6 ms·
yes, just like the communists. the state can seize anything with no compensation. private property assurances were masqueraded as a distinctive tenet between th
by yieldcrv 3y ago
yes, just like the communists. the state can seize anything with no compensation. private property assurances were masqueraded as a distinctive tenet between the systems but they’ve both converged on a discretionary ownership reality.
- danbruc 3y agoCommunists at least seize stuff with good intentions.
- kbenson 3y agoThe reasons communism allows seizure of property are with good intentions, just as the reasons the law allows the seizure of property in this case are because of good intentions. How it's used and abused in practice in both systems is the important part. I'm not sure either system necessarily has a great track record in that respect.
- pstuart 3y agoSorry, but the intentions behind these seizures are in no way benign. Maybe in the original intentions of the law, but the police are there to shake people down. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rJd4Q4u5cqU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rJd4Q4u5cqU Reminder: this is yet another piece of evidence that The War on Drugs™ does not serve us well in any way, shape, or form.
- kbenson 3y ago> Maybe in the original intentions of the law Yes, that is exactly what I said. I'm not sure how to read it otherwise. If you're going to assess how it works under communism by looking at why the government allows and and what their goal is, it only makes sense to assess other systems the same way, which is why I said "the reasons the law allows..."
- danbruc 3y agoFair point. I should have been more precise, I was actually thinking of »hypothetical, never actually realized, potentially impossible to realize true platonic communists« and not of some Soviet era communists or something like that.
- at_a_remove 3y agoPerhaps they can seize this pile of cobblestones I have, in case they need to pave a road to somewhere warm.
- enterprise_cog 3y agoIt is a bit bizarre to read about a system of exploitation that has flourished under a capitalist police state and then mention communists.
- kbenson 3y agoEh, I'm not really pro communism, but it makes sense to me. If one of the central differences people focus on between the systems is private property, if someone sees that as somewhat of an illusion it makes sense to note it.
- wahnfrieden 3y agoPrivate property != personal property Means of production is not the same as the shoes on your feet. It's just unfortunately confusing terminology that leads to twisted argumentation. Btw, the alternative to capitalist liberal states is not exclusively authoritarian marxist-leninist communism. Not all anti-capitalists are pining for another different boot to lick.
- Retric 3y agoA tool (boot, glove, knife, hammer, etc) is easily both the means of production and personal property. The distinction is in effect meaningless.
- enterprise_cog 3y agoA hammer isn’t a factory. There is a distinction, unless you don’t think industrialization had any effect on society.
- Retric 3y agoThe rhetoric around the means of production was initially in reference to slaves. Communism was an offshoot of the abolition movement not in reference to at the time minimal number of factories. And in that context people did abandon slavery. Even today factories aren’t the means of production, they don’t make houses that’s mostly people with hand tools. Nor do they make food or mine resources etc.
- gtowey 3y agoIt's not communism, it's a new form of feudalism.