4 ms·
I had to follow back to the submitted article's author's earlier blog posts, a couple of degrees of linking back, to figure out where the "log-plot of the wings
by tokenadult 15y ago
I had to follow back to the submitted article's author's earlier blog posts, a couple of degrees of linking back, to figure out where the "log-plot of the wingspan vs. mass for different birds along with the human with wings" came from. It came from the author himself, without a validation study, and "anyone can edit" Wikipedia. People who know their history of physics well will remember that Galileo showed that in general, as an animal's size scales up, its mass increases with the cube (third power) of the scale factor while its surface area increases only with the square (second power) of the scale factor.
http://dinosaurtheory.com/scaling.html http://dinosaurtheory.com/scaling.html
http://galileo.phys.virginia.edu/classes/609.ral5q.fall04/LecturePDF/L14-GALILEOSCALING.pdf http://galileo.phys.virginia.edu/classes/609.ral5q.fall04/Le...
To scale up flight by arm motion to the mass of a human adult would have to result in a very different wing loading from that of any bird. There is a lot of hand-waving about electric motor power (at what weight?) for the wings in the video being discussed here on HN, but no verifiable figures about what energy is input into the wings versus what weight the total assemblage has.
As astute comments pointed out in the earlier main thread about the video, it would be easy enough to verify this extraordinary claim just by letting some professional journalists take a look at the rig and weigh it and photograph it up close and do their own videography of a set of flights of the rig and its operator. There is no reason to take an amateur, self-produced video with unverified claims seriously about an issue that is so contrary to well studied principles of aeronautics. Until there is better quality evidence, there is no warrant for believing this extraordinary claim.
- kinship 15y agoAnd in my oPinion, looks like a hangglider could do that no prOblem. Calm down troll.
- angersock 15y agoThe electric motors--if using the heavy-duty outrunners mentioned in the last thread--are on the order of 2-4 kg each, for a total of about 10 lbs. The weight of the fabric/kite is on the order of 1kg (http://www.humanbirdwings.net/about/working-on-the-wings/ http://www.humanbirdwings.net/about/working-on-the-wings/). The batteries appear to be lightweight li-poly packs, so really powerful for very light weight.