6 ms·
They're obviously not lying. NCTA's letter made the issue clear: retail stores have items pre-labeled, and, under this new rule, they'd need to create thousands
by tptacek 3y ago
They're obviously not lying. NCTA's letter made the issue clear: retail stores have items pre-labeled, and, under this new rule, they'd need to create thousands of variations of those labels. Unlike sales tax, where the business always knows what it's going to be charging every customer, pass-through fees vary based on the customer's home address.
Again: these aren't fees Comcast chooses to charge; it's money local governments are taxing from their residents, piggybacking on the ISP billing system.
- YeBanKo 3y agoSales tax depends on your zip code as well, so it is very much like sales tax.
- wolverine876 3y agoThat's NCTA's claim, and we should consider their side, but maybe we shouldn't take it all at face value?
- tptacek 3y agoWe can take what they're objecting to at face value, because they're the ones objecting. So when I say that NCTA is objecting only to pass-through fees, I feel like I'm on pretty firm ground, because they have not objected to other labeling requirements.
- wolverine876 3y agoI'm not saying we should ignore NCTA's public statements, but I'm sure you know that parties who are sophisticated public communicators will object to the thing they are most likely to win on, and which will gain them the most support, rather than the thing they care about most. It happens all the time in public discourse, in politics and in business. Thinking about it, that of course is fundamental to sophisticated negotiations - not revealing your true objectives. And thinking more, people use that same tactic instinctively all the time in social situations.
- tptacek 3y agoThis doesn't make sense. They've conceded the rest of the issues, and were asking for a concession exclusively on this issue. You should read NCTA's filing.
- resist_futility 3y agoThey already know what the fees are from, they just don't want to tell the consumer. How else would they calculate them?
- WWLink 3y ago"NCTA's letter made the issue clear: retail stores have items pre-labeled, and, under this new rule, they'd need to create thousands of variations of those labels." That's a bunch of bullshit though. The cable companies use vastly different pricing all over the place, so there's already "thousands of variations of those labels" - in fact I'm pretty sure those labels are produced regionally.
- tptacek 3y agoSo we're clear: we're talking about labeling requirements that can change multiple times within the span of 10 blocks or so. This isn't a regional problem; it's about as local as it gets.
- venusenvy47 3y agoI'm not sure what they are referring to with "label", but anytime I look for Internet service online the first thing they ask for is my address. So they can easily present the proper "label" on the webpage that they show me.
- amphitoky 3y agoso why not regulate the other end too and force more consistency and transparency in pass-through fees as well?
- tptacek 3y agoBecause Home Rule prevents those regulations.
- ckozlowski 3y ago"it's money local governments are taxing from their residents, piggybacking on the ISP billing system." I'm sympathetic to the point, and this feels like there's area for compromise here. Something along the lines of "We'll gladly support this change if local governments stop hiding taxes behind us." I have to believe the NCTA made this issue clear; I wonder then if the FCC noticed, and if so, why there isn't a similar directive levied at municipalities to stop this practice? To be clear, I fully support forcing ISPs to be transparent, period. But that is a messy issue they're dealing with, and I feel like there could easily a co-argument to localities to stop making it hard for them to be transparent. Edit: Just saw your comment below about Home Rule. Drat.
- tptacek 3y agoMostly my subtext here is that municipalities should stop being so sneaky with their taxes and just come out and bill residents directly, instead of pretending that their taxes are just Comcast being greedy.
- ckozlowski 3y agoI sense that perhaps a lawsuit targeting this practice might be incoming then, if the FCC forces them to proceed.
- tptacek 3y agoOn what basis would they sue the municipalities?
- Avshalom 3y agoThe FCC did notice. from the article: Providers are free, of course, to not pass these fees through to consumers
- tptacek 3y agoThat's even less transparent!
- vel0city 3y agoIf they want to simplify their marketing, just roll all those extra fees into their final price. I have that currently with my AT&T internet bill, the amount my card gets charged every month is the same as what it was advertised.
- tptacek 3y agoThey're not allowed to do that.
- vel0city 3y agoWell, they do, I don't understand why they wouldn't be allowed to. Same thing with my cell phone bill through Mint, other than regular sales tax all the other telecom fees are all rolled into their price. They just mess around with their actual price until the final price lines up with their marketing. Its not exactly challenging math.
- usefulcat 3y agoI don't understand that statement. I have Google fiber and AFAICT that's exactly what they do, and have done for as long as I've been a customer. Before buying, I only ever saw one advertised price for this particular product, and since becoming a customer I only ever see that same price on the statements they send me each month.
