3 ms·
>But then what is it for? Setting a national floor. > It's representatives from California deciding what the minimum wage should be in Texas and not what it w
by lotsofpulp 3y ago
>But then what is it for?
Setting a national floor.
> It's representatives from California deciding what the minimum wage should be in Texas and not what it will be in California.
No, it is the United States’ representatives setting a floor for the United States.
> If the people in Texas want a higher floor they can enact it themselves.
If the people in Texas want a lower floor, they are welcome to try and leave the US.
>But they don't, and they may not be wrong, because different states have different economies.
So do different counties and cities and parts of cities. It is all arbitrarily defined, and at the end of the day, might makes right. Hence, feds set the floor in Texas (currently).
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> Setting a national floor. That's what it does, not what it's for. Why is it good to force misaligned economic policy on various jurisdictions whose people don't want it? > No, it is the United States’ representatives setting a floor for the United States. The United States doesn't have representatives in the national legislature. States and districts do. > If the people in Texas want a lower floor, they are welcome to try and leave the US. Or to repeal the national floor, presumably, but then representatives from California try to stop them even though the national floor does not apply to anyone they represent. > It is all arbitrarily defined, and at the end of the day, might makes right. I'm not asking for an analysis of electoral math. I'm asking why the federal government should override state and local governments who, representing the will of their own populations, judge such rules to be counterproductive given the state of their local economy.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lotsofpulp 3y ago> I'm asking why the federal government should override state and local governments who, representing the will of their own populations, judge such rules to be counterproductive given the state of their local economy. Because there is no “correct” size of ruling government, just what gets negotiated. Feds overrule state, and states overrule counties and cities, and counties overrule cities, and cities overrule neighborhood associations, etc.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoI dispute the notion that there is no "correct" size of ruling government for a given issue. There are some issues, like mail fraud, that are not adequately dealt with on a local level because victims and perpetrators may be in different jurisdictions and the jurisdiction of the perpetrator may have no interest in addressing harms to someone outside their constituency. Then there are issues where the costs and benefits of a given policy are felt predominantly by the local population and have to be tailored to local conditions, for which local policy is a better fit. (It's also not a law of nature that larger governments overrule smaller ones. You could have a constitution that says that in certain domains the national government can pass defaults that apply unless the local government passes a specific law that says something different. Or that allows the national government to regulate interstate commerce but only actual interstate commerce and explicitly not intra-state commerce.) The question of where to address a given issue is a matter for debate, but that isn't to say there can be no reasoned justification for doing it in one way or another. And so what I'm asking is, what is the argument for setting this kind of economic policy at the national level, when the optimal policy depends on local conditions and predominantly affects local people?
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Or to repeal the national floor, presumably, but then representatives from California try to stop them even though the national floor does not apply to anyone they represent. Yes, federal wage and hour law does apply in California, separately and in addition to state law (and in cases where state wage and hour law does not, including to certain actions by the State as an employer.) The fact that people who comply with State law where it applies will generally not have to worry about federal law because they will also be complying with it doesn’t mean that both don’t apply.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoIt means that it has no effect on their constituents -- unless the people of California likewise decided that they wanted a lower minimum. Which means that the federal law can only be either redundant with or adverse to the preferences of any local population.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> If the people in Texas want a lower floor, they are welcome to try and leave the US. Or to try to convince a sufficient portion of the rest of the US to adopt a lower floor.