6 ms·
Could the Universe be a giant quantum computer?
- az09mugen 3y agoA small contribution to this big topic from xkcd since I haven't seen it : https://xkcd.com/224/ https://xkcd.com/224/
- mcculley 3y agoYes. I see a lot of speculation about the possibility that our universe is a simulation. But our experience with inadvertently building Turing-complete systems makes me wonder if our universe is running on something that is just a side-effect of some other computation and not something deliberately constructed. Someone in the enclosing universe could fix a bug and suspend or destroy our universe. Or the computational substrate on which our universe executes is just some natural process in the enclosing universe, like sea foam or solar flares.
- gremlinsinc 3y agoha, how weird it'd be if we're just a bug and not the feature. Totally throws the idea of a god out, I mean sure a programmer launched our instance but we were created totally by accident.
- maxhille 3y ago"just some random test deployment" I wonder what the automated tests will look like to us...
- dsego 3y agoI've recently had this really bizarre intuitive insight telling me I'm just living out the actions that were either pre-recorded as a movie or are computed along the way, and I'm just perceiving it as my actions and my will, like my own volition is just another type of experience or an illusion and not a real phenomenon. Hard to explain, it's very elusive. Another insight was that my internal observer is a separate entity, one that might survive death and isn't really related to my intelligence or personality, but is limited by them (like driving a slow car).
- amitprayal 3y agoyou have probably read some vedanta book or snippet from the book
- lostmsu 3y ago> Someone in the enclosing universe could fix a bug and suspend or destroy our universe. It is not as simple. See Permutation City. TL;DR; from a perspective of a person living in Game of Life, your time doesn't rewind when the computer running it rewinds the state.
- mcculley 3y agoI did not say that the state was reversible. If you are trying to say that non-reversibility implies that state cannot be destroyed, we would need more than your TLDR.
- lostmsu 3y agoThe hoop from TL;DR; is that what happens with the simulation hardware has no bearing on the universe defined by the laws of the simulation. Reversibility is just an example. By changing simulation you just choose a different universe to look at.
- mcculley 3y agoThis would provide comfort to residents of a simulation who still think the self is something other than an illusion.
- rendall 3y agoHow likely would it be that the Universe is an instance of some recent technology that humans created?
- junon 3y agoThis makes no sense whatsoever.
- rendall 3y agoI've seen articles speculating that the Universe is a computer, a simulation, and a hologram. There are serious scholarly speculations that the Universe is a clock, a machine, or a book.
- AtlasBarfed 3y agoThat statement (the universe, which is what we seemingly evolved and grew in, was created by ... us? we are our own creator?) is so circular and illogical that it is actually ingenious. Like humans existed in some other existence, but we were going to get Gnab Gib'd, so we ensured that the next universe would inevitably rise to precisely recreate us through a convoluted 4 billion year evolutionary program in a tiny speck of dirt in one of billions of galaxies? It's like some convoluted anime/manga plotline that occurs in the final stages of a 10-15 year run. Or heck, like the infamous "Dallas" plot element from the 1980s: THE ENTIRE SERIES WAS JUST A DREAM. Or "Lost". It does seem that quantum mechanics hints at the universe being some bizarre gigantic n-dimensional computational matrix, but that's probably because of the discrete quantities and rigid math and things like hard orbits/energy level jumps which seem a lot like memory assignment or cellular automata.
- rendall 3y agoI want to object that the OP et. al. are not arguing that humans created the Universe, but, riding their argument to its logical extremes, that must be the argument. A quantum computer- or a simulation - is a technology that serves human needs and interests. Therefore, if the Universe were an instance of human technology, the Universe is created by humans QED. I suppose though that the OP would argue that these technologies would be universally useful, so to speak, and therefore not necessarily created by humans. Not a good argument, but it seems to be the underlying assumption.
- pseudolus 3y agoLink to the referenced New York Times obituary for Edward Fredkin: https://www.nytimes.com/2023/07/04/science/edward-fredkin-dead.html https://www.nytimes.com/2023/07/04/science/edward-fredkin-de...