- tptacek 3y agoMy understanding is that they are being required by the FCC to break these fees out, though someone else on the thread claims otherwise and for all I know is correct. Either way: hiding the fees and raising their rates does the opposite of what people want from this FCC ruling!
- smsm42 3y ago> ISPs could alternatively roll such discretionary fees into the base monthly price, thereby eliminating the need to itemize them on the label. That's right from the article. I don't know what "people" want, I just want the quoted price to match the billed one.
- Guvante 3y agoThere is an explicit exemption for mandatory charges. If Comcast decides to change it's rate because of those fees it can explain that.
- tptacek 3y agoAgain: they are exclusively objecting to labeling requirement for pass-through fees.
- Guvante 3y agoWhat makes something a pass through fee? Does access to a conduit count? Does sales tax count? Pass-through fees is a vague category that effectively means "I spent money" which is useless.
- tptacek 3y agoThe contracts with cities literally refer to them as "pass-through fees", explaining that they "pass through" to subscribers. People act like this stuff is complicated or unknowable, but you're a Google search away from reading a franchise agreement. Most cities have them, and they're public records.
- Guvante 3y agoThe only justification for avoiding displaying them is wanting to hide something. To your point actual pass through fees are transparent. So what don't they want to show you? The claim of packaging is a crock of shit. Cox won't give me a quote without an exact address since thanks to ISPs building up pseudo monopolies they charge everyone something different. If it is actually a package you can't list the final price due to that anyway. After all you don't know where someone lives based on where they buy something. Remember if you have to deal with quoting accurately you did all of the work to label properly.
- tptacek 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nimish 3y agoFTA: >ISPs can meet the label requirement in alternate sales channels either by providing a hard copy of the label or by "directing the consumer to the specific web page on which the label appears." There's already lookups for sales tax. If they can bill the address the fees, they can show the fees to the customer.
- tptacek 3y agoNo: retail businesses don't need to "look up" their sales tax, because it doesn't change per customer.
- paledot 3y agoExcept when it does, as in the case of status Indian people in Canada, who are exempt from sales tax. I'll take Falsehoods Programmers Believe About for 200.
- brimwats 3y agoI think you mean Indigenous people, as the Indians in my neighborhood in Vancouver aren't exempt from PST or GST
- paledot 3y agoFWIW, "First Nations" is generally the preferred term in Canada. But the relevant law is the Indian Act, not the Indigenous Act or the First Nations Act.
- tomek_ycomb 3y agoNo, I think they mean status Indian. It's a Canadian designation. Their own (the Canadian) government webpage agrees with you that's it's outdated. I'm just commenting because the difference between him saying "status Indian" vs "indigenous Canadians" and "Indian Canadians [meaning indigenous]" is in having said status first Tbh. I didn't know this either. But it seemed so specific to say "status" so I looked it up. Til for me "About Indian status Find out more about entitlement, benefits and registration under the Indian Act and the Indian Register. Use of the term "Indian" Many Indigenous people in Canada prefer not to describe themselves as "Indians" and view this term as rooted in colonialism and racism. Under the Indian Act, the precise legal meaning of the term "Indian" refers to First Nations persons who are entitled to registration."
- daft_pink 3y agoI just want to point out that while it might be true there are some local fees included that are hyper local and hard to disclose. Where I live Comcast and other providers advertise fake low rates, and then tack on multiple surcharges and cost recovery fees that they refuse to disclose, should be considered false advertising, and make it impossible to compare between the different relevant services, because the fees represent more than 20% of your bill.
- tptacek 3y agoNCTA isn't complaining about anything but the pass-through fees.
- whatwhaaaaat 3y agoYes but if you label all the pass-through fees then everything else is a non pass through fee right?
- tptacek 3y agoI don't understand your question, sorry.
- whatwhaaaaat 3y agoYou have fees. Some are government and some are actually just cost of getting the service - modem rental fee or bring your own modem fee. The pass through government fees get labeled as such (small township build rights fee). The other non government fees that are really just the price of the service are now clear because the government fees are labeled.
- paledot 3y agoMy understanding is that under the new rule all fees must be labelled, both real and made-up.
