4 ms·
> Direct CO2 removal (Climeworks). Seems like a drop in the bucket, but feel like this tech needs to grow. I kindly disagree, and I think it is extremely impor
by palata 3y ago
> Direct CO2 removal (Climeworks). Seems like a drop in the bucket, but feel like this tech needs to grow.
I kindly disagree, and I think it is extremely important to understand that. This tech is fundamentally flawed and completely misses the point: climate change (hence CO2) is only a symptom of our biggest problem.
Our biggest problem is abundant energy:
1. Because we have access to a lot of energy, we transform the world in a way that is killing biodiversity: we are currently living a mass extinction (that's not a prediction, that's a fact, it's happening, we can measure it right now). We should do less with less, and preserve habitat for biodiversity. There is no high-tech solution to that, we should preserve life on Earth.
2. Because that abundant energy is mostly fossil based, it emits a ton of CO2. That creates climate change which threatens our very survival (now in the short term). Climate change will create global instability, mass immigration, wars, famines, etc. We don't want that, so we need to emit much, much less CO2. So much less, in fact, that the only viable solution is to do less with less. One could argue that we should "just" replace fossil fuels with better energies (good luck with that, we are not even remotely on that path), but that would not remove point 1 above.
3. Fossil fuels are not unlimited. The peak of conventional oil production was in 2008. The global peak for oil is around now, for gas it is soon. From the peak on, energy will become harder and harder to get (which will induce price instability). Whether we care about climate change and biodiversity or not, fossil energy is going down soon. We don't have viable replacements, so we will have to do less with less. Without abundant energy, we have the same kind of consequences as climate change: global instability, famines, etc. We need to prepare our society to live with less energy. Would you rather go to space on holiday, or eat?
Finally, CO2 removal requires a ton of energy. The only way it can ever possibly be useful is if we suddenly find a way to completely replace fossil energy with renewables (say with nuclear fusion). But it's really not clear at all if we will find such an energy now (nope, wind and solar are not viable replacements for all fossil fuels). Even if we did suddenly get fusion to work, it's already too late: it would take a lot of time to build enough plants everywhere and then rebuild the whole infrastructure to remove fossil fuel.
We need to act now, for our survival. It's high time we accepted that we failed to replace fossil fuels entirely, and even if we did we would still be in a mass extinction. We need to do less with less. Remove what's unnecessary, keep the essential.
It does not mean going back to how people lived in the Middle Age. We need a lot of clever technology if we want to do less with less. That's actually more challenging than what we are doing now, so we need clever people to rethink society and do less with less.
- Aerroon 3y ago>It does not mean going back to how people lived in the Middle Age. It basically does though. The clever technology that allows you to have a smaller carbon energy footprint usually just outsources the cost to somewhere else. There's just no way I can see how people would have anywhere near today's quality of life without the corresponding energy consumption. Number one reason would straight up be political. You're going to have to curb a lot of freedoms from people to do it and they will have a reduction in quality of life since you will never be able to understand what's important to them.
- palata 3y agoFirst, it is important to realize that it's not a choice, really. Fossil energy is not unlimited. Either we start preparing for that, or it will happen and we will be unprepared (which will be worse). > There's just no way I can see how people would have anywhere near today's quality of life without the corresponding energy consumption. I think that there is a lot we can do without changing the quality of life. First, we don't need to take the plane for a weekend trip, and for professional reasons many times it can be solved with a video call. My grand parents and even my parents did not fly nearly as much as I did, and I wouldn't say they were living in the Middle Age. Then we don't need to eat meat. Not so long ago, again, people were not used to cheap meat like today in many places in the world. And pretty clearly, meat is less efficient to grow than plants. I grew up in a world without smartphones, and I don't feel like I live much better today. Do we really need to swipe TikTok over 5G whenever we have a few minutes (or much more) to lose? Do we really need to have 50 machines running a 1h build on the Cloud for every single commit we push? Do we really need generative AI? I literally lived without it my whole life. I grew up in the 90s/2000s, I wouldn't call that Middle Age. Many things today are more efficient than they used to be, the problem is the rebound effects. I would argue that we could do a lot already without altering our quality of life in any meaningful way (we would just need to change some habits, like losing 3h on social network everyday). Of course that's not enough, we need to do a lot more, and that will be more painful. But if we don't manage to start with the part that is not painful, how will we ever get to the next part?
- 3y ago