6 ms·
An important topic that doesn't get enough attention. We need to start switching to crops that require less water (goodbye almonds, pistachios and alfalfa!). Me
by insane_dreamer 3y ago
An important topic that doesn't get enough attention. We need to start switching to crops that require less water (goodbye almonds, pistachios and alfalfa!). Meat consumption plays a big role too since pasture requires more water than many crops.
- drunner 3y agoAt the very least, regionalize the production better. Throwing out the way we currently do water rights and putting sensible limits on how much can be used for ag production would go a long ways.
- causi 3y agoThrowing out the way we currently do water rights Good luck with that one. Southern California has defeated basically every attempt to reform water rights.
- galangalalgol 3y agoReferendums can do almost anything in California can't they? Pass a water reform law as an amendment to their constitution that states the judiciary has no power to interpret the amendment. Declare war on the pacific and declare pi to be 3.
- eppp 3y agoArent water rights mostly a federal issue at this point?
- PaulDavisThe1st 3y agoNo. The water compacts between states are the responsibility of the federal government, but water rights (i.e. landowners' right to access ground water and sometimes river water) are state matters.
- jonhohle 3y agoWhy would the federal government have any control over a states water rights? Except on water on federal land the US government has no authority to control a state’s use of its water, nor should it.
- datavirtue 3y agoClimate change === mass migration. Right now all the people out west think that is something that applies to people in third world countries. In the US it's going to be an attempted migration of the west's middle class to other regions. At first they will have buyers for their homes to fund the migration...until they don't. Before that there will be a frenzy of wasteful government spending to try to preserve the regions and way of life. It will not work. Climate change is the reason we keep digging up civilizations that "just disappeared without a trace."
- galangalalgol 3y agoThe actual west coast is pretty low impact other than sea rise. If you are close enough for the breeze but far enough to avoid the storm surge with a 1.5m rise, that is your ideal. The reason is the cool/cold pacific current. There is no prediction that it will shift, and if it did, I'm not sure any models would tell us what came next. The rainfall issue is certainly a thing, but it impacts agriculture and housing further inland. The east isn't safe either, the extremes will get more extreme. Places that don't usually have A/C will need it. Altitude is your best bet. Buy on the west side of the rockies for the rain at ~7-9kft. Not that your deed will matter when everyone comes knocking.
- dredmorbius 3y agoSouthern California's watershed (Los Angeles, San Diego, Inland Empire), extends 1,500 miles eastward, to the eastern front of the Rocky Mountains, watershed for the Colorado River. One reason urban developments are so sparse and widely-separated west of the Rockies is that there's simply insufficient water, rights are held under Spanish-derived law (seniority), and those senior rights are held, many by large West Coast cities, most especially Los Angeles. Climate changes across that entire region will have a profound impact on coastal dwellers, even if sea-level rise is modest and coastal climates are largely unchanged. Simply because that's not where the water is coming from. (Northern California's water largely comes from Sierra Nevada snowpack (San Francisco, Central Valley), or local reservoirs (mostly coastal counties). Santa Barbara similarly relies on local sources, largely Lake Cachuma, a reservoir in the Santa Ynez Valley. Supplies can dip parlously low in drought years. <https://www.countyofsb.org/2795/Reservoirs https://www.countyofsb.org/2795/Reservoirs>).
- masklinn 3y ago> regionalize the production better. Most crops you can’t regionalise, they grow where they grow and that’s about it. You won’t get oranges in Maine (except under greenhouses at insane costs). The Central Valley is exceptional because of how flexible and productive an environment it is, it’s home to half the fruits, vegetables, and nuts production of the US, 8% of the US agricultural value, and is the primary worldwide producer of several crops. So what is necessary is to change minds about what produces people get, and when.
- hattmall 3y agoAny idea what percent of it irrigation it accounts for?
- jacobr1 3y agoThere is already a great way to do this: prices! The market isn't perfect, but with commodities it really does seem to function. We don't need artificial usage limits, we just need to charge for water on the open market. Reserve whatever is needed for residential use and sustainability and auction the rest. Or allow it to be sold freely. Right now many pleases have a tragedy of the commons situation. If you don't use up as much water as possible, and dig deeper wells to use it up faster than your neighbors, then you can end up with no water and out of business. If you could secure specific water rights you could plan your business. Farms _would_ go out of business with crops that are too water-intensive relative to the price, but that is actually a desirable property of the system. Those crops will raise in price until the demand lowers and the cost of higher water is sustained. Lower water-utilizing crops will replace the previous higher intensity usage.
- lapcat 3y agoLetting a few billionaires buy all of the water in the country is just one step closer to complete dystopia.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- someplaceguy 3y agoYeah, making water sources private property might not turn out well. But if the water sources are publicly managed and water consumption is priced progressively (and sustainably) at the source, I don't see what the problem is of letting markets do the rest. Although water pollution should be addressed as well, but this is required regardless of the scenario.
