9 ms·
Film Review: BlackBerry
- kaycey2022 3y agoI used to think that liberalism taken to its logical end would result in a "Start Trek" society. Little did I expect that at the end of that hike just lay Canada.
- BeckyGonzalez 3y ago[dead]
- bartislartfast 3y agohow many more product / brand origin story movies do we need? Facebook, Uber, Blackberry, Apple, Tetris, Nike Air, Cheetos
- TX81Z 3y agoI loved Glen Howerton’s performance and the first two acts, but the last third felt incoherent, like it wasn’t edited well or the writing wasn’t finished.
- voisin 3y agoPerhaps an homage to BlackBerry / RIM itself. Excellent first two acts devolving into incoherency at the end.
- TX81Z 3y agoYes, but the NHL stuff wasn’t explained whatsoever. I had no idea what was going on there.
- nemo44x 3y agoPossibly. I took it as he was so caught up in his own things that he was mismanaging everything else he needed to be paying attention to at a critical moment. Arrogance. The classic Nero playing his fiddle while Rome burned.
- andrewstuart 3y agoLoved this movie. I ran my first startup at this time and it was exactly the same as the first scene, where were all playing Red Alert on the network after work.
- qingcharles 3y agoHaha, that must have been every start-up at the time.
- ehhthing 3y agoDefinitely the best Canadian movie I've seen. Hits close to home as a UWaterloo student.
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoHow about the movie about the Avro Arrow fighter jet? I'm not canadian but the ending was pretty sad knowing how other canadian tech companies would have similar fates in the future (like Nortel)
- walterbell 3y agohttps://www.bnnbloomberg.ca/did-a-chinese-hack-kill-canada-s-greatest-tech-company-1.1459269 https://www.bnnbloomberg.ca/did-a-chinese-hack-kill-canada-s... > Nortel’s giddy, gilded growth also made it a target. Starting in the late 1990s, the Canadian Security Intelligence Service, the country’s version of the CIA, became aware of “unusual traffic,” suggesting that hackers in China were stealing data and documents from Ottawa. “We went to Nortel in Ottawa, and we told the executives, ‘They’re sucking your intellectual property out,’ ” says Michel Juneau-Katsuya, who headed the agency’s Asia-Pacific unit at the time. “They didn’t do anything.”
- swader999 3y agoMaybe see Fubar, although it is hard to compare with Blackberry.
- racl101 3y agoMight be the best thing to come out of Calgary.
- WoodenChair 3y agoI read the book its based on (Losing the Signal) and saw the movie. Given the budget, in my opinion the movie is not bad. I found the first 10 minutes did not draw me in, but I found the rest of the movie more compelling. I agree with the reviewer that the actor playing Jim put on the best performance. But as this reviewer states, all of the actors are playing something of a caricature of the real people. Personally, I didn't find either the book or the movie astoundingly insightful, and in my opinion both lacked a grounding in enough technical understanding to truly explain the market forces that were working against RIM. My full review of the book is here: https://www.observationalhazard.com/2018/09/book-review-losing-signal.html https://www.observationalhazard.com/2018/09/book-review-losi...
- rchaud 3y agoI thought the book was fantastic, particularly with regards to detailing what Blackberry did right when it came to tech sales and pitching their product. I felt the movie missed the opportunity to have a 'success montage' scene a la Scarface, where Blackberry sales blow up once executives started showing it off as the go-to device for instant email and messaging.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- wslh 3y agoDo the book and/or the movie touch the Blackberry QNX acquisition? [1] [1] https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/qnx-software-systems https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/qnx-software-systems
- WoodenChair 3y agoThe book touches on it, but certainly not in enough technical depth (what was it like integrating, etc.). The movie doesn't.
- ahsteele 3y agoThe book does. Have not seen the movie to know for sure but I believe the movie ends around 2008 or 09 at the time of the Storm’s release and before the QNX acquisition.
- walterbell 3y agohttps://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/blackberry-movie-review-2023 https://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/blackberry-movie-review-2... > “BlackBerry” is a MoneyBro movie par excellence, right up there with “Wall Street,” “Glengarry Glen Ross,” “Boiler Room,” and “The Wolf of Wall Street.” It shares their key, defining trait: even though its main characters are either charismatic sociopaths or sheep, and the capitalist system they operate in is deeply corrupt and rewards men without morals or conscience, the story is so excitingly told, the performances so watchable, and the dialogue so quotable that it becomes the verbal equivalent of an action flick—kinetic, suspenseful, and sometimes unexpectedly beautiful and weirdly moving.
