3 ms·
IMO the least-bad way to keep "objectionable material" out of the hands of minors is to focus on positive signals from devices, ex: __________ 1. Parents cont
by Terr_ 3y ago
IMO the least-bad way to keep "objectionable material" out of the hands of minors is to focus on positive signals from devices, ex:
__________
1. Parents control what hardware the kids have access to. Perhaps not perfectly, but at least it is something the average person can see in meat-space and interact with without requiring special knowledge.
2. They buy devices for their kids that support a parental-lock feature, which (if enabled) causes the device to always send metadata outwards, such as HTTP headers. This metadata encodes some standard like "I'm a minor in Jurisdiction X" or even "I am currently approximately Y months old in jurisdiction X."
3. Online sites/services can comply simply by recognizing these signals and throwing up "denied" pages, without any kind of authentication and no need to build profiles of users or track activity.
__________
Sure, it's not perfect (kid borrows adult device, non-compliant sites, proxy sites that subvert the rstrictions) but it's better than nothing while avoiding massive rating-bureaucracies or forcing shitty backdoors into software. Also, the costs will tend to fall on the same people who want the feature.
Some pain-points will remain like whether to support a country where people under 28.75 years are not allowed to see ankle skin, but that's unavoidable complexity from the problem-domain--bad laws as opposed to bad software.
- solraph 3y ago> 2. Buy devices for kids that support a parental-lock feature, which when enabled causes the device to always send metadata outwards, such as HTTP headers. These would encode "I'm a minor in Jurisdiction X" or even "I am approximately Y months old in jurisdiction X." I like the concept, but I can see bad actors abusing the heck out of these headers in so many ways.
- Terr_ 3y ago> I can see bad actors abusing the heck out of these headers I disagree: Whatever evil they're already committing, a signal of "client device has parental lock enabled" would only make them very slightly more effective at committing it. Those kinds of bad actors are already filtering for minors based on much more impactful means, like how/where the site is advertised and what it purports to offer. In exaggerated contrast, I can't imagine some would-be-molester making a baroque plan to set up a Tax Advice Forum with a hidden code-path for parental-locked devices, one that metaphorically tells the user they've won a free giveaway to candy in a white truck.
- judge2020 3y agoMost sites you can find from google will be blocked simply from the RTA label[0] being on the page - which all the major mobile OSes seem to support, and I imagine (proxy-based) desktop control software does as well. 0: https://www.rtalabel.org/index.php?content=howtofaq https://www.rtalabel.org/index.php?content=howtofaq
- LinuxBender 3y agoI've been putting together a small write-up on these headers [1] and my own crazy conspiracy theory as to why I think they are not utilized any more just so I could keep track of the discussions. They have existed for quite some time and are trivial for both website operators and clients to implement. As a funny side note there is code looking for RTA headers in yt-dlp [2] One could even get a small sample of sites using the header without a Shodan login [3]. I am pleasantly surprised to see AU is not going to be added to the growing list of people forcing a login to a centralized database. [1] - https://bender.ohblog.net/Internet-Crap/20230829-Think-Of-The-Children.html https://bender.ohblog.net/Internet-Crap/20230829-Think-Of-Th... [2] - https://github.com/yt-dlp/yt-dlp/blob/master/yt_dlp/extractor/common.py https://github.com/yt-dlp/yt-dlp/blob/master/yt_dlp/extracto... [3] - https://www.shodan.io/search?query=RTA-5042-1996-1400-1577-RTA https://www.shodan.io/search?query=RTA-5042-1996-1400-1577-R...