3 ms·
> There is no threat to rail passengers, unless a passenger train does not know about a stopped train ahead of it on the tracks, e.g., a cargo train go stopped
by mschuster91 3y ago
> There is no threat to rail passengers, unless a passenger train does not know about a stopped train ahead of it on the tracks, e.g., a cargo train go stopped by the hack, but the passenger train 10min behind it did not and continues to rush onward towards the stopped cargo train.
Almost everywhere in Europe uses actual signalling blocks backed by axle counters and DC detection circuits between the rails of a track, or by physical key/token based interlocks to detect if a train can safely enter the block. The way the US does it (especially detecting if a train has not been separated along the way by using a caboose/end-of-train beacon) may cost less money, but would be viable to such issues.
- pmw 3y ago> The way the US does it (especially detecting if a train has not been separated along the way by using a caboose/end-of-train beacon) may cost less money, but would be viable to such issues. Detecting separation doesn't rely on the end-of-train device. The EOTD only helps with this by 1/ helping activate the brakes twice as fast by detecting loss of pressure on its end and opening the brake valve, and 2/ sending periodic status indication via radio signal to the locomotive so the crew has more visibility into what the pressure is and whether the tail of the train is moving.
- KptMarchewa 3y agoWait, there's no pneumatic brake on US trains?
- mschuster91 3y agoThat's not foolproof - if someone forgets to open the valves during train assembly on the yard, it may not be detected that a train has split.
- iggldiggl 3y agoThat's why you should be doing a brake continuity check before departing… (Of course that's not entirely foolproof, either, and there have been accidents caused e.g. by a lack of braking power because the brake pipe wasn't fully connected throughout the full train.)
- KptMarchewa 3y agoYeah, on Polish railways there's always brake check on the last carriage. > (Of course that's not entirely foolproof, either, and there have been accidents caused e.g. by a lack of braking power because the brake pipe wasn't fully connected throughout the full train.) Can you specify what you mean? If the pipe wasn't properly connected, it shouldn't start at all, because the system needs pressure to release the brakes.
- mschuster91 3y ago> Can you specify what you mean? If the pipe wasn't properly connected, it shouldn't start at all, because the system needs pressure to release the brakes. These pneumatic systems leak. You're not allowed to park a train for longer than 24h in Germany if it is purely secured with air pressure for that reason - if it's a particularly bad composition, you seriously risk having no pressure anywhere in the system by that time, and thus no brakes being applied.
- CapstanRoller 3y agoAren't train brake systems safe by default? I thought air pressures released the brakes, not activated them.