive on a primal level, she's addicted to just the flashy screens. I think the flashy screen being tempting might be a little true, but then I came to a different conclusion about why she was so fascinated with the phone. I noticed she also "changes" her stuffed animals diaper including pretending to apply rash cream, pretends to read books laying around she's seen me read, fidgets with the same household items she's seen me fidget with. That's when I realized what may be obvious to people experienced with kids - they constantly imitate the adults in their lives. So my daughter was probably obsessed with staring at a phone because she saw her parents obsessed with staring at their phones and wanted to imitate them. Of course this may be more relevant for very young kids moreso than teenagers, where the smart phone addictions work at a higher more cognitive level. But it did drill home the message that our children can be a reflection of ourselves so if you want to improve their lives, improve your own.
- killjoywashere 3y agoKids aren't addicted to the flashy screen first. The first order issue is they want to be like you. That want to be like you soooo much. With every fiber of their being.
- googlryas 3y agoNah, they're super enticed by it. For the first two years of my kids life, we had no screens in the house that he ever saw. We had old Nokia brick phones, no TV, and we only used a computer when he was sleeping. Regardless, the moment he saw an iPad in the library, he wanted to stare at it and fiddle with it for an hour. Even to the point of completing ignoring the model train set which he loves.
- aaomidi 3y agoYou’re describing the first time i saw a giraffe. Of course if anyone has never seen a screen like that, the second they see it they’re going to get fascinated by it.
- graemep 3y agoVery true. Be honest with your kids. Also, talk to them. Tell them what the dangers are, tell them what they need to talk to you about. I just had a conversation with my 15 year old about who she talks to online, how she decides what is trustworthy, the fact that conmen and paedos might play a long game etc.
- ddingus 3y agoI agree very strongly with this. Honesty with the kids and clear explanations and options are a big help. I did this once in the 90s with my first kids. I'm currently raising my granddaughter and it's a much different scene. So far I'm still figuring it out but I have a couple of tips I could share. One that seems to work the same is to make sure they've got options. Now what I mean by that is they need to be able to bring it to me rather than me find out about it or get it from them. So what i did, is make damn sure that when they bring something to me we talked through it work it out and it's going to be less painful, if it has to be painful at all, then it would be otherwise. So the incentive is clear take that shit to Papa let's find out what we have to do. Another one, that appears to be a little bit harder today is to give them safe computing options. One really easy example is typing a URL into a browser, rather than the address bar. There are many others, you get the idea. Local devices seem to complicate this, but in the 90s I made sure the internet facing computer gear wasn in common rooms. That way it was a family activity, and that was really good for building trust sharing experiences and all the other good things that need to happen to have a healthy dialogue between parents and child. I may have more to say on this later, but I'm off to read all the other great comments.
- ip26 3y agoThe good news, young parents, is you have a couple years to get it together. A infant wants to see your smiling face, but also won’t be scarred for life if you sometimes look away at a screen. Commit yourself to setting a good example, work on it, and know that while you will slip, you’ve also got time to improve. Some good steps are zero phones at family eating times, kid book time, and kid bed time. I personally also think it’s important you are visibly alone when you are on a screen, in other words don't let your kids see you ignoring another adult for the screen. Like a modern smoke break.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoI find my mobile capable Apple Watch to be useful for this. When I come home, I can put the phone on the ledge where I put keys and wallet, and still be reachable. Or when playing outside or going for a walk. No phone in pocket means it is harder to get distracted.
- wilgertvelinga 3y agoInteresting, I would assume a smartwatch on your wrist would make it way more easy to get distracted. But I've never worn a smartwatch so maybe I'm wrong.
- nraf 3y agoMy experience (as someone who spends too much time on my phone) is that a smartwatch helps avoiding me getting sucked in by my phone. It’s much less usable and I hate constant notifications on my wrist, so I’ll usually have it on mute and do a quick check at my notifications occasionally to see if there’s anything urgent (usually work or a message from my wife). I’ll mostly ignore my group chats on WhatsApp and emails, and there’s no risk of me getting sucked into group coversations with friends, YouTube or the Internet (I don’t have social media apps on my phone so that’s not too much of an issue), which is where the real time sink is for me.