- baerrie 3y agoNo. If you expand the definition of a computer to be any somewhat organized system, maybe. Then you could argue all life is is just a simulation within the system of Earths elements and forces because said forces led to our existence and “organized” our own bodies processes
- gremlinsinc 3y agoThere's code that resembles error correcting code that is used in browsers inside physics calculations. We're nearly able ourselves to create a full universal computer simulation. There's arbitrary speed limits or other 'settings'like a clicker game might have. Speed of light, planks constant, etc... The fact we haven't seen any life could mean we're the only life simulated. The entire universe needn't even exist just our perception that it does, we see it, we can observe but maybe we're just observing facts fed to us if things that should be there in a universe of infinite size. Perhaps the speed limits are set because of size limits of existing hardware. it's easier to believe than there being a god, or the universe could be conscience and we're simulated like a dream is simulated in our subconscious.
- nologic01 3y agoCould Nature turn from one of the most respected academic journals to a clickbaiting blogging outfit in the space of a decade? [1]. The post rehashes some old and sterile ideas. The most recent reference is a preprint from 2013. Alas the zeitgeist is conducive to "bits will eat the world". Here is a more radical idea: Could the Universe be a giant Universe? (= a recursive function). Maybe its Universes all the way down? [1] Apparently yes
- djmips 3y agoSomething 10 years old isn't a measure of irrelevance.
- nologic01 3y agoIn our day and age a decade of no publication or follow up is definitely a measure of something - there is more than enough talented and agitating spirits around to pursue wild ideas. Thats why I picked the word "sterile".
- aradox66 3y agoSort of begs the question, doesn't it? Just kicks the existential mystery one step up the ontological ladder.
- garciasn 3y agoYes, of course it begs the question: that's the whole point of science. To explore and provide hypotheses which can be studied and potentially eventually proven when we can gain enough evidence at a later time. The problem with the universe is that, right now, we operate entirely within its confines and we know we don't even fully understand its physics, let alone any sort of 'physics' which may operate outside of it--should there be something outside of it. Unless something changes in our view of the universe, this will very likely remain a philosophical question, likely for our entire existence and the existence of whatever intelligent life forms replace the human race several times over in the coming billions of years of this planet.
- earthboundkid 3y agoNo, for the same reason it's not a vehicle even though it has many moving parts. A vehicle is something used to transport an agent. A computer is something used to do computation for an agent. Computation is the process of making reliable, rule-driven inferences about one system from another. If the universe is considered as a whole, there is no second system to which to applies the inferences made using the universe as a first system.
- hirundo 3y ago> there is no second system to which to applies the inferences made using the universe as a first system This is as much speculation as a statement that such a system does exist.
- earthboundkid 3y agoIn this case, the word "universe" means everything there is. If there's some kind of comic book like "multiverse", it's really just one "universe" with different pockets. It's not actually multiple "universes." I guess we can't rule out that someone is using Earth as a computer, but if they were, you'd expect the mice to get better cheese.
- karol 3y agoIt could even be a sewer system if that's your obsession.
- maxhille 3y agoCarl Sagan's view on these matters: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=lH7H9d28BR8 https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=lH7H9d28BR8 Although he talks about Gods and Creation, I think the same argument applies to the Simulation Hypothesis aswell.
- Swizec 3y agoObviously the universe is a giant computer. We’re calculating the question to 42. There’s a whole documentary about this!
- veltas 3y agoThe documentary's been on display at the Alpha Centauri planning office for the last fifty years, it's not my fault you have not got around to inventing stellar travel yet.
- karaterobot 3y agoI'm getting good at remembering that it's called Betteridge's law. I used to have to look it up, but I'm getting so much practice that I think it's finally started to stick.
- thereikiway 3y agoCould Nature speculate any more lately?
- okonomiyaki3000 3y agoI think the answer is obvious. It is and it isn't.
