45 ms·
> Imminent lawless action is a very narrow scope and does not overlap with the "fire in a theater" danger of false alarm. Yeah, but “fire in a crowded theater”
by dragonwriter 3y ago
> Imminent lawless action is a very narrow scope and does not overlap with the "fire in a theater" danger of false alarm.
Yeah, but “fire in a crowded theater” was dicta (a non-controlling tangent, basically) that (1) didn’t reflect the law as it existed prior to the case it was written in, (2) didn't illustrate or reflect the new rule in the case it was written in, and (3) was written in a decision that has since been effectively overruled and is widely regarded as one of the worst intrusion on core political speech ever allowed by the Supreme Court.
It is not, and never has been a guide to (or even accurate illustration of) unprotected speech. Despite how catchy it is and how popular it has become as something misused as if it was such a guide.