- dboreham 3y agoConcur with parent post. I find the watch (Samsung here) to provide me with reassurance that servers aren't all down, CEO isn't sending bat signals, etc. I leave my phone in the cat when I go to dinner with wife and other attention-sensitive scenarios.
- ablyveiled 3y agoThis was the message I got with alcohol. Over a glass of wine, hey, don't drink, like ever. For what it's worth, I followed the advice.
- Sander3Utile 3y agoYes buts it’s inevitable that the child at some point will notice other adults/people who use the smartphone in that manner so the belief that it’s okay to passively consume will be reinforced no matter what the parents behavior is
- apsurd 3y agothat's a strange take to me, like why say it? the kid will spend 99% of their formidable time with the parents. sure, baby sitting, grand parents, and over time other external influences creep in, but why turn this into a "yes, but"? especially when these influences absolutely don't have equal weight.
- pseg134 3y agoIt’s his opinion because it excuses his own poor behavior. It’s impossible to get it perfect and everyone else does it so why would I even try?
- drt5b7j 3y agoMy rules is we don't touch our phones while our kid is awake. He's almost 2 now. I'm not sure when to change this, but it won't be any time soon.
- wisty 3y agoSetting a good example shouldn't be the only tool in the toolbox, and it's possible to not set a good example and still do OK, but it's probably the best single thing you can do.
- rakkhi 3y agoYeah... no one wants to hear that. Big point of fights between me and my wife: me using my phone. Alternative in my view is being bored, providing the opportunity to talk to her. I don't use it when we are at dinner or doing an activity. When she is doing something (more constructive eg dealing with our Airbnb) I'm tempted to use my phone. What do I do? Well this. Read HN, twitter (follow fantasy football, economics, politics). It's come to me even just wanting a bath each night after work because it is a guilt free 30-60 mins doing what I want on my phone. Kids policy: 2 aged 7 and 10 (I trying to see again via lawyers, another story). Policy for them was 1hr day on weekdays after homework, 2-4 hours on weekends. Usually they play Minecraft on their tablet. I think this is reasonable. What the hell do I know...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- alfor 3y agoYES! Exactly, the same for cocaine and meth! Seriously, adults have a hard time resisting, kids have zero chances. While we had the chance of growing up without this, they don’t. Our entire social fabric and kids developpement is gone. This summer there was very very few kids playing outside, even if my kids were out, there no one out there. It took us two years to realize that our front neighbor had two kids!
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Kids can easily identify hypocrisy. A parent can’t tell their child to not get addicted to a smartphone if the parent himself is addicted to a smartphone. You can’t tell people “don’t get addicted to X” (I mean, you can tell them anything, but telling people not to get addicted isn’t an effective measure to prevent addiction, generally, and hypocrisy isn’t the main reason.)
- YeBanKo 3y agoWe were sitting at the table, I was responding a work message on the phone. My son took a phone from my hands and put it aside, because I wasn’t paying attention. It happened more than once, during non-work hours and there was no urgency to respond tbh. Then when I had to take an ipad with cartoons he was watching away, I felt how hypocritical it was. I actually was glad he threw a tantrum, because had he been a little older and called out my hypocrisy, it would corner me.
- lll-o-lll 3y agoNah, that’s self-defeating bullshit. As parents we are flawed broken humans, just like all the other flawed broken humans. Just because a parent has a problem with alcohol, or excessive phone use, or any other vice, does not absolve them of setting reasonable restrictions for their children. Is it hypocrisy? Probably. Is it less effective than if the parent did not have said vice? Certainly. Is it better to set limits for your kid and explain why? Definitely.
- barelyauser 3y agoChildren learn by example. There are exceptions of course, and if you believe in exceptions rather than rules then go spend all your income in lottery tickets.
- lll-o-lll 3y agoOf course they learn by example, but show me the perfect parent? Do you want to doom your kids to all of your own failings? Kids also learn by seeing the flaws in their parents and having the parent explain how they got there and how not to repeat the mistakes. He who is without sin, let him cast the first stone.