- lo_zamoyski 3y agoThere are a few problems with this claim, as well as the general idea that the universe is a computer. tl;dr: the claim doesn't even make sense, except perhaps in some figurative sense. First, what a computer is cannot be identified with any physical system, because computation is observer-relative. There is no fact of the matter that some physical system is performing computations. Computation is not a natural kind. We can harness physical phenomena "computer-wise", that is, use physical phenomena to simulate computation, but it makes no sense to identify computation with physical phenomena as such. That physical phenomena involve quantities that can be computed does not mean the phenomena are performing computations as such. A simpler example of something analogous is a book. The print in a book, physically, is just a series of pigmented spots on sheets of something made of plant fiber. Physically, it isn't even "writing" per se, as writing is not a natural kind, but what we call the result of the act of writing. The pigmented spots on plant fiber are the only content, physically, of what is in a book. The content we think of when we speak of books is brought to the book by the reader who interprets the marks on the pages according to what he already has in his head. This is what reading is: interpretation, assigning meaning. The same is true of computers. Physically, no computation is occurring. Second, computation is about something. When a physicist or engineer computes the current in a circuit, he isn't manifesting the circuit. He is computing something about the circuit. Computation is an abstract activity of the mind. (We can use this in an argument against materialism.) Third, part of the reason why this identification of computation with physics is likely occurring is because the methodology or methodologies of physics necessarily strip reality of much of its substance and leave us with a mathematical, formal model expressed in computational terms. Guess what else is a formal model that involves computation? This allows us to talk about the formal equivalence or subsumption or whatever of physical models and computational models. That such a relationship exists isn't that surprising in retrospect.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoFor those thinking 'computer' like we are executing on some system outside of our reality, then I think "no". But, if we take that the universe has rules, and all particles are following a wave function, and interacting. Then it is ok to think of our universe as 'executing functions'. So our universe is self executing, like a computer. There is no randomness, just rules we haven't discovered. See Super Determinism.
- sambeau 3y agoIsn't this all just René Descartes's Demon, the 'Deus Deceptor' that he proposed in his 'Meditations on First Philosophy' in 1641. Are we doing anything more than updating his question to our latest technology? Is there a fundamental difference between this and, say, 'The Truman Show'? Other than a more sophisticated layer of MacGuffin. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evil_demon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evil_demon [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meditations_on_First_Philosophy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meditations_on_First_Philosoph... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Truman_Show https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Truman_Show
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- I_Am_Nous 3y agoI have a hypothesis that the double slit experiment provides evidence that the universe is simulated. It always makes me wonder if photons act as waves when unobserved because it's easier to simulate the general area a particle could end up to save computing costs. However, when observed, the simulation must make the granular calculations and show where that individual particle actually ended up. It also calls into question how much we can learn about the beginning of our universe. We are "trapped" by the physics of our universe so there may be no grand explanation of where all the energy came from. If the universe is simulated it's not like we're going to suddenly get down to the source code, there will just be a distinct point when the universe booted and all the stuff started happening.
- az09mugen 3y agoI like a lot your point of view. And maybe this is a proof of some granularity of our simulated universe. But on the other hand, I can't remove the idea from my brain that maybe there is some kind of hidden variable/dimension/other-concept-we-can't-be-aware-of at the source of this phenomenon explaining perfectly why we see it that way. Our science knew a big expansion since the beginning of 20th century thanks to some geniuses. And now I have the feeling there is no more 'science explosion' coming. Sure, there are some good intuitions, but nothing concrete or testable. Everything nowadays lies on these fancy ideas to prove them or push them to their corners. But nothing really appealing, it's just some 'monkey testing' of our universe. LK-99 : false hope, string theory: too much variable and kinda not testable, dark matter or lambda CDM : nothing going towards the confirmation. Sure, the math/physics models predict a lot of stuff, but nothing incredible. I have the feeling something big is missing to understand our universe, but we're not working in that direction. Sorry, needed to vent. Still, I like your idea.
- I_Am_Nous 3y agoWe are only just starting to experiment with quantum systems and I have hope that there are still many things we can discover. Our understanding of light alone is kind of brain breaking in some ways. It acts like a particle and a wave, but it always has a wavelength even as a single photon. And a photon is more of a quantized description of a certain amount of light energy than an actual particle with mass, as I understand it. It all stems from a certain fluctuation in a specific quantum field, so we may be able to discover properties which allow us to manipulate these as well as other quantum fields. For me it kind of boils down to the more we understand reality, the more complex it becomes, and it always has more layers. We don't truly understand what reality even is, and can only experience certain parts of it with our senses. So have no fear, the drive to understand what is going on around us is a very human trait and we have built some of the best tools in the history of humanity in only the last 60 years. There's a lot of runway left on science :)
- karmakaze 3y agoThere's no reason it needs to be a quantum computer. It can be a simple device, it only needs enough memory. How slow the calculations are doesn't matter because it controls the 'tick's. We'd basically be frozen in a frame of time until the next computation was done rendering.