6 ms·
In this example, someone else had to get it off the ground. The sibling commenter's example of Zachary's is similarly the product of entrepreneurs who got it s
by andsoitis 3y ago
In this example, someone else had to get it off the ground.
The sibling commenter's example of Zachary's is similarly the product of entrepreneurs who got it started https://zacharys.com/about-us/our-story/ https://zacharys.com/about-us/our-story/
- fouc 3y ago> someone else had to get it off the ground implying what? that "workers" can't start something? Even if we imagine there's a category of people that are suited to be "starters" or "entrepreneurs" that category is still plenty numerous, easily 10-35% of the population, if not more.
- wjnc 3y agoPlease be kind in your interpretation. Build and run are two very different phases. You need lots of capital for the former, mostly hands for the latter. Capital formation is probably harder for a group of workers because it leads to messy questions about residual earnings.
- JamesBarney 3y agoI think this is the issue. Starting a company is a lot riskier than working at one. To do that you usually need capital and/or someone who is willing to work their ass off for peanuts for a couple of years. The only reason people will take risks is for outsized returns.
- rcme 3y agoYes that is the implication. Starting something requires raising money and organizing things. Generally, at the start, only a small number of people care to do this work. And once they do it, why would they give their ownership stake away to their employees when they could just keep it for themselves?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- salawat 3y agoBoredom. (You have to be insane to whip something up and get it moving. Some thrive doing just that, but suffer under steady state stagnation.)
- sam0x17 3y agoPractically anyone already wanting to work at such a place would care to do it with the proper resources. Imagine if you could easily get a government grant to start such a co-op...
- rcme 3y agoEven if we're imaging a scenario with free government money, I'm not sure a co-op makes sense because of the financial incentives at the heart of capitalism. Imagine you could get government money to start a co-op or take private investment and maintain a large ownership stake in the business? Isn't the upside way higher for you if you go the private investment route? Of course, the government could subsidize co-ops to the degree that financial incentives of starting a co-op outweigh the financial incentives from starting a traditional business, and maybe they should do that, but it's not how our curent market is structured.
- hnbad 3y agoThis assumes all founders act as rational economic actors. Yes, it's hard to pivot from a traditional corporation to a co-op because of capitalism, but there are plenty of people who love the idea of a co-op but either don't have the capital or where the available capital is not evenly distributed among those interested to found the co-op with them. Amazingly, most humans do not do primarily what has the biggest economic advantages for them but what they think aligns best with who they think they are or want to be. Speaking from personal experience, as a founder who does not come from wealth the biggest reasons not to pivot to a co-op are that you're giving up control over something you created, you have a lot of money caught up in it that could have instead gone towards your personal life and that someone you hired as an employee is not necessarily interested in becoming a co-owner (e.g. if your country has workers rights they might be losing access to certain guarantees and benefits by doing so). Your wording is also needlessly abrasive. The government subsidies a large part of the economy like agriculture and fossil fuels (this is true in Germany and also seems to be the case in the US). Calling subsidies "free government money" suggests this is unheard of and unrealistic. If we want to go full utopia, the government could not simply subsidize co-ops, it could mandate them, e.g. by enacting a law that requires non-publicly traded businesses above a certain size to be worker-owned (with all liabilities to the founders being converted to standard loans) and prohibiting natural persons from holding more than a given percentage of any publicly traded company to shut down the potential loophole of just going public. It's the government. It's what allows corporations to exist so it could also restrict them.
- dagw 3y agoimplying what? that "workers" can't start something? Technically if there's no company yet there is nowhere to work and thus no workers. You need "founders" to get the company started for there even to be workers. Now those people have to decide if they want to never hire anybody new, 'give away' a a piece of 'their' company each time they hire, or give up on the worker-owned idea all together. Of course most "founders" used to be "workers" and often become "workers" again after the company is founded, but the act of founding a company is fundamentally different from the act of working at a company
- hnbad 3y agoAs someone who founded a company and had employees: it's not all that different, though the specifics depend on the kind of business. The biggest difference is that in order to found a company you need capital and workers generally don't have enough capital to found a company (and if they do and do found a company, as you said they become founders themselves). There is of course different work to be done at every stage of development of a company and this means that founding a company may require skills running it may not or vice versa but there is no reason someone who is good at founding companies should continue to call the shots or pocket most of the revenue once the company is fully operational. That's an expectation tied to the return on investment primarily and our system being set up in such a way that founders are owners and workers coming in later are not.
- helpfulmandrill 3y agoA bit of a long read, but the co-operative sector does have some ideas about how to offer "founder incentives" in workers cooperatives. https://jrwiener.com/cooperatives-and-founder-incentives/ https://jrwiener.com/cooperatives-and-founder-incentives/ The idea is that cooperatives don't have to treat everyone exactly the same. You can have different "classes" of members. You can have ordinary worker members, but also "founder" members. For example, for an agreed number of years "founder" members can get to elect a certain amount of board seats and get a higher share of profits. Sure, it moves away from "one-person one-vote" democracy and full equality, but only for a temporary period, and it still gives ordinary workers a much greater say in their workplace than they get in standard companies.
- thefounder 3y agoPretty much like the big law firms work?
- helpfulmandrill 3y agoPossibly. My impression, purely from popular media, is that only partners have any say in the running of a law firm, and becoming a partner involves cash buy-in of some sort, which might be a little different from co-operatives, where usually all permanent non-probationary workers have some sort of vote. But as I say, my knowledge of law firms is mostly from watching The Good Wife, so....
- thefounder 3y agoYou can become partner if you bring good clients with no cash buy in required. I think there are also different levels of partnership(i.e not all of them get their name in the office name). I have a reliable source on this: Suits
- wahnfrieden 3y agoThank you for sharing this, great resource and inspiring