7 ms·
An introduction to the impact of native planting
- pamelafox 3y agoI love porting my garden to native plants and just found out it'll be featured in next year's natives garden tour next year: https://www.bringingbackthenatives.net/ https://www.bringingbackthenatives.net/ If you're in bay area, it's a great way to get ideas for native gardens. It is so fun to watch the pollinators flock to our flowers. Plant native!
- AlbertCory 3y agoThis is a Bay Area thing, and I have no idea if there's such an arg in your area, but: https://www.cnps.org/ https://www.cnps.org/ They did have twice-a-year sales, although I can't really tell from this site if they still do.
- NotMichaelBay 3y agoHere's a list of Native Plant Societies for US & Canada: https://nanps.org/native-plant-societies/ https://nanps.org/native-plant-societies/
- gandalfgreybeer 3y agoTangentially related. there’s a forest in the Philippines that is hectares of land where only a single species of non-native tree was planted [1]. Go there and you won’t hear any birds or wildlife. It’s spooky. It’s partially because the birds avoid it since they’re not familiar with it and even the insects that they might eat don’t like the tree so they all avoid it. 1. https://iamtravelinglight.com/2012/10/09/the-dark-side-of-bohols-bilar-manmade-forest-an-appeal-to-people-planting-trees/ https://iamtravelinglight.com/2012/10/09/the-dark-side-of-bo...
- smallerfish 3y agoThat may be as much about it being a monoculture of giant trees that don't have particularly interesting fruit for wildlife. Plant a monoculture of non-native trees with attractive fruit and you'll get a ton of opportunistic wildlife. Plant a mixed forest of non-native trees with a variety of fruit and habitats and you'll get a lot more wildlife. Of course in areas that have badly depleted ecologies in the first place, planting native will be most likely to provide niches to the wildlife that is around, and the article is generally great advice. But it's too easy to forget that over time the ranges of species spreads significantly via seed dispersal (which can mean jumps of hundreds or even thousands of miles via the guts of birds). "Native" for the US very specifically means "existed when western european settlers arrived and cataloged the local fauna".
- melagonster 3y agomaybethis also means that "last time when ecosystem looks good"
- CoastalCoder 3y agoIs it just me, or does that page have an overlay that makes it look like your phone's screen protector has cracked?
- actionfromafar 3y agoI wish it wouldn’t scroll :-)
- elihu 3y agoI'm not using a phone, but my first reaction was to lean closer and see if I had a hair stuck to my monitor.
- Lutger 3y agoThe concept of native plants is both highly important and deeply problematic. It is much more convoluted than how it is explained in the article. Once you start digging into it, you find out there isn't actually a sound definition and it is rather arbitrary, maybe emotional even. Some species who are introduced are, at first, considered exotic and often cause problems at the time of introduction. The successful ones are often called invasive (mostly pioneers in their native habitat). After a while, when attempts at eradication have become futile, we start to tolerate and merely try to control them a bit. This can take a long time. Then, something magical happens and suddenly we begin to consider them native plants. When, due to changing habitats, their numbers dwindle we sometimes start to care for them or even protect them. This happened with the sparrow in the Netherlands for example, which was a real pest when first introduced. The most commonly cited benefit for native plants (and wildlife) is their co-evolution with other species. This makes them very beneficial to the ecosystem as sometimes hundreds of species rely on them as a source of food. It turns out that this process of co-evolution is happening a lot faster than people generally assume, and a vast array of plants that were brought from and to Europe some 200 to 400 years ago are now completely adapted. Ironically, they sometimes harbor even more relations with wildlife than the plants that have occurred in the same habitat before them, but are still considered non-native and even invasive. I'd like to think of the concept of 'native' as (at its best) an indirect indicator for 'co-evolved' or 'adapted' species, signifying its harmonious place in the ecosystem. A good yet often flawed rule of thumb in the absence of actual knowledge. However, I can't help but think when people use the word that it is also something very cultural, something people just take for granted because someone once drew a line in the sand (time of the settlers) and after that line every newly introduced species is considered non-native. It is interesting to look more closely at this cultural construct of nativity, as it can hide a palette of more substantial values behind a thin facade of ecological benefits. Something like what people mean when they use the word tradition.
- totetsu 3y agoThis was a big rearrangement i had to make in my thinking when I first moved overseas from an island with highly isolated evolution, where "native plant" was very easy to understand.
- 3y ago
- planting-life 3y agoI always love seeing native gardening get attention in non-gardening communities. After reading Tallamy's books last year, my wife and I were surprised at just how much effort is involved in planning a native garden. Although not the point of their post, the authors section about getting started highlights this. I've been building https://planting.life https://planting.life to try to reduce this friction. It helps discover native plants by US zip code and shade/moisture conditions, along with planning and sharing gardens.
- TradingPlaces 3y agoIf you are in the LA area, this is a nonprofit nursery that only sells California natives. https://theodorepayne.org/plants-and-seeds/nursery/retail-nursery/ https://theodorepayne.org/plants-and-seeds/nursery/retail-nu...
- rywalker 3y agoI've got 60-acres in Ohio and we've got a land management plan to remove the invasive honeysuckle and tree of heaven – and take care of the sycamores, maples, buckeyes, walnuts, and oaks. It's a fascinatingly deep area to dive into!
- pragma_x 3y agoI'm all for it. But there are some practical hurdles to overcome to being successful at changing how you garden or cultivate the land. I've only just started looking into this, and I've already hit some trouble. Where I live, the most abundant non-native plants are suburban lawns. If you're taking this fight home, please familiarize yourself with your HOA bylaws (if you have one). You may be surprised at what qualifies as a "garden", and what you must cultivate in terms of a "lawn". There are practical limits, but there are also workarounds. The second biggest problem I face is that native plants here have a very bad time standing up to invasive species. Namely, kudzu and about three other species of vines and bamboo. Also native tree species like locust are very good at sending new suckers far into open spaces. So letting my greenspace simply go wild is not enough - a planned and perpetually maintained approach is a must. While it's possible to do all this with less effort than mowing a lawn, that's not a guarantee.
- coldpie 3y agoHmm, just a thought (I've never lived in an area with an HOA), but how hard are HOAs to legally dismantle? It seems like absolutely no one likes having them, other than the power-trippers who run them. Would it be feasible for a group of neighbors to band together and dismantle theirs? Some areas, like Minnesota, are also introducing laws to preempt cities from banning native lawns, though it's not clear if they can override busybody HOAs. https://minnesotareformer.com/briefs/minnesota-cities-can-no-longer-mandate-turf-grass-lawns/ https://minnesotareformer.com/briefs/minnesota-cities-can-no...
- wingspar 3y agoAs a practical matter, it's all but impossible in most circumstances. (even setting aside getting the owners, some/many of whom are landlords, to approve a dissolution) Usually the HOA legally owns the 'common property', such as retention ponds, club houses, pools, 'parks', etc. If it's a gated community, the HOA owns the roads. The HOA is legally responsible for maintaining those common areas, mowing, cleaning, resurfacing, and even insuring. So if the HOA is dissolved, who owns the common areas, and who pays for (and manages) maintaining them? As I understand it, local government loves HOAs, as they reduce the work they have to do. That tot-lot 'park' is not maintained by the city/county. Those retention ponds are not the counties problem when they go stagnant and have fish-kills. Some states have laws to restrict some of the things HOA's can restrict. Like solar panels, clotheslines, flag poles, and landscaping. Not enough though...
- RecycledEle 3y agoWhy does that web site try to make me think my screen is cracked?