4 ms·
Quite a lot of mildly dangerous things are up to the discretion of the seller. Bartenders cutting people off is one well known example. It’s not necessarily a
by Retric 3y ago
Quite a lot of mildly dangerous things are up to the discretion of the seller.
Bartenders cutting people off is one well known example. It’s not necessarily a legal requirement, but sellers can have morals just like anyone else.
- RandomLensman 3y agoOf course, but then that includes the decision that the danger is low or acceptable for that kind of approach. That decision isn't usually up to the vendor, though.
- velosol 3y agoIt's not always a legal requirement but sometimes it is: https://nccriminallaw.sog.unc.edu/bartenders-duty-cut-off-service-intoxicated-patrons/ https://nccriminallaw.sog.unc.edu/bartenders-duty-cut-off-se...
- 0xcde4c3db 3y agoI have no special expertise in the area, but my understanding is that while it's not generally a crime to serve alcohol to someone who's clearly had too much, it can be grounds for suspending or revoking an establishment's liquor license in many jurisdictions (under e.g. a rule requiring that they "exercise reasonable care" to serve alcohol safely).
- hollerith 3y agoNot to mention the risk of getting sued.
- iso1631 3y agoIn my jurisdiction it's illegal to serve alcohol to someone who is drunk, or to serve alcohol to someone if you know they are going to give it to someone under 18. However if I as a 50 year old, go and buy alcohol from the store, the store has no right to get me to sign a civil contract saying I can't give that win to my 15 year old son, something that's perfectly legal where I live. Nor can they get me to sign a civil contract saying I wont give it to my 3 year old son, something which is not legal in my area.
- jzb 3y ago"the store has no right to get me to sign a civil contract saying I can't give that win to my 15 year old son" It doesn't? What prohibits that? Is there a law that requires liquor stores to sell to you if you're 21 years or older? I'd be curious to know what law or regulation compels a store to sell to you without adding conditions. It might be a bad business practice, but what would actually stop me from requiring customers to sign a document that says a customer won't provide alcohol to an under aged drinker.
- pixl97 3y ago>he store has no right to get me to sign a civil contract saying I can't give that win to my 15 year old so Now, I'm not exactly sure what country you are in, but in the US they 100% do have that legal right. Conversely you have the legal right to visit another store that does not enforce that civil contract. At least for US civil law, you seem to have no clue how it actually works.
- iso1631 3y agoIn my jurisdiction it would be an unenforceable clause due to the a variety of laws protecting consumers from unfair contract terms
- jnwatson 3y agoIt is actually a crime in most US jurisdictions and can lead to suspension of liquor license.