3 ms·
I'm trying to remember the quote about burning the library of Alexandria. I am sure it's a modern(ish) invention, probably the enlightenment or even later. Roma
by ggm 3y ago
I'm trying to remember the quote about burning the library of Alexandria. I am sure it's a modern(ish) invention, probably the enlightenment or even later. Romanticising what people said as they torched the scrolls has a fine quality to it.
(I think it's "if its not in the Koran its a lie, and if it is in the Koran it's superfluous")
- wrp 3y agoI've seen quotes like that in other contexts, but in relation to the Library of Alexandria, it's surely apocryphal. The Library declined over several centuries, so gradually in fact, that it's impossible to say exactly when it ceased to be a major research center.
- andrewstuart 3y agoThe ancient Library of Alexandria was lost to fire in the 3rd century BC. The the even-more-ancient Library of Ashurbanipal from the 7th century BC was not lost and was in fact found with over 30,000 texts. The irony being that it was preserved because it was burned, and most of the writings were clay tablets, thus were preserved even better in the fire.
- wrp 3y agoThere was no cataclysmic destruction of the Library of Alexandria. It declined slowly over several centuries. Wikipedia gives a decent overview. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Library_of_Alexandria https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Library_of_Alexandria) Jean-Yves Empereur discusses the archaeological evidence in "The destruction of the Library of Alexandria: An archaeological viewpoint" in the edited volume What Happened to the Ancient Library of Alexandria? (2008). In that same volume, Qassem Abdou Qassem and Bernard Lewis each discuss the origin of the quote mentioned above and dispute its authenticity.
- raverbashing 3y agoI've hear something similar about the Spanish and the Maya but I might be mistaken
- esalman 3y agoThe quote is disputed, and historical accuracy is important. Additionally, it's worth noting that attributing the burning of the Library of Alexandria solely to Muslims oversimplifies a complex historical event. It's important to consider the broader historical context and the contributions of Muslim scholars, such as the establishment of the Grand Library of Baghdad, which reflects a different aspect of their relationship with knowledge.
- MandieD 3y agoThe 415 AD murder of Hypatia of Alexandria, the first well-known female mathematician, was a 100% Christian operation... likely inspired by a political smear campaign put on by the Bishop of Alexandria who was trying to consolidate secular power.