- happymellon 3y ago> There is already a great way to do this: prices! The market isn't perfect, but with commodities it really does seem to function. That's absolutely insane. Don't worry poor people, you won't be able to drink water because Amazon is being lazy with pumping tap water to cool it's data centers, but it's okay because markets have deemed you irrelevant!
- gruez 3y ago>Throwing out the way we currently do water rights IANAL but is that even remotely feasible? My impression is that they're basically akin to property rights, and the state unilaterally revoking them is going to be blocked by the courts.
- PM_me_your_math 3y ago[flagged]
- smcg 3y agoThey'll be food justice camps run by Nestle. You know the company that employs child slaves.
- PM_me_your_math 3y agoLike Apple? Think Different.
- drewg123 3y agoIndeed. Beef actually plays the biggest role. From what I can find, feef requires 106gal/oz while almonds require 23gal/oz. Reducing animal agriculture has so many benefits for the planet.
- andreiii 3y agois not like that water stays within the animal. most of it is back into the natural circuit very quick.
- masklinn 3y agoThe same is true of most crops, almonds contain less than 5% water. The problem is that the water is still pumped out the acquifer, and non-acquifer water is still water which generally becomes unavailable to other uses because it evaporates or is too polluted.
- myshpa 3y agoAnd those pastures and alfalfa fields don't replenish aquifers, forests do.
- someplaceguy 3y agoSure, but more importantly, beef requires only 10.6 gal/taste unit while almonds require 46 gal/taste unit.
- hellisothers 3y agoWhat is a taste unit?
- someplaceguy 3y agoIt's each person's measure of how much you go "hmm...! That was sooo good!" after eating 1 oz of a certain type of food. In that example, 1 oz of beef contains 10 of my taste units while 1 oz of almonds contains 0.5 of my taste units. Since each person's taste units are different, humans have decided that the best way to allocate food is to sell it on something called a "market", where each person can express their own individual taste units, or "preferences", by buying the food on this "market". The price of the food on the market reflects the scarcity of the food and everything it took to produce it, although sometimes there are distortions which should be corrected externally (e.g. by a government), not by restricting the types of food we consume, but by addressing their root causes at the source (e.g. by taxing water consumption to address the tragedy of the commons, or by taxing CO2 production to address global warming). These taxes should be increased up to the point where consumption/pollution becomes sustainable.
- donkeyd 3y ago> pasture requires more water than many crops I see this argument often in the discussion around meat (beef, mostly) consumption. I also see the counter that most of that water goes straight back into the ground and most of the rest goes back in after it goes through the cow. The counter seems logical to me, but I am probably missing something?
- PaulDavisThe1st 3y agoEvaporation. In most places that do above-ground irrigation of livestock crops, humidity is low, temperatures are warm, and a significant part of the water is lost to evaporation.
- tzs 3y agoThen what happens to it? For example just looking at the prevailing winds in the San Joaquin valley I'd expect a lot of water that evaporates there to end up as rain in the Sierra Nevada mountains. Does that in fact happen? If so, where does that water go after it becomes rain? If not, where does it go? The Earth's water systems as a whole are a huge collection of cyclic paths, with many branches. If you artificially take water from someplace and drop it someplace else you have almost always just borrowed the water and it will eventually end up back where it came from. "Eventually" could be a very long time though, and if we borrow enough water for long enough it is possible we could permanently change some of the cycles so that some places never recover their water. I've not been able to find any analysis that looks at this from a whole systems approach and figures out if we are borrowing enough to permanently change things, or how long it takes borrowed water in specific cases to effectively return.
- myshpa 3y agoELI5: Forests retain rainwater in the soil, replenish aquifers, cool the soil, nourish soil biodiversity, contribute to the formation of new rainfall, distribute it inland, alter local microclimates, and sustain biodiversity. With pastures, none of that applies. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biotic_pump https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biotic_pump
- myshpa 3y agoI agree with you that meat consumption is a menace, but please don't put almonds (or any trees) at the same level as cattle. Alfalfa consumes 10-20x more water than almonds. Alfalfa is used for animal feed, is using fertilizers, pesticides, herbicides, animal ag produces methane and causes water pollution and oceanic dead zones, is a source of zoonotic diseases, consumes a lot of antibiotics ... None of that is true with almonds and pistachios, as both crops could replace milk and dairy, and they produce proteins and fats that can feed the population sustainably. I understand that growing almond monocultures in a desert may be a stupid idea, but remove animal ag. water usage and you will have water problems no more. Change those almond monocultures (and alfalfa fields) to diverse food forest, and you may reverse desertification and increase precipitation in that area.
- pragmatic 3y agoAlfalfa can be grown on dry land. You just won’t get as many cuttings. It grows in the upper Midwest just fine without irrigation. > Pasture requires more water I’m not sure where you’re getting that information? It’s not a common practice to irrigate pasture. Animals are watered from “dug outs”, wells or rural water programs which draw water from rivers like the Missouri.