3 ms·
If a security feature was required by law and car manufacturers decided to not include it then I can at least see a case, but as it stands this is ridiculous. T
by paxys 3y ago
If a security feature was required by law and car manufacturers decided to not include it then I can at least see a case, but as it stands this is ridiculous. The courts aren't a way to enforce unwritten legislation.
- deelowe 3y agoI'll go a bit further. If this sort of behaviour from politicians is tolerated, it will lead to perverse incentives. Why proactively create legislation when you can wait until there's a problem and THEN take action to garner support for reelection? Never let a crisis go to waste...
- rufus_foreman 3y agoOther people disagree. From the article: "Todd Henderson, a legal scholar at the University of Chicago, says that on the face of it, the cities suing might have a case. It would rest, he says, on the argument that when a simple and cheap technology is available that can radically reduce the chance of a product causing enormous damage, “the non-inclusion makes the product defective.” A car that is so easily stolen might be analogous to an iron that does not automatically switch off, and so burns down a house." So, if a company sells an iron that doesn't switch off when not in use and houses burn down, would you think lawsuits against that company are ridiculous? Or is that iron that burns houses down a defective product? From my perspective, I've lived through this and I've had enough of the car thieves on my block. I hope Kia gets sued out of existence.
- chrismcb 3y agoWell it isn't like the car steals itself. A better analogy either be if someone broke into the house and switched the iron on.
- LapsangGuzzler 3y agoThis is exactly why tort law exists, to argue in court that someone else is causing an undue burden and should compensate you. > The courts aren't a way to enforce unwritten legislation. OK, so some big company storing your PII gets hacked and you get hacked as a result and your bank account was drained. Assuming no laws were broken by the company storing your PII, should you not be entitled to sue? This is exactly why lawsuits exist. If there are no digital privacy laws on the books, then no big company should ever be held responsible for a data breach, that's absurd.
- dangus 3y agoThat’s not really how civil court works though. You don’t have to break the law to be judged to be liable for harming someone else financially in civil court. Civil cases work on the “preponderance of the evidence.” The judge or jury must believe that your case is stronger than the other side’s case. I think there is so much data pointing to Kia and Hyundai’s practice being unusual, and I’d guess that discovery will find out that decision makes at Hyundai knew that increased thefts would occur. If so, it stands to reason that they knew their decision to forego immobilizers would directly shoulder cities with extra costs.
- tzs 3y agoIt's a civil case. One of the main purposes of the civil law system is to address harms from things that are not illegal.
- Ekaros 3y agoAnd in this case the problem isn't the manufacturers. But cities who have not invested sufficiently in both jail and police capacity.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]