- steve_adams_86 3y agoI love this. I believe it’s the only correct answer after reading and thinking hard about many. The ability for young children to recognize hypocrisy is incredible, and the aptitude among teenagers to leverage hypocrisy to enable their own bad behaviour and use yours against you isn’t something worth contending with. You can only win by force, and your kids will resent the hell out of you for it. And for what? To look at your phone more? Do any of us find ways to use our phones in worthwhile ways more than 15m in a day, truthfully? I sure as hell don’t. But I can sink a lot more time than that if I don’t think about what I’m doing.
- hunter-gatherer 3y agoThat's just it. I put my smart phone in the cupboard with my wallet and keys when I come home and don't touch it unless I have to. Sometimes I'll be in the middle of something with my kids and I tell them what I'm going to do, even though they are just 2 and 4, before doing it. Then I put it back as soon as I'm done. Just tonightz for example I needed it to doubke check a recipe. So I told them I was going to look at a recipe, checked it out, and then put it back in the cupboard. Having a designated place for your phone helps. Another thing I found to make phone use at home less appealing when I first wanted to get away from it was to have a personal rule that I always had to be stabding up in the corner. I don't allow myself to sit down with it, which actuality helps a lot.
- mikepurvis 3y agoKeeping it out of the bedroom is another good one— get an old school clock radio and leave the phone charging on the kitchen counter.
- steve_adams_86 3y agoI hadn’t heard of the designated location idea before. I like that, thanks. I might do the same and see if I can get my family to use the same spot.
- halper 3y agoWait, what? Absolutely! I speak with my friends on my phone. Sometimes I may speak and laugh for two hours with an old friend I, for family/life reasons, haven't seen for years but with whom I have this ability to instantly resume our customary banter. I read books on my phone. I do prefer a physical book but after I started a job where I travelled a lot I actually started buying the electronic versions, and once I got a phone with an OLED display it is quite okay to read on it in the dark. I read at least an hour a day. I think the "problem" is that any phone usage looks the same. If you are sitting with your calculus book you look "usefully busy", but not if you're studying on your phone. If I read a thick novel I look serious and smart, but with the book on the phone I look like I'm scrolling on Facebook or whatever people use nowadays. If I watch a lecture on computer science I appear the same as if watching anything else. Is "phone" itself bad, or is it just that it looks the same as if one is being "lazy"?
- mixmastamyk 3y agoWhat makes you think I don't have "screen time" on myself and wifi scheduled at the router already? And why is this antagonizing "full of shit" comment at the top of an important post?
- corethree 3y agoThis is true. But if everyone else in the world is using smart phones and you and your kid are the only people in the world NOT using smart phones... your kid will still think you're full of shit. Clearly.
- aconsult1 3y agoI've been following this "good example" for both my kids who are 10 and 2 years old and I can say it works very well. At least for the addictive behavior. We still allow them to watch movies and cartoons plus games in TVs and iPads but no phones for them. My wife and I have a policy that when we're eating no screens are allowed unless it's an emergency. I think this probably has the biggest effect of all. Also we have zero social networks (except professional ones). I'm so tired of going to restaurants and seeing the entire family looking at their screens. The bigger the kid the bigger the screen. Technology really has killed social interaction and I try my best to raise my kids out of this mass hypnosis everybody seems to be in. When we go out to eat my table is always kind of a mess because my two year old is all over the place. And that's fine. We can deal with it and we have some fun. I really don't buy he argument to giving kids a screen during meals so the adults can talk. Kids must engage in any conversation they want or simply sit and listen to adults talking. That's how they learn. If they're constantly zooming out then they won't learn how to behave properly. I find it too convenient that adults who never had problems with this kind of addiction (because those devices did not exist) continue to feed their kids with algorithms. Once my kids get to an age that they are more responsible I'll handle them a device and set boundaries. Since we (the adults) have been showing boundaries since the beginning I think it will work just fine. So yeah, lead by example!