- 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tialaramex 3y ago> these aren't fees Comcast chooses to charge These are, in fact, fees Comcast chooses to charge. This reminds me of the confusion of some other employees when a start-up I was working for got purchased. The new owners proposed that we should sign documents agreeing certain conditions in exchange for which they'd pay us a "bonus" of an amount to be determined by a complicated formula at the end of their financial year. So I glance at this document, it's as I think, and I explain this document requires you to work for them for a period of time, it's a weaker version of the document the senior people are signing or have signed -- but unlike theirs it doesn't actually pay us ordinary employees any money - therefore I explain you should not sign if you think you might want to work somewhere else any time soon. e.g. if your role makes no sense as part of the larger entity and you've got better things to do with your life rather than collect a salary for a few months until they realise you aren't necessary and fire you. I got widespread objections - it has a bonus scheme. Yeah, the way that scheme works their accountants are going to decide whether they pay us money in a year's time. Guess what those accountants are going to say? They're going to say "No". If they wanted to pay us money, they would just pay us money as they did with our management. Employers can always pay you money. There is tax due on it if they do, but that's their problem not yours. When an employer doesn't give you money the reason is that they don't want to give you money. Don't ask for another explanation, it's demeaning for them to have to pretend and for you to listen. In a year's time I got a call from the CTO, an old friend, was I on that bonus scheme? Yes, I said, it doesn't matter to me (then or now). He was warning people because he'd been tipped off that of course it was worthless, exactly as I had said, but whoever had told him had seen the numbers from the accountants now. Comcast can choose not to charge these fees, but it wants to. It would like to be able to say "Our price is $49.99" and then bill you say $84 per month and blame the difference on vague "fees". They only need to justify how that adds up to $84 in the case that someone works very hard, maybe a journalist working on a story about rip off ISPs. And if it's bullshit? They just say "Oops" and refund some fees when caught if their lawyers tell them that's cheapest. In the UK for a long time ISPs would claim their charges didn't match the advertised price because it didn't include a fee they paid to BT Openreach, the incumbent telco whose copper cables they're using to provide service. In a way they were telling the truth, Openreach did charge them a fee. Unfortunately that fee is published by law, fairly small, and it had been steadily going down, because "maintaining some copper cables under the street" isn't expensive. On the other hand the fee these ISPs would add to the supposed "price" for consumers was larger and going up over time. Eventually the regulator told them to knock it off with this bullshit and just tell people the actual price including this mandatory fee.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- JoeAltmaier 3y agoAgain, this is spurious. They can create the bill; they can label the charges on the bill. That's inarguable.
- babypuncher 3y agoThis argument carries no weight. Comcast doesn't show me prices until I give them my address, at which point they have all of the data necessary to show me the actual price. This is not a difficult problem for them to solve, they just don't want to do it because these companies are run by greedy shitgibbons who don't want to tell you the actual price of their product until the last possible second.
- tptacek 3y agoHow I know this is false is that NCTA's compromise offer was to quote customers the maximum possible fee (nonbinding) in lieu of tracking down the specific fee from the customer's zip code, which would allow them to pre-label retail SKUs, which is the problem they are trying to solve. I know "shitgibbon" is fun to write and Comcast is a convenient punching bag (I don't like them either), but they're not as straightforwardly the villain in this story as articles like these want to pretend.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tareqak 3y agoThat's a technical problem though right? The ISP could create state/county/parish/municipal maps that show which passthrough fees are in effect. Putting that on a bill would be difficult I agree. What about listing the ceiling of the passthrough fees e.g. <$7.00 ?
- smsm42 3y agoThey don't have to pass on the fees, it's their choice. Too hard? Charge fixed price, eat the fees and save the troubles. Want to nickel and dime instead? Disclose it then.
- tptacek 3y agoThis doesn't make much sense as an objection. It's not Comcast that came up with the idea of charging subscribers these fees; it's their own local governments, who wrote contracts requiring fees to be passed through to the customers.
- smsm42 3y agoSo your claim is that when the FDA says this: > ISPs could alternatively roll such discretionary fees into the base monthly price, thereby eliminating the need to itemize them on the label. they are lying and flat rate pricing is prohibited by the FDA? As somebody who does pay flat rate (not to Comcast) I wonder how my provider did pull off such an illegal feat. Also, T-mobile (not exactly an ISP but also a telecom) has "fees and taxes included" flat rate, and they are charging exactly as stated. Would be weird if this prohibition were applying only to ISPs but not to mobile providers?
- patmorgan23 3y agoThey obviously ARE lying. Either a) they have the information to be compliant and pay all applicable fees or b) NCTA is admitting that the entire industry is chronically non-compliant and every state/municipality needs to launch an audit of every ISP.
- protocolture 3y agoI dont understand why you are getting downvoted, you are completely correct.
- gamblor956 3y agoThat is simply wrong. FTA: "Comcast and other ISPs objected to a requirement that ISPs "list all recurring monthly fees" including "all charges that providers impose at their discretion, i.e., charges not mandated by a government.""