2 ms·
> The report represents one of the over 70 actions implemented by the White House Task Force on Worker Organizing and Empowerment, chaired by Vice President Har
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
> The report represents one of the over 70 actions implemented by the White House Task Force on Worker Organizing and Empowerment, chaired by Vice President Harris.
They commissioned a partisan report. It opens with the classic move where you put a graph of two things that happened in the decades following WW-II, find a big correlation or anti-correlation between them (because the post-war period moved the needle on nearly every graph of everything), and then imply causation.
Much of the paper is just listing broken things in the economy, like high housing costs, and hand waving a theory that unions could help with that somehow. But that doesn't even work -- if you have housing scarcity caused by restrictive zoning, raising wages without alleviating the shortfall only makes people bid up the existing housing stock and transfers most of the higher pay to landlords. To actually fix it you have to build more housing.
And increasing the pay of only some workers can even make it worse, because it increases the cost of goods and services -- like new housing construction -- which then raises prices for everyone, both the people getting paid more and the people not. Which is made worse because unions are less able to monopolize unskilled labor than skilled labor, so unions will tend to increase the price of skilled labor (in monopolistic industries) while unskilled workers only get higher costs.
But the fundamental point -- and the fundamental problem -- is this one:
> At these firms with market power, unions engaging in monopoly behavior of their own can bargain for workers to share some of the high profits earned by firm owners, executives, and shareholders
Unions can only extract something from companies in uncompetitive markets because competitive markets have slim margins, but uncompetitive markets are bad and those industries need to be broken up, not have the monopoly rents shared only with the workers in those industries while everyone else continues to experience inefficiency and high prices.
And unionizing those industries creates a new lobby to prevent that necessary antitrust action, because those unions will not want the industry to be made competitive if they're extracting part of the monopoly rent being paid by the general public.