4 ms·
The distance between "sort of works" and "works" for AI is considerable. Not infinite. Look at self-driving cars. The first tries were in the late 1950s, with
by Animats 3y ago
The distance between "sort of works" and "works" for AI is considerable. Not infinite.
Look at self-driving cars. The first tries were in the late 1950s, with GM's Firebird 3, guided by wires in the road. By the 1980s, the first self-driving vehicles were moving around CMU, very slowly. By the early 1990s, experimental highway driving had been demoed. In the early 2000s, we had the DARPA Grand Challenge, which had off-road driving on empty roads working. Then there were a few experimental self-driving cars that sort of worked on general roads. Many startups, most went bust.
Today you can take a driverless cab in San Francisco. 64 years since GM's Firebird III.
(Which still exists, in driveable condition, in GM's in-house collection.)
It may take a while to get from GPT-3 to Microsoft Middle Manager 2.0. But the path is clear now.
- logifail 3y ago> The distance between "sort of works" and "works" for AI is considerable. Not infinite. > Today you can take a driverless cab in San Francisco [...] From the outside, it sure does look like driverless is still firmly at "sort of works": "After California regulators approved the expansion of driverless taxi services in San Francisco earlier this month, it took only a little more than 24 hours for a series of events to begin that seemed to justify the taxis’ detractors. The day after the vote, 10 autonomous vehicles operated by Cruise, a subsidiary of General Motors, abruptly stopped functioning in the middle of a busy street in the North Beach neighborhood of San Francisco. Posts to social media showed the cars jammed up, their hazard lights flashing, blocking traffic for 15 minutes. A few days later, another Cruise vehicle drove into a paving project in the Western Addition and got stuck in freshly poured concrete. And then last week, a Cruise car collided with a fire truck in the city, injuring a passenger in the car. So it was that last Friday Cruise agreed to a request from the California Department of Motor Vehicles to cut in half the number of vehicles it operated in San Francisco, even though regulatory approval for more remained in place. The company, which has had 400 driverless vehicles operating in the city, will now have no more than 50 cars running during the day and 150 at night."[0] [0] https://www.nytimes.com/2023/08/22/us/california-autonomous-vehicles.html https://www.nytimes.com/2023/08/22/us/california-autonomous-...
- emptysongglass 3y agoThat's Cruise. Waymo has driven 1 million miles as of last January with only two incidents that have met the government's reporting criteria and no injuries. Those stats are impressive. https://waymo.com/blog/2023/02/first-million-rider-only-miles-how.html https://waymo.com/blog/2023/02/first-million-rider-only-mile...
- Animats 3y agoCruise started as a "fake it til you make it" operation. The tradition continues.
- naillo 3y agoThat's true for driverless cars but there's many areas where you don't need 100% to be useful. Stable diffusion and LLMs are 90% there but still very useful and cool.
- Tanjreeve 3y agoMost of those areas don't normally have a lot of value or you're marginally improving on existing recommendation systems. It's a coin toss on how much of an improvement this wave of LLM powered ML systems will have over the previous wave of "enterprise knowledge collation" systems and if that will be enough for people to buy them.
- cstejerean 3y agoPeople seem to be buying them already, looks like OpenAI is now pulling in $80M per month in revenue.
- drawfloat 3y agoBeing able to take a cab in a single tiny part of the world remains firmly in “sort of works” camp.
- Ekaros 3y agoAlso when you start to get in more extreme but not actually extreme scenarios. I wonder how well will these do with let's say 5cm of fresh snow. With no other traffic yet meaning no road markings are visible, and in bad case signs could be covered. Probably a yearly scenario in many parts of the world.
- intended 3y agoSelf-driving is never going to happen, and its also sitting in some sort of informational blind spot for the people working on it - I have no idea why. There is no such thing as "driving" there is no physical force, or particle. There is no force preventing you from driving in the opposite direction of traffic, or through glass panes. "Driving" is entirely a social phenomnon, the confluence of societal self impositions and engineering. If you have a car on fire in front of you, you will need to reverse in the wrong direction of traffic. In many countries - you have to regularly deal with drivers going full tilt, on the wrong side of the road. Or You have to deal with theft, and people trying to rob you at every red light. Im underscoring that this is a social issue. You would need to create models for each country and region, to truly improve self driving. Self driving assumes a far narrower problem space than reality gives a fig for. Self driving theory currently works in the same way any theory that assumes spherical cows works.
- emptyfile 3y ago[dead]
- pferde 3y agoIndeed, it would probably require the invention of a true Artificial Intelligence, and of high quality as well. Not the glorified autocomplete the scammers are trying to pass as AI now, but the real thing that can sense and understand the world around it.
- esperent 3y ago> In many countries - you have to regularly deal with drivers going full tilt, on the wrong side of the road. I don't agree with most of your comment but this point is worth examining. I think it's not an argument against self driving for a few reasons: 1. There's lots of places in the world where people driving on the wrong side of the road is uncommon. We can start with self driving there. You can apply this to many other situations as well - AI can't handle ice yet? Well, let's start with non-icy roads. Even when you apply all the stipulations like these that you need, you'll still be left with a large enough percentage of the world to make self driving useful. Especially since a lot of the places that are suitable will be rich cities in developed countries. 2. Driving habits change. Thailand is a good example of this, it's a country in transition from the "developing country driving style" to the "developed country driving style", for want of better terms. Driving there 15 years ago was an extremely different, far noiser, far more dangerous experience than driving there now. It's still got a long way to go, of course. 3. If self driving becomes the norm, well then, problem solved. We don't even have to get to FSD. Partial but always on assisted driving that nags you whenever you drive on the wrong side of the road or go over the speed limit would probably be enough to cause a shift if most people have it.
