8 ms·
I don't know if I'm going to be able to express what I feel but I'll try. YC "bugs" are - startups that are accepted and fail - startups that are rejected an
by bambax 15y ago
I don't know if I'm going to be able to express what I feel but I'll try.
YC "bugs" are
- startups that are accepted and fail
- startups that are rejected and fail, but would have thrived had they been accepted
(Of course this last kind of bug is extremely difficult to track down.)
But if a startup makes a killing after being rejected by YC it means they didn't need you.
If you consider this a bug, there's some kind of moral problem because it means YC is trying to siphon every promising team in order to maximize YC's success, independently of who YC is likely to help more.
You're not just betting on horses, you're also training them: it seems what you should want to maximize is YC's impact...?
- jwb119 15y agoYou're considering success or failure as a binary outcome. It's possible that a startup is accepted and wouldn't have failed anyways, but that being in YC makes it a bigger success than it otherwise would have been (through mentoring or other intervention by YC). My understanding is that is the sweetspot for YC anyways - everyone is a winner there.
- mirsadm 15y agoI think a more important aspect is that YC is able to connect with exceptional individuals (and groups). Even if one particular group fails they may add talented individuals to their network and connect them with other more successful startups.
- bambax 15y ago> You're considering success or failure as a binary outcome I think that's how it is, yes, and PG seems to have stated as much; in essence, you either die or don't die; if you don't die, the scale of your success depends on a lot of things that are beyond your control. (Actual quote from PG: "The formula for the success of a startup includes a random multiplier of roughly zero to a thousand." — http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3050280 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3050280 ) If one subscribes to this point of view then the purpose of YC is to help startups not die, and the purpose of the YC admission process is to 1. select all startups that have a chance of not dying if admitted (eg, refuse startups that don't stand a chance in hell of not dying) 2. if the sample from #1 is too large, reduce it at the low end first (startups that are not very likely to not die) but maybe also at the high end (startups that seem certain to not die no matter what) Maybe reducing the selection from the high end is just plain stupid / counter productive, but if you don't do that, it's not very clear why one would be in this business in the first place (as opposed to other lucrative businesses).
- vibrunazo 15y agoI think you're both right. Success can be understood as binary, depending on how you interpret it. You either fail or you don't. But YC can help you find that faster than without YC. So there's room for improvement even if success is binary. These guys got 10k users in a month. But maybe they'd get 100k in 3 if they had YC. Even if you understand that either way it would be a success anyway. It's still reasonable to assume that it would be a worthwhile deal for them. If YC missed the opportunity to help them get even better, even faster. It's reasonable for both sides to treat that as a bug.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- pemulis 15y agoI don't really see the moral problem. YC is a group of investors, not a charity. Of course they're going to look for the kind of hardy founders who would succeed even if they got rejected.
- bambax 15y agoYes, they're not a charity. They're also not a pension fund. To me they look a little like a prep school (but maybe I'm wrong). The mission of a prep school is to help good students become brilliant; if it becomes stuffed by already brilliant candidates (for example because the admission process is more selective than the admission process of the college it preps for), so much so that there's no place left for second-tier students who would make the most of its teaching, then there's a problem. I'm just wondering if this is something YC worries about or should worry about.
- pemulis 15y agoI see what you mean, since Y Combinator is an institution now, and its selection process has an impact on the overall ecosystem. But let's say Startup A, which is top-tier, would become a $75M company with Y Combinator's help, but would become a $50M company without them. Meanwhile, Startup B, which is second-tier, would become a $3M company with Y Combinator, but would become a $30K company without them. Even if we throw profit out the window (which an investment group doesn't do, obviously), Y Combinator would add a greater total dollar value to Startup A than to Startup B, even though they would multiply the value of Startup B by 100x. Also, elite prep schools do try to fill their classes with nothing but brilliant students, for a variety of reasons, including money and prestige. There are some negative consequences, to be sure, but it happens. At least Y Combinator increases the size of its classes every year, unlike prep schools.
- tptacek 15y agoYC is not like a prep school. It is a win condition for the YC model (really, for any investment system) if so many top-tier companies apply that there's no room for second-tier companies. YC is a business, not a public good.
- InclinedPlane 15y agoFrom YC's perspective there are two ways in which they win when they invest in a company. On the one hand they make a return on their investment, classic straight-up utility maximizing economics. On the other hand they help a startup succeed, which is part of their overall purpose aside from raking in fat stacks of filthy lucre. Even if a company succeeds without YC that doesn't mean that YC's potential involvement is a no-op. On the one hand that represents a missed opportunity for revenue. It also means a missed opportunity to perhaps accelerate the growth of that company beyond what it has managed to achieve on its own.
- padobson 15y agoI think this is too narrow a range to determine where bugs are in the process. Bugs in the application process can only really be rooted out by startups that apply and are successful. Startups that apply and fail could point to a bug in a number of different areas - not just the application process. If the purpose of YC is to make money and improve startups, than they are failing at both of those things if they pass on startups that eventually succeed.
- noahc 15y ago>- startups that are rejected and fail, but would have thrived had they been accepted PG has specifically stated that this is not a bug (it's a feature). The goal of YC is not to take mediocre or bad startup teams and turn them into wins, but to take the winners and turn them into Super-Winners(Dropbox). As far as maximizing YC's impact, I think Dropbox maximizes it more than small wins from teams that would have lost had they not been in YC.
- ma2rten 15y agoIf a company can only succeed by getting funding though YC, they should not fund it, in my opinion. I don't think those founders are ready yet to start a startup.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- goatcurious 15y agoI think PG is talking about YC's selection process. A startup applied, was not accepted, but became a success. Selection is the core of YC team's job, and this post is a self reflection on how can they get better. In that sense, this is certainly a bug.
- wheels 15y agoYou're confusing YC with a charity. It is not. Trying to invest in teams that will succeed is the modus operandi of virtually all venture investors, YC included. YC is trying to rewrite a lot of the rules of venture investing, and has had quite some success there, but at its very core it's important to remember that they are investors. At the end of the day, the measuring stick of an investor is their returns, not how many (proto-) companies they pulled from the brink of implosion. As such, your second measuring stick rings false. I suspect that AirBnb, Dropbox and Heroku are simultaneously among the investments that YC is the most proud of and the companies that would have been most likely to succeed had they not been a part of YC.
- pbreit 15y agoI don't think that makes any sense at all. Like any organization or group, it is seeking the best. In fact, I would imagine they'd be delighted bringing in folks even YC could learn from. I'm sure PG would be the first to say he doesn't have all the answers and cannot magically make every team be successful. Suggesting it's a deficiency in morality is absurd.