4 ms·
I have never understood the fair use argument when it comes to training data. I publish a copyrighted article. Some LLM ingests it without permission, but sinc
by paxys 3y ago
I have never understood the fair use argument when it comes to training data.
I publish a copyrighted article. Some LLM ingests it without permission, but since the output of that LLM is sufficiently different from my source article there is no violation.
I publish copyrighted code. Some company decides to consume it without purchasing a license. The product they distribute is vastly different from my code itself, but I can still sue them into oblivion.
What's the difference between the two?
- Mathnerd314 3y agoWell "consuming" the code means copying it word for word into your source tree. The compilation process does mangle it a bit but usually you can find identical function names and so on, and the courts have ruled that object code is equivalent to source code for purposes of copyright. A different situation is you read a copyrighted news article and write the facts from it in your essay. Since the copyright of the news article only extends to creative expression and not factual information, there is no violation. For me, it is hard to tell what difference there is between this situation and an LLM identifying statistical patterns in the news article.
- devsda 3y ago> A different situation is you read a copyrighted news article and write the facts from it in your essay. This is fine for actual facts(with some caveats) but how should it apply for creative works like a novel ?
- ryathal 3y agoThe same way it does now. Simply having a character resurrect in a story doesn't violate copyright of the Bible; Game of Thrones; Lion, Witch, and Wardrobe; Harry Potter; Lord of the Rings; etc. Writing a Story About Luke Skywalker as a ten-year-old kid exploring Tatooine, is likely to run into problems.
- Yodel0914 3y ago> I publish copyrighted code. Some company decides to consume it without purchasing a license. The product they distribute is vastly different from my code itself, but I can still sue them into oblivion. Isn't the analogy more: an employee at a company reads your copyrighted code, along with many other pieces of code, and produces a new piece of code? Your code influenced the output, but in no way can you a) detect that influence b) assert any copyright over the output. In your analogy, your code is still "in tact" within the new product; that's not the case with LLM-produced output.
- thayne 3y agoIf the new code is almost identical to the original code, then it is very much subject to copyright, or at the very least is grounds for a lawsuit. And generetive AIs can and do generate output extremely similar to some of its inputs if given the right prompt. My personal opinion is that training a model isn't infringing the copyright. But generating outputs can, if they are sufficiently similar. And since the model itself can't be liable for such infringing works, I think the creator of the model should be responsible.
- olalonde 3y agoThe copyrighted article is not part of the output (at least, not verbatim). The copyrighted code is part of the output.
- renonce 3y agoYou can actually prove that some company distributed a product with your code but you can't practically prove that LLM contains your source article.
- JamesBarney 3y ago> I publish copyrighted code. Some company decides to consume it without purchasing a license. The product they distribute is vastly different from my code itself, but I can still sue them into oblivion. No you can't. If a company reads your copyrighted code, then writes up a spec and sends it to another team that writes up code that accomplishes what you did, that doesn't violate copyright and you wouldn't be able to sue them into oblivion.
- livrem 3y agoIt's more like if I look at thousands of articles and produced a big spreadsheet containing interesting facts about those articles, like word frequencies or what words tend to come after what other words. I never before heard anyone suggest that that kind of analysis would be copyright infringing. The new thing is that someone figured out how to organize dumb facts like that in a clever way and use it to create something sometimes useful, but without actually copying parts of the original articles since those were never saved as part of the data.
- gaganyaan 3y agoThe difference is that the software is in active use in your scenario. Consider if you took a copyrighted program and calculated the sha hash of it. You can then use that hash without needing to have a copy of the original program. The hash is also not infringing, because it's a simple fact.