3 ms·
What is this American moral universalism? Why would “we combat” or “take down” MBS? What the f—k business do we have weighing in on Saudi society? Also, do you
by rayiner 3y ago
What is this American moral universalism? Why would “we combat” or “take down” MBS? What the f—k business do we have weighing in on Saudi society? Also, do you know who is waiting in the wings behind MBS? It’s not anyone western liberals are going to like.
And I’m not defending MBS—but the reason I dislike Saudi is that they do the exact same moral universalism to the rest of the Muslim world, exporting Wahhabism to moderate Muslim countries. I see no reason for the US to get into Crusades 2.0.
- dddssddd 3y agoyou can't defend something grotesque then say i'm not defending him and be wiped clean of your previous gross comment.
- rayiner 3y agoI don’t subscribe to the George W. Bush idea of “you’re with us or against us.” Saying that it’s not the role of US billionaires and corporations to weigh in about the affairs of sovereign foreign countries is not a defense of what’s happening in those foreign countries. It’s about people staying in their lane.
- mthoms 3y agoThe op was asking what we, as individuals, could do. You argued (very poorly) that we shouldn't do anything simply because it's none of our businesses. When pressed on that (here and elsewhere in this thread) you keep pivoting to talk about what the US government, billionaires and corporations should or shouldn't do. But that wasn't the question asked. I can only assume you keep pivoting to that angle because those are easier arguments to make and involve considerably less self-reflection.
- rayiner 3y agoIn pivoting to that angle because the article criticizes billionaire that owns a major media platform for not leveraging that power to criticize a sovereign country’s domestic laws.
- mthoms 3y agoMaybe start your own top level comment thread if you want to talk about that; You specifically replied to a person asking what they can do about it as an individual. Peacefully. You told them that it wasn’t their place to do anything. When asked to justify your position you invoked “Crusades 2.0” and George Bush. You’re being blatantly disingenuous.
- rayiner 3y agoYou think individual citizens failing to mind their own business don’t fuel America’ “democracy and liberation” wars? Along with immoral and destructive economic sanctions on countries like Iran? And OP’s use of “we” and “taking down MBS” aren’t consistent with your characterization.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dctoedt 3y agoWhat's with this seeming worship of sovereignty? "Sovereignty" is simply a pretty word for "collective might makes right."
- rayiner 3y agoSovereignty is the recognition that the basic unit of the international order is the nation, not the individual. Recognizing sovereignty as the highest principle is also necessary for pluralism to work. If western nations think that individual “rights” in other countries is their business, then their infringement on the internal affairs of other nations—with violence—will continue unabated.
- mthoms 3y ago>What is this American moral universalism? Believing you shouldn't be brutally murdered for criticizing your government is not an American thing. >What the f—k business do we have weighing in on Saudi society? Some people believe basic human rights ought to be universal. Strange, I know. >I see no reason for the US to get into Crusades 2.0. Absolutely no one is suggesting that.
- rayiner 3y ago[flagged]
- mikeyouse 3y agoSurely you’re not justifying multi-decade sentences for insults? Or execution for retweets? I don’t think opposing those things falls into the category of “white people” human rights…
- rayiner 3y agoCan I defended it personally? No. But I was raised in Virginia and won’t even concede the federalists were right. However, it’s none of my business how Saudi society is structured. Nobody came from the outside and imposed that monarchy on them. The country is a closely knit collection of families with a vast imported non-citizen workforce. We can’t conceive of how their society works. “Human rights” in general arises from a conception of the worth of the individual relative to the collective that’s distinctly rooted in European culture. And even within that culture it’s a relatively recent development. European countries prosecuted such crimes well into the late 1800s, although usually not with the death penalty. (But Islam is also much more accepting of the death penalty.)
- mthoms 3y agoYou acknowledge that the practice is morally indefensible but at the same time you're actively trying to convince others they shouldn't care. What a truly baffling (and concerning) serious of comments.
- spookie 3y agoOP says that "combating" while living abroad is useless, it's arguing in favour of something else. It also points out how hypocritical it is to trade with those who don't uphold democratic values. If you want to be beheaded by stating your opinions online, be my guest. But, personally, I would trust my country more, if it didn't aid financially those who bring terror upon their people. It's easier to trust it that way. Public beheadings are acts of propaganda and to instill fear among the population. They only serve that purpose.