3 ms·
As far as I understand it, the bottleneck idea is based on a back-calculation of "effective population size" in the past from existing genetic diversity in the
by thaumasiotes 3y ago
As far as I understand it, the bottleneck idea is based on a back-calculation of "effective population size" in the past from existing genetic diversity in the present. (This is definitely the case in the article, which specifies "the population of breeding individuals".)
There are a couple of things that tend to be miscommunicated:
1. An effective population size of N means an actual population size that is significantly larger; children too young to reproduce, adults too old to reproduce, and nerds too awkward to reproduce are all not counted in effective population size.
2. If a group gets demographically wiped out at time T, their ancestors at time T-1000 vanish from the effective population at time T-1000, even though those same ancestors were part of the effective population at time T-1000 if you did the same calculation at time T-200.
(This is true to the extent that the vanishing ancestors don't also have other descendants in groups that survive. But the effect is quite significant - the effective size of the pre-Cherokee population in the year 1000 was much larger in the year 1450 than the same quantity, the effective size of the pre-1450-Cherokee population in the year 1000, is today. Was there a bottleneck? Sure; Amerinds in the region of the United States got wiped out. How long did that process take? When did it happen? We know a lot about the shape of the population over the relevant time period - is it something we're comfortable calling a "bottleneck"?)
So we might estimate our group of 1300 effective individuals as reflecting maybe 430 men of reproductive age, 870 women of reproductive age, plus 220 more women of reproductive age who fail to reproduce, 650 more men of reproductive age who fail to reproduce, and a few thousand children and elders not of reproductive age. And if this group later loses a war, their population could be a lot higher than that.