8 ms·
It's easier to make sense of when you remember the original purpose of HIPAA, which was cost control and portability (that's what the 'p' stands for!). The con
by tptacek 3y ago
It's easier to make sense of when you remember the original purpose of HIPAA, which was cost control and portability (that's what the 'p' stands for!).
The confidentiality rules in HIPAA are part of (IIRC, I think, etc?) the "Administrative Simplification" section, which was about standardizing electronic health care records and making them available to the government for combating Medicare fraud. The law wasn't a sweeping medical privacy bill; it added privacy rules to mitigate concerns people had about centralizing medical records as part of its major purpose.
- dclowd9901 3y agoWhich sucks because there is tremendous value in anonymized collections of health records, yet we can’t use these health records for research at all. I realize it was out of scope for the bill, but damned if it didn’t stymie medical research to a ridiculous degree.
- mr_toad 3y agoAnonymised collections of health records are available to bona fide researchers.
- kccqzy 3y agoAnonymization is hard. Unless you have very accomplished cryptographers defining and implementing anonymization, I do not trust it. That basically means not trusting anyone but large governments and FAANG companies. That said I do think agencies like NIST should define anonymization standards.
- bombcar 3y agoAnd medical issues are such that even fully anonymous you can probably identify who is whom.
- jasonhong 3y agoLatanya Sweeney demonstrated how hard it is to anonymize health data back in the late 1990s as part of her dissertation work: https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2009/09/your-secrets-live-online-in-databases-of-ruin/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2009/09/your-secrets-liv... "At the time GIC released the data, William Weld, then Governor of Massachusetts, assured the public that GIC had protected patient privacy by deleting identifiers. In response, then-graduate student Sweeney started hunting for the Governor’s hospital records in the GIC data. She knew that Governor Weld resided in Cambridge, Massachusetts, a city of 54,000 residents and seven ZIP codes. For twenty dollars, she purchased the complete voter rolls from the city of Cambridge, a database containing, among other things, the name, address, ZIP code, birth date, and sex of every voter. By combining this data with the GIC records, Sweeney found Governor Weld with ease. Only six people in Cambridge shared his birth date, only three of them men, and of them, only he lived in his ZIP code. In a theatrical flourish, Dr. Sweeney sent the Governor’s health records (which included diagnoses and prescriptions) to his office." This same article also mentions one of her more famous findings too: "in 2000, she showed that 87 percent of all Americans could be uniquely identified using only three bits of information: ZIP code, birthdate, and sex."
- ghaff 3y agoYep. I've used that example in presentations. If you really want to de-anonymize a medical record, it's pretty easy to do so on the basis of other data which is arguably public for good reasons (and/or as a matter of law).
- bombcar 3y agoEven if you remove all location and date information from a medical record, you can likely work out quite a bit of information (certain procedures occur at certain times, etc). And at that point you’re starting to destroy the value of the data.
- flandish 3y agoI worked with de-identification of records - it was not only difficult, but also rewarding. The records were used in research, tied to other biomedical data. Some of it was simply migration of encounter data +/- a date range, with removal of the obvious stuff, too. Other was cool like NLP on doc notes to ensure stuff like “pt said the school shooting they got this wound from was..” (think: cohort sizes for major incidents are often small and therefore easy to re-id.)
- KingMob 3y agoThis is just incorrect. I've collaborated in studies using anonymized MRI scans and health data. You don't get a blank check, but there are plenty of studies doing exactly this.
- earthboundkid 3y agoRetracted
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]