> Usually “reasonable” is a cue that you are discussing a matter of fact, which is the province of the jury. And then there are motions for a JMOL (see FRCP 50

> Usually “reasonable” is a cue that you are discussing a matter of fact, which is the province of the jury. And then there are motions for a JMOL (see FRCP 50), where a judge has to decide whether a “reasonable jury” could have a legally sufficient basis to find in favor of a party. Law as the verkehrte Welt of itself. :)