4 ms·
Detective Who Arrested Man for Satirical Facebook Post Denied Immunity by 5th C
- deodar 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- atlas_hugged 3y agoKeep licking those boots
- chung8123 3y agoI personally hate responses like these to someone who has shown an opinion. It not only is a personal attack it is not constructive.
- davidwritesbugs 3y agoWhy does he need to be “constructive”? Because it’s nice to be nice? Are we at a vicar’s tea party? Calling the commenter a “boot licker” is an accurate critique of a pro-authority sycophant that has the virtue of brevity.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Why does he need to be “constructive”? We’re adults having a discussion. And it breaks HN Guidelines; “be nice” and “reply to the argument instead of calling names” [1]. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- SQueeeeeL 3y agoThe defacto assumption that internet discourse is a "discussion" is pretty implicitly wrong or at least very misguided. Most forums are much more in the mode of loud public arguments, which is why we have votes. Even my own comment, by continuing this conversation serves in rhetorical, political, and philosophic capacities; many of which I don't intend but are implicit to how the medium is presented
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> assumption that internet discourse is a "discussion" is pretty implicitly wrong…many forums We aren’t on many forums. We’re here. I wouldn’t think twice about that comment on e.g. Reddit. But that’s why I’m no longer there. The people who go into “loud public arguments” and win often had an adult discussion before. That an increasing fraction of world chooses to only engage in the former is creating problems and the necessity of moving important debates, including political debates, away from them.
- SQueeeeeL 3y agoPeople use comments as a substitute for reading the article, that means whatever ideological thread is dominating the comments is also defacto going to be the mass interpretation of events. "Winning" a comment section can have relative major ideological concerns as it makes a whole community start framing events around them with certain sets of priors
- deodar 3y agoHello, I'm not a sycophant, you can check my comment history. In this case I genuinely believe the post was borderline criminal and grossly irresponsible given the situation the world was in on March 20, 2020.
- alex_lav 3y ago> In this case I genuinely believe the post was borderline criminal and grossly irresponsible given the situation the world was in on March 20, 2020. You could rewrite this as "Not criminal". So you agree, the arrest was illegal. Great!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mensetmanusman 3y agoSo, if someone said they wanted Brad Pitt to save them from the police, how likely do you think someone will take that seriously? I would put it in the 0.001-0.00001% possibility. If you fear the mentally ill and make policy choices on that fear, you would necessarily have to ban free speech to mitigate such low risk.
- jagraff 3y agoSo, nobody can tell jokes if any person, no matter how mentally disturbed, might take it seriously?
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> finding it impossible to have any sympathy for Mr. Bailey From being arrested? > finding it impossible to have any sympathy for Mr. Bailey Nobody asked for sympathy. Just whether you think the state has the right to arrest people who make jokes “in poor taste.”
- akomtu 3y agoSo was he arrested for what others could've done?
- aaplok 3y agoWithout going into the merits of this particular case, you can get charged for inciting to violence. Indeed that's being arrested for what others could've done. Specifically for what they could have done, but would not have done if you had not incited them to. For example, if a black man walks into a neighbourhood and someone claims to the neighbours that he is armed and on a killing spree, they are possibly putting that man's life in danger. Edit: actually a better example is swarming. It's seriously endangering someone's life, so someone doing it can get arrested for what police could have done.
- akomtu 3y agoOn the other hand, that man would have to be arrested because others wouldn't feel threatened should he not chosen to walk into that neighborhood.
- courseofaction 3y agoIf the legal standard for speech is "cannot be misinterpreted by an insane person" then... uh... how do we proceed?
- garyfirestorm 3y agoYour statements were interpreted by an insane person incorrectly. So we gotta arrest you now! /s
- cooldrcool2 3y ago"a mentally disturbed individual may take it seriously and decide to take the "law" in his own hands." Are we going to arrest the entirety of the GOP and Fox news next?
- alex_lav 3y ago"This person said something I didn't like so they should be arrested", isn't really a valid or worthwhile opinion though. I don't like your post. Should you be arrested for it?
- sourcecodeplz 3y ago[flagged]
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> that post was incredibly bad and the author was rightfully arrested Would you say you believe free speech is a fundamental and important right?
- courseofaction 3y agoYou seriously think that a brad pit zombie movie joke on facebook should be arrestable? By whom? On what grounds?
- cooldrcool2 3y agoYour opinion sucks. People shouldn't be arrested for telling a joke that doesn't land well.
- alex_lav 3y agoJust casually supporting open fascism now.
- throwuxiytayq 3y agoHis post looks like perfectly normal dumb internet shit you yourself would send in chat at 3:00 AM just a couple of years ago, if not today. Admit it.
- 1letterunixname 3y agoIt's good to see common sense upheld by jurists applying case law to hold the line against arbitrary arrest by LEAs over-stepping their authorities. Now, if police-involved firearms incident data reporting were mandatory because we only know some details of most cases, but there's no national standard. 1055 people were shot by police in 2021 that we know of. How can the public health crisis of violent deaths be addressed if we're unable to scrutinize the data of each incident? Overall, there were 48k firearm deaths in 2021, or 13 / 100k. (variance by state from Massachusetts 3.4 / 100k to Mississippi 33 / 100k)
- redhale 3y agoNot only did this man DESERVE to be arrested, but Brad Pitt himself should be arrested for the MURDER of the World War Z source material by his boring movie. /s This was an absolutely insane case, and I'm glad it at least ended with sanity. The fact this arrest happened at all is unbelievably dumb and also scary.
- zootboy 3y agoSadly, this isn't over. The appeals court simply overturned a lower court decision and remanded the case back to the lower court.
- RetroTechie 3y agoLike the article states, this is likely to end in a settlement. I would hope settlements for power abuses of this type would come out of this PD's pocket. Meaning: abuse power = less $ left for paying officers, obtaining gear, etc. So that in future, PDs would be more hesitant to stomp on things they don't like simply because they can. But who am I kidding.. probably taxpayers on the hook as usual (same with court costs). Btw: too bad victim deleted his post. No deletion (or even apology) needed.
- rowan_actualish 3y ago[flagged]
- rowan_actualish 3y ago[flagged]