3 ms·
> At the end of the day, you're not entitled to everything everyone else has. It has nothing to do with entitlement. Copyright is not a god-given right. It is
by tomp 15y ago
> At the end of the day, you're not entitled to everything everyone else has.
It has nothing to do with entitlement. Copyright is not a god-given right. It is a social contract; the consumer respects the copyright so that the artist gets more money, in return the consumer gets more art.
Currently, this social contract is out of balance. I think the right approach would be for some smaller countries, such as Slovenia, which get routinely neglected by copyright moguls, to pass laws saying that copyright is only valid if the work in question is offered domestically under equal terms as elsewhere worldwide. That would solve the problem real quick, one way or the other.
- qdog 15y agoIt's not a social contract, it's a government granted monopoly. Currently the 'industry' operates much like a cartel. I would posit that granting monopolies rarely benefits the most people, despite the good intentions.
- rwmj 15y agoIt's both: the public grants a monopoly and expects a social contract in return for this. Note: the public CAN withdraw the monopoly at any time.
- geoffschmidt 15y agoOnce it's been given? Unclear. Google "regulatory taking." When you downzone property you have to be worried about lawsuits. It seems like you could make a similar argument around copyright.