6 ms·
This is a problem. You don't want an emergency stop signal to be ignored because somebody didn't update their encryption keys. And it's very useful for railroad
by Animats 3y ago
This is a problem. You don't want an emergency stop signal to be ignored because somebody didn't update their encryption keys. And it's very useful for railroad workers to be provided with handhelds that can send an emergency stop signal. Here's one used in the US.[1] This is for yard operations, where there's slow-speed (the US limit is 20mph) traffic going in various directions without full signal control. Outside the "yard limit", signals control, and speeds are higher.
If you have no idea what a railroad yard working environment is like, here's a Union Pacific recruiting video.[2] They're up-front about what you're getting into; the intro shows someone at 5:48 AM in a snowstorm in a railyard in Chicago.
[1] https://railserve.biz/react-safety-device/ https://railserve.biz/react-safety-device/
[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lMViWazEYoc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lMViWazEYoc
- KptMarchewa 3y agoThere is no encryption.
- praptak 3y agoGP point is that encryption would add a layer of things that can fail, to a system where a false negative is extremely costly.
- thejazzman 3y agoI actually know someone who was hit by a train in these circumstances in the 90s. He was in the hospital for years. We're all still incredibly amazed that he's still alive -- on the upside, he got one hell of a payout over it. But yeah, it's REALLY important these radios work :|
- rob74 3y agoI was thinking the same thing and wondering what the use case may be for doing this via radio - thanks for clearing it up! But once you use unencrypted radio, you open it up for remote exploitation - the same thing that can be sent from close up can also be sent from further away with more powerful equipment. That's probably why the systems I was aware of until now use magnets on the track (this can of course only be used to make sure trains stop at a signal, or respect the speed limit, not for arbitrarily stopping them).
- praptak 3y agoThe train stops that are mounted on the tracks (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Train_stop https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Train_stop) can be used to arbitrarily stop trains. This is obviously much less practical for the attacker.