- ssddanbrown 3y agoI've been looking forward to watching this film, but it's frustratingly not been available in the UK. Looks like it might be reaching cinemas in October though. I don't usually look into new movies, so don't know how things usually work, but this regional specific delay feels really quite outdated.
- darkclouds 3y agoI agree, but at the same time I used to think, let the US rate it first, but overtime I've learnt the US is not always right and when it comes to films, its only the PR red carpet shenanigans that prevent the instant global roll out. Movie stars cant be in two or more places at once "promoting" their films. Tom Cruise or any other movie star turning up for a country's premiere is not going to sway me either way, the trailers either look good or not. Sometimes Rotten Tomatoes may also sway me. The British press dont sway me. Comments from strangers in the street who rave on about a film sway me more than the press do! And this is why Netflix and Apple TV have an advantage at eating into both the Hollywood pie and a country's own terrestrial offerings like Channel 4 or BBC films. Carving out a niche in the middle which is where the money can be found especially considering the low cost of CGI. Hollywood could do more if it embraced iMax more, for example I've yet to see the latest TopGun:Maverick film, because I want to see it at an iMax theatre for that whole AV in the thick of the action experience. I have this Blackberry film on my list of films to see though because it looks funny, I want to see how reality has been altered and I dont think some of the tech companies get enough Hollywood treatment considering how pivotal they are or have been in our lives. Tetris is another on my list to see. Le Man's 66, and Joy are other examples of pivotal things in our lives, even if some of us dont shop on QVC, they still fill in that gap of how did these things come to be, even if not historically 100% accurate, its the sort of history lesson no one else is giving to the masses. Most history taught at school is just battles and wars, its like the state has an obsession with fighting, so to have Hollywood give us some history is refreshing and I encourage them to do more please.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Reason077 3y ago
- wunderland 3y agoGlenn Howerton is a great actor. Loved this movie
- pwillia7 3y agoWell you had to ... you know because of the implication
- wunderland 3y agoHe went full Brian LeFevre
- nailer 3y agoFilm is releasing in the UK in October. It came out in May. I absolutely want to give the filmmakers money now to see it. Why do they do this to themselves? Sell it to me. Take the money out of my hand. I am giving it to you.
- Kranar 3y agoFor the same reason farmers don't own grocery stores; making a film is different from distributing it. The filmmakers know how to make a film but they don't know how to release it to movie theaters and actually receive payment from ticket sales, heck they first have to actually convince the movie theatre to show the film in the first place. They also have to get it classified and rated and sometimes even censored, get all the appropriate music licenses for different markets, advertise for it including making trailers and posters and that work often has legalities associated with it all on its own, and the host of work that is needed to make it worthwhile to release a movie in various foreign markets. The filmmakers release it in their local market first, usually the U.S. is the biggest market. If the film does well and an UK distributor has the confidence that it's worth releasing in the UK then the filmmakers will sell the rights to the distributor to handle all the stuff I mentioned above.
- lobf 3y agoIn the USA it’s actually illegal for studios to own theaters.
- Kranar 3y agoYou are referring to the Paramount Decree, which is not longer in force: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Paramount_Pictures,_Inc.#Termination_of_the_Paramount_decrees https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Paramount_Pic...
- nailer 3y agoEverything you're saying is true, but I suspect it doesn't compensate for a late release in an overseas market when the worldwide hype has died down already. It's a legacy of the world pre mainstream internet.
- glitchc 3y agoI was fine with the review, even though the film was panned by an insider as being quite inaccurate [0], but this got to me: > Of course, Research in Motion imploded spectacularly… Blackberry went from controlling over 50% to now controlling 0% of the cellphone market, Alberta’s oil industry has been destroyed by a decade-plus of willful misgovernance, and Canada’s long national suicide continues even as it’s doctors encourage it’s citizens to opt for physician-assisted suicide rather than burden the system with their depression, homelessness, or wounds sustained in their country’s wars… Really? That much self-hate? Then stop voting in governments full of shallow, vapid people based on how they look, or how much money they give away. People deserve the governments they elect. [0] https://nationalpost.com/opinion/dennis-kavelman-i-was-a-longtime-senior-leader-at-blackberry-the-new-movie-is-not-our-story https://nationalpost.com/opinion/dennis-kavelman-i-was-a-lon...
