2 ms·
The author is grossly mistaken here. The idea that the AGPL is unenforceable is dangerous advice that could backfire on someone. Let me offer a different view
by kazinator 3y ago
The author is grossly mistaken here.
The idea that the AGPL is unenforceable is dangerous advice that could backfire on someone.
Let me offer a different viewpoint.
The AGPL is a non-free license which uses the same legal principles as shrink-wrap EULA licenses. If the AGPL is not enforceable, then the majority of (other) EULAs are also not enforceable. Quick, someone tell Microsoft, Adobe, Apple, ... do they and their legal departments and lawyers know?
The restrictions/requirements inherent in the AGPL are use restrictions. If you run the program such that people connect to it, you are not redistributing it and so copyright does not apply. That use of the software is governed by requirements.
No software with use restrictions can reasonably be called free.
The legal doctrine at play is exactly like that in shrink-wrapped EULAs (note the "U" there): you are allowed to have a copy of the program (which lands under copyright) if you conform to certain behaviors. In the case of a typical EULA: that you won't reverse engineer the program, or copy it, or crack the license to give yourself unlimited use, etc. In the case of the AGPL, that you won't use it in a way that people can access it, without giving them the code with all your mods.
If you don't comply with the rules, then the offer lapses: the program is not licensed to you. You are not properly engaged in the contract, and so the copyright holder does not give you permissions to have and use a copy of that program, or to use it in that way.
That's how I think it works. Software licenses which restrict use do not use only copyright. They are contracts which make the granting of the copy conditional on contracted behavior. Arbitrary conditions can be linked to the copyrighted work.
If some court does find the AGPL or any other EULA unenforceable, it will almost certainly be due to some much more subtle argument than "oh, it's a copyright license that's only concerned with redistribution distribution, so whatever it says about use can just be ignored".