3 ms·
That link just made my head explode: Did all nine of the Supreme Court Justices just conflate patent eligibility with novelty and non-obviousness? Yes they di
by nl 15y ago
That link just made my head explode:
Did all nine of the Supreme Court Justices just conflate patent eligibility with novelty and non-obviousness? Yes they did! But it gets worse — they explicitly admitted doing so!
and
The Supreme Court also further specifically ignored the Government’s objective, reasonable and until today correct assertion that any step beyond a statement of a law of nature transforms the claim into one that displays patent eligible subject matter
I had to double-check if this was some kind of parody site. Perhaps this could be an extension to Poe's Law?
- moldbug 15y agoI had to double-check if this was some kind of parody site. It's always a lot easier to sound like the voice of reason when you're winning. Defeat, especially unexpected defeat, brings out the inner crazy even in the most reasonable. But's still surprising to hear the notorious Quinn shrieking like Goebbels in March '45. That quote about the Federal Circuit is just priceless. It is absolutely correct. It's also an admission against interest, which is why you'll never hear anyone say it. Someone at EFF better get the screenshot pronto, before Quinn goes back on his meds...
- Natsu 15y ago> Did all nine of the Supreme Court Justices just conflate patent eligibility with novelty and non-obviousness? Yes they did! But it gets worse — they explicitly admitted doing so! He's mad because he just got Flooked[1]. Some patent lawyers have gotten too attached to the trick they've been using for decades now where they could just split up the section 101, 102 & 103 obligations to meet them each by parts, and consider anyone confused who supposes that the patent as a whole ought to live up to each of those obligations. Note that word "ought" though: for a long time, the courts were more than happy to let them do that. If he's dismayed, it's because the Supreme Court has the power to turn that particular ought into an is. But this led to an odd state of affairs where so many bad patents issued where the only novelty they offered wasn't actually patentable and the patentable subject matter had already been invented. [1] That was a bad pun. But this ruling honestly seemed, at least to me, like a return to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parker_v._Flook https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parker_v._Flook which is quoted extensively.
- ScottBurson 15y agoThank you for this. I was trying to understand where Quinn was coming from. Your explanation makes perfect sense.