- Reason077 3y agoFor context, the National Post is a pretty heavily right-wing/conservative slanted publication. Basically the "Fox News" of Canadian newspapers.
- myth_drannon 3y agoCanadian media is not that polarized. Please stop comparing everything with Fox News, it became the new Hitler term.
- Reason077 3y agoI wouldn't say polarized, but there is certainly a sliding scale. And the National Post is as right wing as it gets in Canada. Certainly some of their opinion pieces can get pretty extreme - see example above.
- zeckalpha 3y agoIn the US, the polarization has "improved" as far-right people are leaving Fox News for OAN and similar.
- 3y ago
- ecornflak 3y agoI might be late to the party but I think if you watched BlackBerry you’d like the Tetris movie too. It’s a bit silly but in a good way.
- Reason077 3y agoAnd if you like the Tetris movie I also recommend "Pinball: The Man Who Saved the Game". About the guy who got New York City's long-time ban on pinball machines overturned, by proving that pinball was a game of skill, not chance.
- jspann 3y agoGreat timing! I just watched this last night with my friends. We all were surprised that this movie didn't get more traction! > But Glenn Howerton’s Portrayal of Jim Balsillie’s explosive rage is one of the great performances. Ever. it’s one of those instant legendary meme performances. Totally agree. Even if you're not into the story of blackberry, the character performances and rarely onscreen story of "engineer becoming corporate" is worth the watch.
- lebski88 3y agoMatthias Wandel (woodgears.ca), who was an engineer at blackberry throughout a lot of this, reviewed the film a few months ago: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4yuqdr_1iRg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4yuqdr_1iRg
- xavieralexandre 3y agoHe also did a nice post about a machine he built to test Blackberry pagers' radio reception: https://woodgears.ca/misc/rotating_machine.html https://woodgears.ca/misc/rotating_machine.html
- efxhoy 3y agoThe film really reminded me of what silicon valley, the series, would be like if it was set in that time frame. I thought it was funny.
- torgard 3y agoGlenn Howerton's performance is so good. Best performance I've seen this year, that's for sure.
- amanj41 3y agoBut of course! He is a five star man, after all
- 0x445442 3y agoI was a BlackBerry user from 2004 until 2019. The Bold 9900 was peak smartphone IMHO.
- _Parfait_ 3y agoThe blackberry bold is better than the iPhone? In what way?
- xethos 3y agoKeyOne, not Bold, but: To this day I use (and prefer) my KeyOne to anything else - though I do occasionally try to switch to the Pinephone Pro. It's just... better. Better battery life, better typing (including blind or without looking down), better notifications with the LED, better with hardware buttons for mute/speaker/end call, better at surviving drops, and less of a headache to repair. Less than 12 hours ago I dropped my KeyOne with enough force to make the back cover un-snap, and the phone shut down. But parts are not serialized, the back isn't fragile glass, and repairs are easy - and in this case, I just snapped the back into place. This isn't even the best BlackBerry. I still keep my Q10 on-hand, in a drawer, sadly wishing there was a functional Matrix client for it. If there was, I'd still carry it.
- dubcanada 3y agoIt certainly is not as bright and shiny as the iPhone, but frankly I LOVE blackberry keyboards. The OS was also amazing, it had honestly everything you need in a phone. You don't need youtube, facebook, an entire computer in your phone (as far as I am concerned). What you need was text messaging, being able to browse the internet/read snippets, news (if that matters to you), email, phone. It had ALL of that in a much better package then iPhone (minus the browsing that was still when dot mobi was a thing).
- brookst 3y agoYou’re kind of saying that a horse is the best car because nobody needs to go more than a few miles. Today, the word “phone” means always-connected handheld general purpose computer. And while *you^ may not need that, the market suggests you’re in a minority.
- moolcool 3y agoIf you liked BlackBerry, I very-highly recommend watching "Nirvanna The Band The Show", the TV show made by the same director.
