3 ms·
For context, this is a paper by Avi Loeb [1,2], the "Oumuamua is an interstellar spaceship" researcher. In this paper, Avi explores a possible interstellar ori
by echelon 3y ago
For context, this is a paper by Avi Loeb [1,2], the "Oumuamua is an interstellar spaceship" researcher.
In this paper, Avi explores a possible interstellar origin meteorite. He used data from US air defence senors that had tracked a highly unusual atmospheric entry nearly a decade ago. This object was theorized as a possible extrasolar trajectory meteorite when it had entered the earth's atmosphere. [3,4]
Avi recently chartered a research expedition in an attempt to dredge up samples of this meteorite from the sea floor.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avi_Loeb https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avi_Loeb
[2] https://youtu.be/plcc6E-E1uU https://youtu.be/plcc6E-E1uU
[3] https://youtu.be/lD8xgJLcbjI https://youtu.be/lD8xgJLcbjI
[4] https://www.nytimes.com/2023/07/24/science/avi-loeb-extraterrestrial-life.html https://www.nytimes.com/2023/07/24/science/avi-loeb-extrater...
- Zetice 3y agoFrom this very paper: > Another possibility is that this unfamiliar abundance pattern may reflect an extraterrestrial technological origin. Gotta love unsubstantiated paradigm-destroying claims thrown in casually at the tail end of papers...
- anigbrowl 3y agoYou don't have to substantiate possibilities. My takeaway was that the meteorite was asserted to be extrasolar, might be the result of some cosmic explosion, might be something else.
- Zetice 3y agoYou absolutely have to substantiate possibilities; otherwise we could just list off anything that comes to mind endlessly. There must be a reason why this possibility is worth mentioning but not all of the other unsubstantiated ones.
- anigbrowl 3y agoNo. Artificial alloys exist; we know because we make them all the time. Since we don't know what natural process might yield this particular material (yet) there's always the possibility that it's artificial. You're demanding the proof before the investigation.
- maxbond 3y agoConsider that "possibility" as it's used here is really a synonym for "hypothesis". Do you really think it's unreasonable to criticize a research paper for presenting an unsubstantiated hypothesis? Do you think including snippets like this serves more to advance scientific understanding, or Loeb's profile in the media and podcast circuit?
- anigbrowl 3y agoIt's not a hypothesis, which asserts something may be true and proposes tests. It's just conjecture, enumerating a variety of possible explanations for a puzzling discovery. IT's restrained and not conclusory. Scientists are allowed to have imagination and speculate. Y'all are making out like he's arrogantly asserting this is the only possible explanation. This is the actual quote (citations omitted for readability): The “BeLaU" abundance pattern suggests that IM1 may have originated from a highly differentiated crust of a planet with an iron core outside the solar system. In that case, IM1’s high speed of ∼ 60 km s−1 in the Local Standard of Rest of the Milky Way galaxy and the extremely large number of similar objects per star, ∼ 1023±1295, inferred statistically for the population of natural interstellar objects it represents, are challenging to explain by common dynamical processes. The “BeLaU" overabundance of heavy elements could perhaps have instead originated from r-process enrichment and fragmentation of ejecta from core-collapse supernovae or neutron star mergers. However, the “BeLaU" pattern also displays s-process enrichment which must have a separate origin, such as Asymptotic Giant Branch (AGB) stars. Another possibility is that this unfamiliar abundance pattern may reflect an extraterrestrial technological origin. These interpretations will be considered critically along with additional results from spherule analysis in future publications. Quit with the pearl-clutching.
- 3y ago