6 ms·
This is a very clever idea. However, I realize that I would never want to use something like this that would change over time. E.g. if I ran it every 6 months
by crazygringo 3y ago
This is a very clever idea.
However, I realize that I would never want to use something like this that would change over time. E.g. if I ran it every 6 months and last year "db" produced "debug", while this year it produces "database". Because talk about messing up my muscle memory and habits. And the language I write changes very much over time.
So I'd actually be much more interested in a "universal" version of this -- if you ran it across books and e-mails and text messages from thousands of authors covering diverse backgrounds and contexts, then what would most reliably help everyone?
E.g. expanding "t" to "the" seems like a no-brainer, just like "st" to "something". Is there a minimal set of, say, 200-500 of these that could simply be turned into a "standard keyboard" that everyone could learn?
- leobabauta 3y agoI think the phrase "changes over time" should be one of your shortcuts.
- calvinmorrison 3y agoCongrats you just invented shorthand!
- IanCal 3y agoYou could make it append only by default. Only ever add new shortcuts - if db was debug for you before then database would have to take on a new shortcut (e.g. dtb)
- munificent 3y agoThat would lead to pointless verbosity over time because the older shortcuts would squat on useful shorter shortcuts for words that are no longer used. It would lead to the "horseless carriage" effect for shortcuts.
- IanCal 3y agoJust delete things manually.
- kulikalov 3y agoA simple ngram index can address your concern
- sosodev 3y agoIs the universal version of this stenotype?
- NateEag 3y agoMore or less, yeah. There are different stenography systems, each with their own shortcuts and abbreviations, but at core they're all about producing large volumes of text with minimal physical effort at very high speeds. Those interested should check out http://www.openstenoproject.org/ http://www.openstenoproject.org/. A good mechanical keyboard (e.g. the ErgoDox EZ) and Plover mean the only thing standing between you and >200 WPM typing is the time and effort to learn it.
- Exuma 3y agoI hit this invisible wall at about 165 WPM that I can't just get beyond, and it kills me. I wonder how fast I could get with stenography... I see dem 400 WPM videos and they look awesome.
- jodrellblank 3y agoThe Plover / OpenSteno founder Mirabai Knight was working on Python steno a decade ago: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fu7DygveoB4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fu7DygveoB4 Longer video eight years ago: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jRFKZGWrmrM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jRFKZGWrmrM Some random YouTube video, JavaScript steno seven years ago: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RBBiri3CD6w https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RBBiri3CD6w Steno coding in Ruby, four months ago: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3W9_k2CXrXE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3W9_k2CXrXE
- SOLAR_FIELDS 3y agoCurious what kind of work you are doing where WPM is a limiting factor. I’m in software, like a lot of people here, so being able to type in speed is rarely the limiting factor. Besides stenographers, the only other line of work off the top of my head that needs this kind of speed are people who are paid to write subtitles for TV shows and movies in another language. Which I guess is just another form of stenography, when you unwrap it. Or is it not for work and it’s just purely to see how fast you can type?
- capableweb 3y ago> However, I realize that I would never want to use something like this that would change over time. E.g. if I ran it every 6 months and last year "db" produced "debug", while this year it produces "database". Because talk about messing up my muscle memory and habits. And the language I write changes very much over time. > However, I realize that I would never want to use something like this that would change over time. > And the language I write changes very much over time. Sounds like exactly you want something that evolves after time, since how you write changes over time. An universal version would maximize the amount of helpfulness on an average for everyone, but a tool that learns from your individual actions, can be much better improvement for you. And by making the tool available to everyone, more people could get bigger benefits from it, rather than just "average" benefits.
- crazygringo 3y ago> Sounds like exactly you want something that evolves after time, since how you write changes over time. No, because I don't want the shortcuts to be changing on me. That would drive me nuts. The whole point for me would be to establish new habits and then keep them. To turn into muscle memory, not something to be thinking about. It's like toolbars that "learn" which actions you're currently using the most, but the buttons are constantly moving around and are never where they were last week. It's an exercise in frustration.
- esquivalience 3y agoI think it's built and fixed until you decide to extend or modify it.
- eschluntz 3y agoYup, it doesn't run automatically for exactly this reason. It outputs "suggested_shortcuts.yaml" and I can copy and paste from that into "shortcuts.yaml" so I have manual control over which shortcuts are live :)
- Sparkyte 3y agoThis is good I can imagine all of the embarrassing auto typing. It is the reason I hate Android phones. I will be typing and it will try to predict what I am writing. Some of it not sure what data it is built on came out hilarious or down right inappropriate. Not like swears or vulgar just the punch of the expressions.
- James_Henry 3y agoYou can turn that feature off on Android phones.
- munificent 3y agoEven then, universal doesn't mean time-independent. A universal set of shortcuts trained on a giant corpus in 2018 wouldn't have a shortcut for "covid" or "pandemic" but in 2020, it would be really handy.
