3 ms·
I'm sympathetic to right-to-repair, in general, but this argument bothers me: > “The current barriers to these works include service passwords and digital lock
by neilv 3y ago
I'm sympathetic to right-to-repair, in general, but this argument bothers me:
> “The current barriers to these works include service passwords and digital locks,” the petition reads. “Commercial ice cream machines, such as the Taylor manufactured ice cream machines used by McDonald’s, frequently fall into disrepair when its daily pasteurization cycle fails. Circumventing the digital lock on the software would enable owners and repair professionals to diagnose and perform the necessary repairs to get these devices back up and running.”
They're talking about a safety-sensitive process failing and consequently locking out use... mere syllables before asking for the ability to circumvent locks.
Which prompts the concern that some fast food employees, their managers or small business owners, sketchier repairpeople, and Aliexpress gadgets are going to effectively use that lock circumvention ability to circumvent a safety feature, eventually killing children whose parents treated them to ice cream cones.
- Benanov 3y agoYou're conflating "I can't get the diagnostic repair codes that Taylor can" with "Kids are going to get hurt because the machine is malfunctioning" Please stop doing that.
- neilv 3y agoSee, you can casually whip out a more persuasive (or less self-defeating) argument than they did, in their presumably carefully crafted petition.
- gruez 3y ago> You're conflating "I can't get the diagnostic repair codes that Taylor can" with "Kids are going to get hurt because the machine is malfunctioning" But the article and the linked vice.com article suggests that the device isn't just decoding error codes, it's also providing a hardware bypass for safety features like lockouts.
- spiderxxxx 3y agono, the article says "groups seek permission from the government to break arbitrary software locks and passwords that keep consumers and repair professionals from diagnosing and repairing equipment they own or are authorized by the owner to work on." It doesn't mention "lockouts", or bypassing safety features. It's about access to the machine, and the diagnostics that a repair person has access to, but the owner does not.
- Clent 3y agoBut are they authorized? These are McDonalds franchises. There is a contract. We're going to start limiting what McDonalds can do to control quality of product because the tech community thinks it knows better? Dairy is not a product to play loose with the rules on.
- ghostpepper 3y ago(Semi-)Serious question: does McDonald’s soft serve “ice cream” contain dairy?
- mcpackieh 3y agoIt does contain dairy, but they can't legally call it ice cream. (Or at least they can't call their shakes "milkshakes": https://www.mcdonalds.com/us/en-us/faq/desserts-and-shakes.html https://www.mcdonalds.com/us/en-us/faq/desserts-and-shakes.h... ) Q: Why don't you call your 'shakes,' 'milkshakes'? A: Great question. Our shakes contain milk from our reduced-fat soft serve, which makes them thick and creamy. Dairy regulations actually vary from state to state on what can officially be called a 'milkshake.' We like to keep it simple and refer to them strictly as 'shakes.' (Note they say "reduced-fat soft serve" and not "ice cream")
- Clent 3y agoI really don't want keep defending a corporation here but it's quite clear form that messaging that it may be consider ice cream in some states. If we're going to dunk on corporations can we do it for legitimate reasons?
- spiderxxxx 3y agoA lot of the time, the reason why it fails is simply because the feed bucket is filled too much to heat it up to a high enough temperature in the 4 hours, but the error codes give no indication of this unless you go into a service menu which the code is not available to the owners of the machines. If you could get into the service menu, you could find out what the problem is, fix it, and have it successfully complete a cycle, if you had access to the settings, you might be able to set it to try for a 5 hour cleaning cycle to give it more time to heat itself up to clean itself. It's not about trying to bypass a safety lockout, it's about being able to troubleshoot the issue and fix it.
- banannaise 3y agoThe lock doesn't prevent using the machine - it prevents restarting the cleaning process. The fact that the cleaning process hasn't been completed is what prevents using the machine. There is no danger in unlocking the cleaning process so the cleaning process can be restarted.
- fluoridation 3y agoWon't somebody please think of the children?
- ImPostingOnHN 3y agoresponsibility for restaurant sanitation falls on the restaurant if you're going to mcdonalds, with your children, with the view that they will serve you and your children spoiled, contaminated food, and kill you and them, unless a little computer gadget physically prevents them, you might either have poor judgement, or you might be a contrived plot device in an implausible hypothetic scenario dreamed up by a HNer
- pinot 3y agoAll modern industrial machinery has safety features that often include shutting down the machine. Most machine owners are allowed to send mainteance in to evaluate the reason of the shutdown, resolve the issue and restart the machine, without calling the OEM. Imagine if a walk-in cooler had a high-temp alarm, and the machine shut itself down, and locked the cooler as a result, then told the owner to call the cooler OEM. Thankfully it doesn't work that way, it might alarm then you diagnose (radiator fan not running, fan coils covered in leaves, whatever) resolve and restart.