5 ms·
Amateur astronomers spot new impact on Jupiter
- belter 3y agohttps://twitter.com/MASA_06R/status/1696613936534360293?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw%7Ctwcamp%5Etweetembed%7Ctwterm%5E1696613936534360293%7Ctwgr%5E96d0ca585434e44afa00e7f0703bdc80b536113a%7Ctwcon%5Es1_&ref_url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.space.com%2Famateur-astronomers-jupiter-cosmic-collision https://twitter.com/MASA_06R/status/1696613936534360293?ref_...
- tetris11 3y agoIf you can, you should: https://nitter.net/MASA_06R/status/1696613936534360293 https://nitter.net/MASA_06R/status/1696613936534360293
- dredmorbius 3y agoLooks to me as if the shockwave from the impact may be visible as well, briefly spreading outwards.
- pohl 3y agoWould there be any interesting science to be had if we sent something to orbit Jupiter that could wait for, detect, and get us closer readings/views of such impacts?
- stouset 3y agoI’m sure there would be some but of course those resources are an opportunity cost for potentially more-valuable science performed elsewhere.
- trilbyglens 3y agoThis is totally going to be my old man hobby.
- dylan604 3y agoIt's sad it has to be this way. I have a telescope with a smaller telescope for tracking. I have the motorized equatorial mount. I have the gear to connect the mount and smaller scope with a camera to my laptop. I have the software to control them for precise tracking. I have the camera to attach to the main telescope. I have the stacking software. I don't have the luck of being free when the seeing is great, and have the unfortunate luck of always being available when the seeing is for shite. Edit: my "old man" plans are to buy some property well outside of light pollution. that way i can just do my hobby any night there's clear skies Edit2: there's a site in New Mexico[0] where a group has purchased some land strategically where they are at a bit of altitude, and have more nights than not of clear skies. They've it up so that you can CoLo your astro gear there, and they provided a remote connection so you can do everything remotely. For a small nominal monthly fee of course. This is my "pre-old man" plan B to research, but I feel my stuff my be too amateurish for this [0]https://nmskies.com/newmexicosite.html https://nmskies.com/newmexicosite.html
- jebarker 3y agoA good place to consider for your property purchase is the area around Crestone, CO. It was recently designated a Dark Sky Sanctuary. It's near some great hiking, Sand Dunes National Park and good skiing. Also, it has the only legal funeral pyre in the USA. [1] As for the remote sites in New Mexico, I've looked into renting telescope time or remotely locating my astrophotography gear but I just feel like I'd be losing something from the hobby if it didn't require me to be hands on with the gear and outside. [1] https://crestoneendoflifeproject.org/services/open-air-cremation-site/ https://crestoneendoflifeproject.org/services/open-air-crema...
- dylan604 3y agoThere's a group about 4 hours from Dallas called 3 Rivers Foundation (www.3rf.org) that has been buying up land in the county. The last time I was there, they were trying to get their campus (700+ acres at that time) designated as a dark sky location too. They are also attempting to increase their acreage to help keep it that way. There's a state park Copper Breaks that has the darkest skies of any state park (caveat being Big Bend is a national park) in the same area. >I just feel like I'd be losing something Spend enough cold nights outside, and you'll get really fuzzy to the remote concept! There have been nights where it was so cold, that once the rig was running, everyone just hangs out inside where it's warm with a periodic jaunts outside just to check on things. Edit: I had to look up some details. At one of the post facilities I once worked, I met John Davis of Jimmy Neutron fame. He's a big astrophotography buff as well. While we were in the color session waiting for some renders to finish, he showed me his remote setup. He can log in and view some cameras to ensure it is safe to open up for observing. He can tell it what to observe in a set it and forget it manner. At the end, it is scripted to process the images and email it to him for review. That's exactly how I'd spend my Hollywood earnings too if I ever had any. I can't remember if he was the person I learned about 3rf from or if it was another client. But yeah, it's a pick your mouth up from the floor and wipe the drool off your face before you look like a fool. He said that's not the first time it's happened to him. Very cool cat.
- BiteCode_dev 3y agoI'm stunned that there is a not a constant recording of those bodies, with some image analysis to detect anomalies like this, done by some university.
- dylan604 3y agoThe sky is big. Every telescope that can be used is looking at something.
- dredmorbius 3y agoThe planets, save Earth, number only seven. And Jupiter is the most likely of them to see impacts. If nothing else, this would help give us a baseline for frequency.
- dylan604 3y agoso you're saying we're not allowed to look at the rest of the universe so that we can solely focus on the low frequency of times an object collides with Jupiter? that seems like not a good use of all of the observation ability we have
- Auracle 3y agoNo, he’s saying one singular (small) telescope could be pointed at Jupiter at all times. Not every telescope everywhere at once.
- dredmorbius 3y agoThe Search for Terrestrial Intelligence scores a positive signal. Adding one further factor to your list: there's all but certainly a direct correlation between major Jupiter strikes and Earth strikes. Refining estimates of the former will help in establishing values of the latter. Though existing known power-law relations of meteor(ite) impacts on Earth of size vs. time are fairly well established as well, I suppose.
- thetomcraig 3y agoIt’s amazing that amateur folks can provide this much insight these days. I worked at JPL 10 years ago and setup a pipeline for amateur Jupiter astronomers to get their images to JPL/NASA. Basically JPL figured out that these people were consistently producing such high quality data, that NASA could take advantage of it for the Juno mission. Glad to see this in the news :).