- anon____ 3y agoUsing a standard input method editor (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Input_method https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Input_method) solves the multiple targets problem, and it could be a universal, but customizable solution, as I explained in another comment (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37330658 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37330658).
- throwaway738393 3y ago> E.g. expanding "t" to "the" seems like a no-brainer, just like "st" to "something". Is there a minimal set of, say, 200-500 of these that could simply be turned into a "standard keyboard" that everyone could learn? Take a look at Evans Basic English Code, a shorthand system based off of Phillips Code (for telegraphs). It's a little dated, but the most common words are quite useful for writing or typing. https://archive.org/details/evansbasicenglis00evan https://archive.org/details/evansbasicenglis00evan (use the pdf, the txt file is a bad OCR and practically useless) Also useful: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Most_common_words_in_English https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Most_common_words_in_English
- zserge 3y agoI appreciate the fact that it contains shortcuts for such words as "endeavour" (EDV), "ecclesiastic" (EC), "notwithstanding" (NWG) or "vehemence" (VMC) being a dictionary of the "basic and most frequently used words". Also, the suggested abbreviation for "sex" is "SEX".
- nojs 3y ago> expanding "t" to "the" seems like a no-brainer, just like "st" to "something" I have jk mapped to escape in vim, and for a key combo that seems like it should never occur naturally, I’m often surprised how often it misfires when I actually need to type “jk”. Globally remapping hundreds of things like “t” and “st” would actually be quite frustrating I think. Like imagine you’re emailing your friend about a trip to st petersburg, or about some code containing the variable t, etc.
- theptrk 3y agoYou gotta try “fd”
- xigoi 3y agoTry mapping both jk and kj to Escape, then set 'timeout' really low in insert mode so you have to press the keys simultaneously.
- jayknight 3y ago>I have jk mapped to escape in vim, and for a key combo that seems like it should never occur naturally, I’m often surprised how often it misfires when I actually need to type “jk”. I saw that great recommendation somewhere so immediately set that up in vim. But those are my initials, and usually the beginning of my username... So took that out real quick. -jk
- vGPU 3y agoThere are a few natural ones that stand out, for example: w/ = with.
- jorvi 3y ago> E.g. expanding "t" to "the" seems like a no-brainer, just like "st" to "something". Is there a minimal set of, say, 200-500 of these that could simply be turned into a "standard keyboard" that everyone could learn? Is it a "no-brainer"? I would map "st" to "start".
- chiefbucket 3y agoSomething is quite a bit more common than start. Probably if you write any long form English, st == something is better.
- jorvi 3y agoI would map "Something" to "sth" because that is way waaay more memorable and recognizable. "Start" is something you use a lot more as a dev. That's the true no-brainer. Memorable, good mapping.
- fsckboy 3y agolooks like we have a choice, to see the Cardinals game, would you rather go to Something Louis or Start Louis? Or we could wait till they play the Twins and visit Start Paul at the same time.
- Fearlesspancake 3y agoI discovered [Yublin](https://jonaquino.blogspot.com/2007/06/yublin-shorthand-for-speed-writing.html?m=1 https://jonaquino.blogspot.com/2007/06/yublin-shorthand-for-...) a while back which set out to do exactly this: create 1-3 letter shorthands for the 600 most common words in English. And sure enough, "the -> t" is at the top of the list.
- fouronnes3 3y agoThat's really cool. If using a QMK or other configurable keyboard, I could see this being on a dedicated modifier+chords.
- water-your-self 3y agoA general solution would just be lukewarm for a lot of people. A chemist might type "dropper" often, 'dp' while a bureaucrat might prefer "department"
- beardedwizard 3y ago> a "universal" version of this -- if you ran it across books and e-mails and text messages from thousands of authors covering diverse backgrounds and contexts, then what would most reliably help everyone Isn't this approaching llm territory?
- efreak 3y agoNo, this is simple statistics. Just list all the words in your corpus in order by how frequently they're used, then use a dedicated software solution like the one given here to make shorthand from it and expand as you type. Machine learning is massive overkill for this, like nuking a fly-- it's a massive waste of resources (time, energy, energy over time, every metric I can think of), and you're going to have targeting issues at that scale (how exactly do you propose to ensure a LLM stays on target and doesn't duplicate answers, make up words, skip words, etc? Are you sure your LLM actually knows what the correct distribution is? If you know it does because you checked, doesn't that mean you already have a word list you can use?)
- beardedwizard 3y ago> No, this is simple statistics. How exactly is an llm different? I'm not sure it is, just more layers.
- fxtentacle 3y agoI was thinking the exact same thing. That sounds like a small ByT5 LLM model. Upon space you auto-complete the past word based on a moving context window of the past 32 characters or so.
- offices 3y agoYes, LLMs and text compression are the same problem: guessing what comes next.
- xigoi 3y agoNo. Unlike LLMs, it's a simple deterministic algorithm.