2 ms·
You're doing the same thing the other commenters are: you're trying to derive from first principles what "ethical hacking" means. That's why this marketing tric
by tptacek 3y ago
You're doing the same thing the other commenters are: you're trying to derive from first principles what "ethical hacking" means. That's why this marketing trick is so insidious: everybody does that, and attributes to the term whatever they think the right things are. But the term doesn't mean those right things: it means what the vendors meant, which is: co-opted researchers working in collusion with vendors to give dev teams the maximum conceivable amount of time to apply fixes (years, often) and never revealing the details of any flaws (also: that any security researcher that doesn't put the word "ethical" in their title is endorsing criminal hacking; also: that you should buy all your security services from I.B.M.).
You can say "that's not what I mean by ethical hacking", but that doesn't matter, because that's what the term of art itself does mean.
If you want to live in a little rhetorical bubble where terms of art mean what you think they should mean, that's fine. I think it's worth being aware that, to practitioners, that's not what the terms mean, and that people familiar with the field generally won't care about your idiosyncratic definitions.