- skyyler 3y agoAnother flick he made, The Dirties, is the best movie about a school shooting movie I’ve ever seen
- cmrdporcupine 3y agoThe fairly hurt-feelings "this isn't close to accurate" reviews from people who were insiders or employees at Blackberry turned me off from wanting to watch this film. I never had good feelings about RIM/Blackberry the company. I worked at Google Waterloo with a lot of people I'd characterize as "refugees" from there. And by the time the 2010s rolled around they were clearly in a serious decline. But this movie doesn't sound like it has the finger on why. Other people have linked to this article in the comments, but I'll call it up here into the root: https://nationalpost.com/opinion/dennis-kavelman-i-was-a-longtime-senior-leader-at-blackberry-the-new-movie-is-not-our-story https://nationalpost.com/opinion/dennis-kavelman-i-was-a-lon... In particular I think this is insightful and worth calling out: "It was also sad to see the easy knocks against Canada from Canadian movie writers — the movie Mike is quoted as saying “I didn’t say they were the best engineers in the world, I said they were the best engineers in Canada.” Do we really need to still talk about how the University of Waterloo is one of the top universities in the world? It sounds entertaining, but wildly wildly inaccurate. And disparaging of various humans and efforts involved. Dramatizations often are, but maybe this is just too close to home?
- _ea1k 3y agoBlackBerry really illustrates the problems that come with something truly new enters a market. You often only se two choices: - Don't imitate them and steadily cede market share - Imitate them and immediately alienate your user base I often wonder what they really should have done?
- Mountain_Skies 3y agoThey made some pretty bad decisions during their decline. As a developer, it became infuriating how often the signing server was down. You can't push unsigned code to a Blackberry hardware device and the software simulator was not very good at replicating the actual behavior of code on the actual hardware. It was often broken at random for a couple of days but that stretched over a week sometimes. Even correcting a small typo like 'SEX Compliance' that should have been 'SEC Compliance' could take a week because the size of a change didn't matter, everything sent to the device had to be signed by RIM's signing server. This was at a time they were pleading for developers to not abandon the platform for Apple and Android, both of which had much simpler development on testing cycles for their hardware, even if publishing to the actual store could be a chore.
- ttul 3y agoBlackBerry didn’t have a second act. They put all their blackberries in one very nice basket and failed to invest their riches into the kind of deep, speculative R&D that keeps Apple, Microsoft, and Google on the cutting edge on multiple fronts simultaneously, ready to pivot when the opportunity or threat presents itself. Is it a tragedy, though? I think most companies are doing well if they manage to return billions to their initial shareholders by exploiting a breakthrough product for a few years. Companies aren’t meant to last forever. They exist to enrich shareholders for a while - hopefully a long time, but everyone realizes most companies eventually are bought or fail due to changing market conditions.
- no_wizard 3y agoThey almost did with BBM. They came really close to getting major telecoms to use it as their backbone to replace SMS / MMS infrastructure. A bit of a shame that never came to fruition honestly
- EncomLab 3y agoThe biggest issue I have with the movie is it attempts to shoe-horn the RiM story into the same mold as Apple. But RiM was a large company when it began developing devices for two-way paging - and the BB was the output of a team of engineers evolving existing products, not some flash in the pan new device developed by one guy in his garage. Besides, as anyone who has read "Losing the Signal" knows - it was not the devices but the proprietary servers that were the real money makers for RiM. The spectrum providers PAID RiM a monthly fee per user to have RiM servers in their datacenters. It was the loss of that revenue that doomed the company.
- dangus 3y agoI thought that skipping those technical details served the movie well. After all, it’s not a documentary, it’s made to be emotionally engaging and entertaining. It seems to me that the underlying reason that the spectrum providers were no longer willing to pay RIM was because customers wanted to use alternative products that didn’t saddle the carriers with the those extra costs. If Apple and Android hadn’t come around, BlackBerry would have had a lot more leverage.
- rchaud 3y agoYou can't expect a movie adaptation of a non-fiction book to be completely faithful to the original. I love the book but I realize it makes total sense to market the film as the story of Canada's versio of Apple Computer. The Blackberry devices were an icon of the corporate world and Wall Street; like a Rolex, it told the world you were important. It's that image that got Fortune 100 companies to order the things in droves and pay for the expensive servers.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ronyfadel 3y agoWhat similar movies to you recommend watching? Part nerdy, part business.
- fortunateregard 3y agoMargin Call
- tptacek 3y agoThis person wrote a post a couple days back about how "Jews are the American Cossacks", "explicitly given privileges and more freedoms than other ethnicities". So yeah, I think maybe I'll stick with Metacritic for the movie reviews.