3 ms·
Innocent person in jail means that guilty person walked free. If it is easy to lock Innocent people, justice system has no incentive to try to figure out who re
by watwut 3y ago
Innocent person in jail means that guilty person walked free. If it is easy to lock Innocent people, justice system has no incentive to try to figure out who really did it.
Result is easily that then you have both more innocent people in prison and more guilty people being free.
- bee_rider 3y agoExactly. The expression sets up a relationship: more strict and more effective vs less strict and less effective, and asks us how much effectiveness we’re willing to give up in exchange for safety. This just misses the point, a legal system that locks up innocent people instead of guilty ones is just not doing a good job. I think it is well intended (at least for values of n much greater than 1) but harmful.
- cornholio 3y agoThe problem of "n" does not completely go away even in a much improved legal system. Assuming you can identify the killer 99.99% correctly with absolute certainty, you will still have that one in ten thousand case where the killer is not precisely known, but there is 50%, 90%, 99% probability it's them, that is, you risk to convict one innocent man for every n = 1, 10, 100 guilty persons in those rare cases. So the efficiency of the criminal system and the problem of "n" are somewhat orthogonal: the first is an issue of effective governance, the second is a political choice faced by any practical (thus, imperfect) system of governance.