4 ms·
> but the root problem is the sexism, not the ad copy. I agree it was a very sexist thing to write. It makes me wonder though: 1. Which is worse, hiring an a
by mistermann 15y ago
> but the root problem is the sexism, not the ad copy.
I agree it was a very sexist thing to write. It makes me wonder though:
1. Which is worse, hiring an all female serving staff (perhaps wearing uniforms that would be considered particularly attractive to heterosexual males), or acknowledging that you have done this by writing about it in your invitations? Is it inappropriate (always and everywhere) to hire only attractive females and make them wear "sexy" uniforms? If they had hired all females, but not advertised it, would people still be upset after they had arrived and seen that all the staff were female? I wouldn't be upset. But advertising it, or at least they way they did it, strikes me as offensive, but I don't know why.
2. I feel mentioning the female serving staff in this instance is inappropriate, but is it always inappropriate? Is it acceptable for a sports bar to mention their "Bud Girls" or whatever in their ad copy? I would consider this acceptable, but I don't know why. Is it because a sports bar is purely leisure, and a hackathon, while leisure, is (presumably) directly connected to your profession?
I think what they did feels wrong, but I can't think of a good explanation of why it is wrong that is logically consistent with other acceptable norms in our society.
- cheez 15y agoFYI, there is an upscale restaurant where I go regularly for lunch that has only attractive women. (Not Hooters)
- protomyth 15y agoThere is a difference between a hackathon and a restaurant. There are actually restaurants that hire very good looking men also because they are going for a certain clientele. Sexuality sells a lot of things, but that's hormones and money. The problem here is that a goodly chunk of people expect the clientele of a hackathon to be developers. Developers are men and women who are professional. As much as sexuality sells beer, food, cars, etc., it is not a accepted selling point of professionals. Rather, it will get you in serious trouble in many professional environments. Now, it is revealed that this company's fantasy event is programming while being served beer by hot women. This basically puts them in the frat with a big no hire for women.
- rtperson 15y ago> it is not a accepted selling point of professionals. Rather, it will get you in serious trouble in many professional environments. Not to defend Sqoot at all, but... um... booth babes? Every large trade show has them. They are there specifically to excite the hormones of the male professionals in attendance. Their use is as sexist as it is effective. Had Sqoot quietly hired a bunch of models to serve beer to the attendants, and had they had the sense not to publicly high-five themselves for doing so, there would have been no controversy. The reason Sqoot landed in the soup is because they wore their sexism on their sleeves, and handled their communications like obnoxious rubes rather than responsible business owners. Their crime was lack of finesse.
- cgoddard 15y agoJust because a form of sexism is pervasive doesn't mean it isn't also offensive and demeaning to people. Part of being professional and encouraging diversity is not promoting a frat-like or male-dominated business culture.
- rtperson 15y agoI completely agree. I was just pointing out that sexism of this nature had gone on for years without apparent protest. I was not defending the practice.
- protomyth 15y agoBooth babes are a problem and the protests have gone up about them (to the point of misidentifying a women as a booth babe will get you in trouble). If they had quietly done it and female developers had showed up, the damage would have been worse, much worse. Words are one thing, pictures of scantily clad models serving beer at a hackathon would have been a little too juicy for the bloggers. Twitter pictures turn into mainstream media articles rather quickly these days. Their crime is thinking it was acceptable. As my Dad told me (constantly as a youth it seemed), "I'm amazed you thought of that, and appalled you actually did it." Fantasy is best kept out of the professional workplace / event planning.
- samth 15y agoThe point I'm trying to make is that thinking of hiring women staff as a "perk" is sexist and unprofessional, and you shouldn't do it. It assumes that everyone attending is a straight guy, and it also assumes that the straight guys that attend want to be included in your sexual fantasies. As to the larger society, yes, "Bud Girls", booth babes, GoDaddy ads, and Hooters are all sexist.
- petercooper 15y agoBut advertising it, or at least they way they did it, strikes me as offensive, but I don't know why. Here's my take. Things that are implicitly accepted as being the true state of things can become offensive when they are shared or explicitly shared. You can pretty much assume everyone you meet poops or masturbates, that's not offensive. But if we deliberately express details of these activities in public, it then becomes inappropriate or even offensive. Likewise, we all have opinions on people's characteristics, conscious or not but we accept these things as quirks of being animals. What makes us decent and human, however, is keeping unpleasant or uncontrollable thoughts and opinions to ourselves, and if we start sharing them explicitly, it becomes inappropriate.