4 ms·
This brings back thoughts of the NTSC days and broadcast safe limits, and the horrible time of clients that loved loved loved red. Explaining to them how the be
by dylan604 3y ago
This brings back thoughts of the NTSC days and broadcast safe limits, and the horrible time of clients that loved loved loved red. Explaining to them how the beautiful red artwork will be anything but beautiful on TV was never fun, especially if they wanted it for broadcast. Even when it wasn't for broadcast, an illegal red could still be seen frames later, and would bleed like it just had its throat slit.
- LocalH 3y agoRed is still a particularly hard color to accurately represent, just not as hard as it used to be. The bleeding and chroma crawl that is most visible in NTSC red, has been replaced with at best half chroma resolution, and depending on how the viewer's decoder works, red edges may be especially harsh-looking. It's definitely better than it used to be, though.
- adrian_b 3y agoThe better monitors can be reconfigured to use the DCI-P3 primary colors instead of the default Rec. 709 primary colors (a.k.a. sRGB primaries). (sRGB combines the Rec. 709 primaries with a certain nonlinear transfer function, while Display P3 combines the DCI-P3 primaries with the sRGB nonlinear transfer function and with the PAL/SECAM white, which is also used by Rec. 709 and sRGB). With the DCI-P3 primaries, it is very noticeable that the red is much better, allowing the displaying of reddish colors that are simultaneously more saturated and brighter than what can be achieved with the Rec. 709 red. While DCI-P3 also has a better green than Rec. 709, there the improvement is much less obvious than in the red area.
- PaulHoule 3y agoThe monitor has a set of primaries that doesn't change but the monitor can treat R, G and B signals as if they are in a particular color space with certain primaries and do the best that it can to simulate the appearance specified in the signal.
- adrian_b 3y agoFor most monitors, as a user you cannot know which are the true colors of the pixels of the screen and this is completely irrelevant. What matters is which are the colors that will be reproduced on the display when you send the digital codes corresponding to pure red, green and blue, through the DisplayPort or HDMI interfaces of the monitor. All the good monitors have a menu for the selection of the color space that will be used by DisplayPort and HDMI, and the menu will typically present a choice between sRGB and Display P3 or DCI-P3. Even when in the menu it is written DCI-P3, what is meant is Display P3, i.e. the menu changes only the primaries, without changing the white or the nonlinear transfer function. All monitors will process the digital codes corresponding to standard color spaces to generate the appropriate values needed to command their specific pixels in order to reproduce a color as close as possible to what is specified by the standard color space. The cheapest monitors are able to display only a color space close to Rec. 709 a.k.a. sRGB, those of medium price are normally able to display a color space close to DCI-P3 and a few very expensive monitors and many expensive TV-sets, which use either quantum dots or OLED, are able to display a larger fraction of the Rec. 2020 color space (laser projectors can display the complete Rec. 2020 color space). Even when a monitor can display bright and saturated reds, as long as it remains in the default configuration of using sRGB over DisplayPort and HDMI, you cannot command the monitor to display those colors. For that, you have to switch the color space used by DisplayPort and HDMI to a color space with a wider color gamut. Some monitors, typically those that are advertised to support HDR, allow the use of the Rec. 2020 color space over DisplayPort and HDMI, but most such monitors cannot display the full Rec. 2020 color space, so the very saturated colors will either be clipped to maximum saturation or mapped to less saturated colors.
- account42 3y ago> All monitors will process the digital codes corresponding to standard color spaces to generate the appropriate values needed to command their specific pixels in order to reproduce a color as close as possible to what is specified by the standard color space. This is overly optimistic. It has gotten better lately but most monitors aren't calibrated as well as they could but. And not that long ago the RGB signals were directly mapped to the monitors colors.
- mrandish 3y agoAs someone who also worked within the arcane limitations of analog video, at both the broadcast and prosumer levels, today's UHD video standards and colorspaces can be incredible when correctly applied in a maximal high-end workflow such as native 4k 10-bit HDR. Yet when I look at today's typical "top quality" live broadcast content such as the 4K Super Bowl as delivered by mass consumer distribution such as Comcast Xfinity (via their latest high-end decoder box), it's a visual mess compared to what the signal chain should be capable of delivering. Even though I have top notch viewing gear properly configured and calibrated (with local video processing 'enhancements' disabled), it looks terrible. Unfortunately, due to the layers of compression, conversion and DRM slathered on the signal before I receive it, it's extremely difficult to analyze what's going wrong. All I can determine is that it is a video feed being decompressed into a 4K-resolution, 4:2:2, 60fps frame buffer. However, examining still frame sequences reveals extensive motion, color and resolution artifacts. The net effect conveys a sense of "sharpness" in the frequency domain at first glance but on critical viewing over time it's a weird kind of digital abomination of macro-blocked chroma splotches, lagged temporal artifacts and bizarre over-saturation of primary hues. While some pre-compressed streamed film content looks quite good when delivered via a streaming service willing to devote sufficient encoding time and delivery bitrate, it's still hit and miss. Live broadcast content, especially high-motion sports, is almost always a mess. We've come so far in standards and specifications yet still have so far to go in the actual delivered result to most households.
- PaulHoule 3y agoYes, the visual quality of a sports game can vary a lot and is frequently a disappointment. I can get an ATSC 3 multiplex from Syracuse and it is sad that it is not really better than the ATSC 2 symbol.
- mrandish 3y agoThat's disappointing to hear because my current residence came with a large digital-capable antenna installed in the attic which I've never connected. When more local stations in my market start ATSC 3 broadcasts next year I was thinking of hooking up an OTA feed just to see if it's better than the Comcast XFinity cable-delivered mess. I don't even watch that much TV content but when I do, I want it to not look like crap. It's frustrating because I'm sure the four national broadcast networks and top cable channels (eg ESPN, CNN, etc) are providing pristine source feeds at their head-end distribution points which look amazing. Is there even any meaningfully better-quality alternative these days? Maybe some over-the-top streaming provider of broadcast and cable channels who actually delivers 4k sources with guaranteed high-quality encoding and decent bitrates? If so, I'd cut the Comcast cord even if it costs more. It's not like Comcast is cheap but I also hate the idea of paying top dollar for such a substandard product simply because there are no better alternatives. BTW: I'd be delighted to learn of any viable US-based content alternatives (eg streaming, direct satellite, etc). Back in the analog SDTV days I had a C-Band sat dish and the direct network feeds looked amazing in pure 6 Mhz analog component compared to local cable and even local OTA broadcast.
- chrismorgan 3y ago> […] and would bleed like it just had its throat slit. Thank you for your beautiful turn of phrase which has made my evening brighter.