4 ms·

I still can't understand why MS is forced to break up product bundles but Google can make Android with a bunch of Google apps, some of which are very difficult

I still can't understand why MS is forced to break up product bundles but Google can make Android with a bunch of Google apps, some of which are very difficult to turn off.

hypertele-Xii 3y ago
I was under the impression that the EU is working on legistlation forcing all smartphone apps to be uninstallable, including manufacturer bundled ones. https://www.androidauthority.com/eu-draft-law-uninstall-preinstalled-apps-1163382/ https://www.androidauthority.com/eu-draft-law-uninstall-prei...
- pipes 3y ago
  I haven't experienced something being uninstallable, I've always used Google pixel phones, do other manufacturers do this?
  - daveoc64 3y ago
    You can't uninstall most Google apps on a Pixel phone. Google Maps and Google Drive can't be uninstalled, for example. You can disable them - this stops the app running and will remove its icon, but it'll still use space. Some system apps can't be disabled - many of these are critical system processes, but there are also some that are non-essential.
    - pipes 3y ago
      Ah I didn't know! Thanks
- matthewfelgate 3y ago
  Maybe the EU should concentrate on more important things. Like why EU GDP is stagnating compare to the USA.
stop50 3y ago
Google can argue that they don't have 100% of the market and they did changes with android 12+ that enables other stores to provide packages.
- fidotron 3y ago
  Outside of the English speaking world (and Japan) iOS market share is generally much lower than particularly in the US. I would be tempted to say this is because a lot of the iOS pitch is “trust Apple because you don’t trust the regulatory environment” whereas in places like Germany the regulatory trust is higher so that pitch sounds weaker.
  - Proziam 3y ago
    Apple hardware is prohibitively expensive for most of the world. That's probably the primary driver for the market share gap. Even in the US, the brand is a status/class symbol to some extent. That said, I have heard the "trust" version of the pitch from some VC types floating around UNLV and I find their trust in Apple to be perplexing.
    - bdavbdav 3y ago
      It’s not an uncommon view - I trust them in terms of privacy and security much more than the alternatives.
jsnell 3y ago
The reason you can't understand it is that your entire premise is faulty. The EU already forced Google to unbundle parts of Android (while also issuing a 4 billion Euro fine) about 5 years ago. Specifically, for Android it's the device manufacturer who decides what gets pre-installed on the phone. The EU required Google to not make preinstalling Search and Chrome a precondition of getting to install the other apps.
Dalewyn 3y ago
Understand for a moment that Microsoft isn't even counted as Big Tech by most people: GAFA (Google Apple Facebook Amazon) or FAANG (Facebook Apple Amazon Netflix Google) as Big Tech is usually referred by. Microsoft isn't or can't line the necessary wallets to play with the big boys, simply speaking. This means they don't get to enjoy the perks of Big Tech, but also get to enjoy not being lambasted along with them.
- supriyo-biswas 3y ago
  "GAFAM" is definitely a well-known term in the EU at least.
- Delphiza 3y ago
  Microsoft is in the top 3 of big tech market cap (US). They officially spend about $10M per year lobbying in the US, which is in the same ballpark as other big tech. Maybe the HN crowd doesn't count Microsoft as big tech, but financial markets, enterprises, governments, and regulators most definitely do.
- matthewfelgate 3y ago
  Community Notes: Microsoft is the 2nd biggest company in the world behind Apple.
- scarface_74 3y ago
  No Microsoft isn’t treated like BigTech by geeks who listened to a loud mouth guy on CNBC who originally coined the term “FANG” (notice the missing “A”) that included a Netflix who’s market share is nothing compared to Apple and Microsoft that were already two of the 5 most valuable companies even when the term was coined

I still can't understand why MS is forced to break up product bundles but Google can make Android with a bunch of Google apps, some of which are very difficult to turn off.

hypertele-Xii 3y ago

I was under the impression that the EU is working on legistlation forcing all smartphone apps to be uninstallable, including manufacturer bundled ones. https://www.androidauthority.com/eu-draft-law-uninstall-preinstalled-apps-1163382/ https://www.androidauthority.com/eu-draft-law-uninstall-prei...

pipes 3y ago
I haven't experienced something being uninstallable, I've always used Google pixel phones, do other manufacturers do this?
- daveoc64 3y ago
  You can't uninstall most Google apps on a Pixel phone. Google Maps and Google Drive can't be uninstalled, for example. You can disable them - this stops the app running and will remove its icon, but it'll still use space. Some system apps can't be disabled - many of these are critical system processes, but there are also some that are non-essential.
  - pipes 3y ago
    Ah I didn't know! Thanks
matthewfelgate 3y ago
Maybe the EU should concentrate on more important things. Like why EU GDP is stagnating compare to the USA.

stop50 3y ago

Google can argue that they don't have 100% of the market and they did changes with android 12+ that enables other stores to provide packages.

fidotron 3y ago
Outside of the English speaking world (and Japan) iOS market share is generally much lower than particularly in the US. I would be tempted to say this is because a lot of the iOS pitch is “trust Apple because you don’t trust the regulatory environment” whereas in places like Germany the regulatory trust is higher so that pitch sounds weaker.
- Proziam 3y ago
  Apple hardware is prohibitively expensive for most of the world. That's probably the primary driver for the market share gap. Even in the US, the brand is a status/class symbol to some extent. That said, I have heard the "trust" version of the pitch from some VC types floating around UNLV and I find their trust in Apple to be perplexing.
  - bdavbdav 3y ago
    It’s not an uncommon view - I trust them in terms of privacy and security much more than the alternatives.

jsnell 3y ago

The reason you can't understand it is that your entire premise is faulty. The EU already forced Google to unbundle parts of Android (while also issuing a 4 billion Euro fine) about 5 years ago. Specifically, for Android it's the device manufacturer who decides what gets pre-installed on the phone. The EU required Google to not make preinstalling Search and Chrome a precondition of getting to install the other apps.

Dalewyn 3y ago

Understand for a moment that Microsoft isn't even counted as Big Tech by most people: GAFA (Google Apple Facebook Amazon) or FAANG (Facebook Apple Amazon Netflix Google) as Big Tech is usually referred by. Microsoft isn't or can't line the necessary wallets to play with the big boys, simply speaking. This means they don't get to enjoy the perks of Big Tech, but also get to enjoy not being lambasted along with them.

supriyo-biswas 3y ago
"GAFAM" is definitely a well-known term in the EU at least.
Delphiza 3y ago
Microsoft is in the top 3 of big tech market cap (US). They officially spend about $10M per year lobbying in the US, which is in the same ballpark as other big tech. Maybe the HN crowd doesn't count Microsoft as big tech, but financial markets, enterprises, governments, and regulators most definitely do.
matthewfelgate 3y ago
Community Notes: Microsoft is the 2nd biggest company in the world behind Apple.
scarface_74 3y ago
No Microsoft isn’t treated like BigTech by geeks who listened to a loud mouth guy on CNBC who originally coined the term “FANG” (notice the missing “A”) that included a Netflix who’s market share is nothing compared to Apple and Microsoft that were already two of the 5 most valuable companies even when the term was coined