3 ms·
This is obviously not true. If you're in a municipality in the US (if you're not, none of this matters anyways), you can probably go to the website for that mun
by tptacek 3y ago
This is obviously not true. If you're in a municipality in the US (if you're not, none of this matters anyways), you can probably go to the website for that municipality and look it up; the franchise contracts for mine are the first search result, and they spell out the fees that Comcast are required to charge.
The reason I'm on this hobby horse is that I serve on my local village telecom commission and, after 2 years of zoning out and playing solitaire whenever the "franchise agreement" came up as a topic, I finally paid attention and learned that we were making high six figures every year in our general fund charging Comcast users a Comcast tax. It's a thing my commission works on: just how much we should soak local ISP users.
We've gone for several years without a franchise contract renewal because, apparently, Comcast doesn't want to do this anymore. I don't blame them!
- tialaramex 3y ago> We've gone for several years without a franchise contract renewal And so as a result there's no Internet in your village and you just realised you aren't actually posting on HN and the reply has vanished in a puff of logic? No?
- tptacek 3y agoI have no idea what you're trying to say here. No, obviously, we still have Internet access --- the current franchise agreement remains in force until we finally renegotiate a new one, which is stalled over these pass-through fees. I'm still not clear on what your original objection was to my comment. Do you really not understand what a municipal pass-through fee is? I mean, why would you, but: the concept isn't that hard to grasp, right? It's a tax that the municipality requires the ISP to collect.
- tialaramex 3y ago> It's a tax that the municipality requires the ISP to collect. Really? How does this requirement supposedly work to your understanding? What exactly would happen if Comcast charged the wrong amount of tax to some customers. Do the customers get a receipt so that they know they've paid the correct local taxes? The reality is that your village taxes Comcast via this "franchise agreement". Comcast have no obligation to "pass through" that cost to their customers in your village, they choose to charge opaque and vague extra "fees" which may or may not be adjusted according to the tax, and you are (presumably inadvertently) now here arguing that a giant corporation is the victim because they have to pay taxes like everybody else.
- tptacek 3y agoWe would sue them, and collect in state court. The contract literally stipulates the fees as "passed through" to subscribers. You've writing very confidently here, but, again: this is one of the rare instances where I have strong opinions about things because I've had to work with them. I have the impression that I've read a franchise contract, and you haven't. Am I wrong?
- tialaramex 3y ago> We would sue them, and collect in state court. That would work if Comcast didn't pay you but that's not the scenario under discussion, I asked what happens if they don't charge their customers exactly what you wanted and the answer is "Nothing". You don't have standing to insist Comcast charge this fee to their customers, that's between Comcast and their customers. > I have the impression that I've read a franchise contract, and you haven't. Am I wrong? I have the impression that you haven't read the enabling law for this, and you've assumed that "pass through" establishes some sort of magical tax at a distance when it's merely permission for them to pass these taxes on to their customers. Comcast are not, in fact, required to do this but they choose to do so. Specifically the 1934 Communications Act (yeah, I know, that's a super old law, it was updated to explain how cable TV works) tells cable companies that they may pass through such franchise fees to their end customer. Note the word used, not "must".
- taeric 3y agoThis is still misrepresenting it, though? They are free to not pass the fees through directly to users. They are required to pay the fee to the municipality. These are not, necessarily, linked things. You are correct that it would somewhat increase their costs, such that they may have to increase their billing rate, but they are in no way required to pass the bill through directly to the customer. Note that this is very different from taxes. Those are typically collected by the business, but owed by the purchaser. Right?
- tptacek 3y agoI'm having trouble understanding how they are anything other than taxes. They're called "pass-through fees" because the underlying contracts (or, in some cases, statutes) set the expectation that they'll be passed directly to the consumer. They're fees governments charge to their residents, through service providers, for services the government does not itself provide. They're not even tolls. They're taxes. I like taxes! I'm a Democrat! But I think these particular taxes are pretty shady.
- taeric 3y agoSnidely, they aren't taxes for the simple reason that I couldn't itemize them in federal deductions. That isn't quite as relevant nowadays, I suppose. There is also usually a benefit for Comcast in this, as well. As such, it feels somewhat ok to treat them separate from taxes collected by Comcast. In particular, it is not uncommon for the franchise agreement to free up a ton of advertising concerns that the company would otherwise have to do. I do think an interesting question is if this is counted as revenue for them? I'm currently assuming that they do count it in gross revenue? As such, it is literally them finding a way to get more revenue for places that cost more to do business, without open faced charging more. That is, yes it is an expense that they have to pay, but so is, for example, the gas they have to pay to send a technician out. For that matter, the vehicle is also an expense of doing business. I'd be annoyed if those were line item added to my bill as a way to inflate what I paid. Not sure how this is any different?
- 3y ago