4 ms·
Sometimes I wonder why the American public has to be subject to the all the evils of so-called "tech" companies when clearly the US government has the personnel
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y ago
Sometimes I wonder why the American public has to be subject to the all the evils of so-called "tech" companies when clearly the US government has the personnel to write safe, reliable software.
Unlike so-called "tech" companies that can smugly ignore Americans' reasonable expectations of privacy in order to generate obscene profits, there are laws that prohibit the US government from engaging in similar shenangigans. (The "shenangigans" should be crimes but money has intervened.)
Even if hypothetical government-issued software might be "inferior" to whatever the so-called "tech" companies are producing, it would still be "superior" from a legal/regulatory standpoint. Americans would have some enforceable rights as software users. (Other countries are making some progress.)
Someone is inevitably going to make a wise crack reply about government contracting in the US. But I'm not referring to contractors. I'm referring to government employees.
We'll also likely see some reply about the technical superiority of so-called "tech" company software. But I'm not referring to technical superiority, I'm referring to (a) legal/regulatory limits on software authors and (b) software user rights.
- TylerE 3y agoGovernment software is great if you have a decade and a billion dollars to spend.
- themagician 3y ago>"Sometimes I wonder why the American public has to be subject to the all the evils of so-called "tech" companies when clearly the US government has the personnel to write safe, reliable software." It's not just the American public, it's every computer user—everywhere. The reason is because it's easy. There's plenty of secure software and systems out there. It's hard to use. The costs outweigh the benefits for most people most of the time. We could all be running Qubes or openBSD but we don't because it's hard. It's hard to do simple things. Most of the world runs on Windows and people are logged in as admin. It's a point and click world. I don't know if the government needs to write software, but I do think there is room for a vendor to step up, particularly in the business world, with systems that offer ironclad security. IMO we are in an increasingly dangerous world. I'm surprised the internet connected world hasn't collapsed yet. Every day seems to be a new kind of scam or malware. It takes incredible effort to safeguard systems today. One wrong click and in 5 minutes your entire life can be destroyed. I'm curious what the stats are on malware that has completely destroyed businesses. Cyber insurance policies are almost necessary now even if you consider yourself a skilled user.
- bredren 3y ago> there are laws that prohibit the US government from engaging in similar shenangigans. If the laws you’re alluding to are steadfast, provide true equal protection and are perfectly enforced I could see greater reliance on government software tools. However, history is littered with government agencies failing to protect people. Not to pick on the FBI here but the organization’s own J. Edward Hoover wasn’t the most privacy focused person. The group’s HQ is still named after this person. Perhaps other organizations could be relied on more. People have wanted free tax filing software for a long time. However, even the IRS has been shown vulnerable to take actions based on pressure from political forces.