5 ms·
That, plus that the ease with which the virus jumped back to animals (deer, hamsters, mice, ferrets, cats, dogs) makes the search for a reservoir animal very di
by jacquesm 3y ago
That, plus that the ease with which the virus jumped back to animals (deer, hamsters, mice, ferrets, cats, dogs) makes the search for a reservoir animal very difficult, as well as the fair chance that there were few enough of those (possibly only one) that that part of the evidence chain may well remain broken.
- jahnu 3y agoWouldn't our extensive records of the variants so far make it possible to see if a variant discovered in bats tomorrow is newer than the one that started the original outbreak in humans?
- jacquesm 3y agoIf the differences are large enough: yes. If not then it may remain undecided. The closest match found in the wild so far is 96% or so, which is good but not good enough (and it was found in a bat, but relatively far away from the spot where it was first found in humans). I think that is the most recent state of affairs.
- stringsandchars 3y ago> but relatively far away from the spot where it was first found in humans But not far away from humans who had been to where the bat virus was found to bring back samples for analysis and experimentation in their laboratory [1] [1] spoiler alert: the Wuhan Institute of Virology
- jacquesm 3y agoSo? That's what they do at that institute. The only reason that that bat was far away from where it was first found in humans is simply because we haven't found a better sample, yet. This was iirc a sample taken long ago, so there was plenty of time for migration. Bats fly insanely long distances and can have multiple roosts. What all lab-leak theory adherents seem to forget: if the Chinese really had ready access to the very earliest strains of COVID they could have easily falsified evidence of where it originated. The fact that this hasn't happened is - especially given what is at stake here - pretty good circumstantial evidence that they not have access to that strain. I suspect it will take a long time (years, maybe as much as a decade) before the whole picture will come out and if not then too bad, it will be one of those things we'll never know. Which is entirely in line with expectations, and with the historical record of other discoveries like that. In the meantime: speculation is pointless. Either you have evidence or you don't. And [] do not confer any special insights unless actually accompanied by a citation, preferably of something that is not written by the same author.
- stringsandchars 3y ago> That, plus that the ease with which the virus jumped back to animals It is trivial to tell whether a variant is antecedent - this is how the absurd 'double jump' of lineage A and lineage B was necessary for Worobey to justify his thesis that the wet market was the origin of covid... twice
- jacquesm 3y agoWithout commenting on Worobey's thesis: > It is trivial to tell whether a variant is antecedent I'm sure all of the evolutionary biologists would love to have your level of confidence. It's trivial when the differences and the timescales are large (and even then we get it wrong plenty of times). But it isn't trivial at all when the differences are minor and the timescales are close, in fact it can be really, really hard. Fortunately with COVID19 a lot of evidence was gathered in real time and preserved so there are a lot of theories that can be ruled out based on that. One of the hardest problems is to figure out when there is an individual where more than one virus took hold at the same time and genetic material was exchanged between two strains rather than just a mutation. There is some - but inconclusive - evidence that this happened more than once during the COVID pandemic.
- stringsandchars 3y ago> I'm sure all of the evolutionary biologists would love to have your level of confidence. It's easy to say this, as neither you nor I have the requisite knowledge to prove/disprove your assertion. But I read threads like this one [1] or resources like this one [2] and realize that there are experts who are able to distinguish earlier and later variants. Incidentally, I noticed that you edited your first response several times while I wrote this. The tone of what you wrote first was a bit less considered than the what I'm responding to now, but I hope it's ok to just leave it at this. [1] https://nitter.net/ydeigin/status/1695588327540347329 https://nitter.net/ydeigin/status/1695588327540347329 [2] https://github.com/jbloom/PRJNA692319_public https://github.com/jbloom/PRJNA692319_public
- jacquesm 3y ago