- qsort 3y agoDoes Microsoft Middle Manager 2.0 stop working in the presence of traffic cones? More seriously, the distance between "sort of works" and "works" might not be infinite, but it most likely involves fundamentally unpredictable future developments of the current technology. There is no straight line of incremental improvements that gets us there. It's fairly straightforward to imagine that if you have a 4.77mhz CPU and 64kb of RAM you will soon have a 3ghz CPU and 64gb RAM. Bigger number going brrr is no guarantee of anything, here, so much so that models using a fraction of GPT4's resources are somewhat competitive. By all means continue developing the technology, but claims that we are within arms' reach of X for disparate values of X are not exactly supported by anything.
- veltas 3y ago> Does Microsoft Middle Manager 2.0 stop working in the presence of traffic cones? Yes, but it integrates well into Outlook.
- drawkbox 3y ago> Does Microsoft Middle Manager 2.0 stop working in the presence of traffic cones? That could be a benefit. Imagine being able to go dev shields up with just cones around your desk. When it is time to innovate, surround yourself with cones. "You haven't checked on your 'resources' in an hour, how is resource #4233 (Johnson) doing on that new feature?" -- funding borg consultcult front man "I don't know, his cone shields are up, we can't get our needed hourly metrics" -- Microsoft Middle Manager 2.0
- vineyardmike 3y ago> Does Microsoft Middle Manager 2.0 stop working in the presence of traffic cones? I think if you put a traffic cone on my IRL managers head she’d stop working too. Maybe a bit different… but maybe not. I don’t think the poster was saying we’re within arms reach of it, but that there’s a path that takes us from here to there. A MSFT AI manager obviously wouldn’t behave exactly like a real human, but a tool that aggregates and summarizes information from many reports for a high level manager, and helps negotiate priorities is something potentially doable with some prompt engineering and advancements in models. I respect many of my past managers, and some of them were great mentors and materially improved my life but 50+% of the value managers provide to an organization can be done with a bit of glue between GPT-x and Jira. It’d free up a lot of their time for the remaining 50% too.
- TMWNN 3y ago>It may take a while to get from GPT-3 to Microsoft Middle Manager 2.0. But the path is clear now. I was intrigued by the announced Business Chat feature for Microsoft Teams <https://www.reddit.com/r/singularity/comments/11swyeu/introducing_microsoft_365_copilot_your_copilot/ https://www.reddit.com/r/singularity/comments/11swyeu/introd...>, but learned that it is just summaries of conversations. That's not quite what I'd imagined, which is something like this: ---- A: ... and that is why I think we should go with option 1. B: No, the points you mentioned support my case for option 2. C: Nothing you guys have said changes my mind about option 3 being best. D: Business Chat, what do you think? BC: Based on this discussion, and my research, option 1 seems more realistic but option 2 would be more profitable if possible. My reasons are ... C: Business Chat and you guys all don't understand point N, which is the main reason why option 3 is best. B: Higher profit is exactly why I think option 2 is the way to go. A: No, our rival is going to hit the market next month. We need to get something out there ASAP. Option 1 can do this. D: You've all given me things to think about. Thank you for coming. Business Chat, email me a summary of the meeting, and set up a followup meeting for Tuesday 3pm. ---- That is, AI used as a colleague/assistant, not necessarily subordinate but not seen as omniscient, either; another viewpoint to consider. Like you said, Middle Manager 2.0. When do you think the above will be feasible? This year? Five years?
- yMMe2WYE_D 3y agoIt might be more an issue of "if" than "when". Can LLM even go beyond being "interactive textbook"? On the other hand, looking at constant complaints from data scientists, ChatGPT can replace them here and now. It might not be able to understand the problems, but supplying boss with arguments that support their decision is the matter of weeks, maybe just an extra preamble/prompt will be enough.
- pjc50 3y ago> Microsoft Middle Manager 2.0 I think we've found the common thread between AI and crypto: the dumping of externalities and increase in energy usage. Do people really want to work for Microsoft Middle Manager? Have we not seen enough horror stories about metric-slavery in Amazon warehouses and the gig economy? It might be cheaper, but it's also worse, for a class of people who don't get any input in the decision. Similarly self-driving unleashes a new class of poorly behaved "learner" drivers on the road, who may be less aggressive but are also capable of causing problems from that very timidity and lack of general competence.
- vGPU 3y agoJust you wait until it realizes that firing you would result in a net carbon usage savings for the company.
- arcticbull 3y agoThe other common thread is it’s all the same grifters. The same people who hyped up the worlds slowest coal powered linked list as the future of money are now hyping up AI. I do think AI is somewhat different as we will be left with more to show for it than “PayPal for Cambodian human traffickers running pig butchering scams.” My banal take is: notwithstanding above, all the risk premium is gone for investors and employees. Everything in the AI space is priced assuming flawless execution over a 20 year time frame. As a potential employee - or investor - that equity is just not interesting to me.
- Animats 3y ago> The other common thread is it’s all the same grifters. Yes, the same grifters are migrating to AI. But there's a real industry in AI, unlike blockchain, where it was almost all grifters. The pure scam industries, day trading, binary options, cryptocurrency, contracts for difference, retail FOREX, etc. do have many of the same people. If you want to follow this, there's Offshore Alert.[1] [1] https://www.offshorealert.com/ https://www.offshorealert.com/
- Animats 3y ago
- tome 3y ago> It may take a while to get from GPT-3 to Microsoft Middle Manager 2.0. But the path is clear now. Is there a way you could make the path clear to me too? I just don't get it. Sure, I can imagine in principle it's possible. But I don't see how you can already see it's certain. Is there something you can share that will allow me to see why it's certain?