- dylan604 3y agoIt makes sense seeing that NASA/JPL only have so many instruments pointing at Jupiter at any time. That number is dwarfed by the number of amateurs looking at it on any night. It also helps that it's one of the easiest things to view.
- beebeepka 3y agoWhat does one need to look at Jupiter, visible light or not? And how much would it cost to have a setup that I can feed some sky coordinates and enjoy the feed/s on a screen. Any useful software that also happens to be free and/or open source? I just realized I don't know anything about this fascinating stuff
- dylan604 3y agoThere's lots of really good options available now at some very affordable prices. There's quite a few reflectors in the 6"-8" size that are very small and easy to set up. Because the planets are so much brighter, especially the moon, than deep sky objects, all of the tracking and image stacking software is not necessary to start. There are scopes now that come with a mobile app and a built in camera. Because I don't have hands on experience with anything other than my gear, I can't really recommend specific models. Celestron would be a good safe starting point. The magazine/sites from places like Sky&Telescope or BBC Sky at Night, will publish reviews of new gear ranging from "baby's first scope" to as much money as you have. https://skyandtelescope.org/ https://skyandtelescope.org/ https://www.skyatnightmagazine.com/ https://www.skyatnightmagazine.com/
- JacobAldridge 3y agoI was only 12 when Shoemaker-Levy banged into Jupiter in 1994, so wiser minds or those with better memories may correct me. At the time, the leading theory for what killed the dinosaurs was still quite terrestrial - volcanos and climate change. There was increasing evidence for the meteorite impact theory, but a big block was “Space is big, outside the early formation of the Solar System comets and asteroids don’t just slam into planets”. Then comet Shoemaker-Levy showed us that they actually do, perhaps still quite frequently, with Jupiter playing an imperfect shield for Earth. It was one of the last roadblocks to the now-widely accepted impact theory (still not ‘solved’ of course, and perhaps only part of the extinction puzzle). Dinosaurs were back in the zeitgeist thanks to Jurassic Park (1993), but Shoemaker-Levy and the impact theory gave us the 1998 twin movies Armageddon and (the better of the two, imho) Deep Impact.
- dylan604 3y agoWas that really the leading theory you were taught? If you were 12, I'm <10 years older, and even then I distinctly remember the asteroid theory being taught as what wiped out the dinosaurs. Climate change is kind of given after that, but the asteroid was taught as the cause. There's been a few "big one" theories I've heard about. The impending California earthquake is a popular one, but I'm familiar with super volcanoes and asteroids too from childhood.
- davesque 3y agoYeah, I remember the same. I was 13 in 1994 and I remember the impact theory being taught as the cause well before the Shoemaker-Levy impact.
- labster 3y agoMy experience as well. Sometimes education can lag well beyond scientific theory. The Scopes Monkey Trial happened in 1925, and evolution still isn’t being taught in many American schools.
- scns 3y ago
- jebarker 3y agoIt seems fairly frequent that amateurs observe large impacts on Jupiter. Presumably they would be devastating impacts if they hit Earth. Is the reason we don't get them frequently on Earth because of the size difference (11X smaller than Jupiter) or we're somehow protected by location?
- Waterluvian 3y agoThe answer is in the sub-headline: “This gas giant regularly absorbs hits from comets and asteroids, protecting inner solar system worlds.” It’s a really cool concept, though it’s not settled science: https://earthsky.org/space/is-it-true-that-jupiter-protects-earth/ https://earthsky.org/space/is-it-true-that-jupiter-protects-... It’s interesting to consider that a Kepler planet may also require larger mass planets further out to perform a similar role.
- sillysaurusx 3y agoI once heard that Jupiter protects us because it’s so massive that it catches rocks that would otherwise come towards us. No idea if that’s true, but it makes for a nice story about the silent gassy protector.
- ehvatum 3y agoJupiter has a lot of magnetism and the baroque clockwork ballet of its moons in the solar wind and on its stormy poles never fail to sing their eternal opera. My grandfather, Hein Hvatum, thought this might be the case and happened to be the first to point a radio telescope at Jupiter and write a paper about it.
- zmmmmm 3y agothat was the most interesting part in the last paragraph to me: > The gas giant is considered to play a big role in protecting the inner solar system from asteroids and comets by attracting and absorbing impacts or flinging potentially dangerous objects further out into the solar system It's fascinating to think how many factors have come together to make life on earth so particularly viable. Even with this "protection" we've had major catastrophic events that nearly wiped out all advanced forms of life.
- ThinkingGuy 3y agoIs it reasonable to assume that Jupiter, being the largest body in the solar system besides the sun, can be expected to have the most frequent impacts, if only due to the laws of gravity?
- Keyframe 3y agoyeah, it's a vacuum cleaner
- LeonB 3y agoThe widely believed claim, repeated in the first paragraph— that the gas giants are “protecting inner solar system worlds” is not necessarily true. Though heavier planets are more likely to be hit they also serve to attract more matter into the region — some of which hits other planets. Some well regarded models show that it’s approximately break-even… the losses and the wins cancel each other out. And in some runs of the simulation, if we’re unlucky, the losses greatly outweigh the wins. I provide no reference to these claims, as I’m typing this from memory, with patchy internet, and leave it to y’all.
- ljlolel 3y agoYes this makes more sense to me. Jupiter would only intervene with a small number of impacts. The rest of the time it’s gravity well would redirect matter from a far-off-course trajectory to one closer to Jupiter and maybe us too
- AndrewVos 3y agoDoes anyone know how large this object was? Doesn’t seem to be mentioned anywhere.