2 ms·
That's a really interesting effect, but as a product, I don't see how it's superior to modern small form-factor filters from Sawyer, Katadyn, etc. Those don't
by JohnFen 3y ago
That's a really interesting effect, but as a product, I don't see how it's superior to modern small form-factor filters from Sawyer, Katadyn, etc.
Those don't require electricity, are as good at ridding the water of microorganisms, and also filter out many harmful non-biological contaminants.
- zwieback 3y agorequire replaceable filters, though. I could see that as a tradeoff.
- JohnFen 3y agoTrue, but those filters last a very long time. The Sawyer Squeeze (what I use) produces ~1000 gallons of filtered water before needing replacement[1]. I assume others using the same technology perform similarly. It also filters the water much more quickly. As fast as you can drink it. [1] Assuming you properly maintain it by backflushing every so often, which is quick and easy, but still necessary.
- bryceacc 3y agowarranty is actually lifetime: https://www.sawyer.com/lifetime-warranty https://www.sawyer.com/lifetime-warranty i think you would need more than the syringe and arm power backflush to really restore a good flow over years, but hey it's only 30 bucks and mine has been working for 4 years
- JohnFen 3y agoTrue, and they also claim that the filter is good for at least 100,000 gallons. That may be correct and I'm just doing something wrong, but my experience with it is more in line with what most reviewers claim: about 1,000 gallons before I can no longer restore reasonable flow. As you say, they're inexpensive, so I don't sweat this too much.
- boh 3y agoI don't think it's a product so much as a proof of concept. The use of electricity will definitely not make this a must-have for backpackers, but maybe the technology can be leveraged for larger scale filtration systems (or just the one you use in your house).
- chaostheory 3y agoI can see this as a product given the trend of failing infrastructure. Right now, we’re only seeing things like poorly maintained roads & bridges, and failing power grids depending on your area. I predict that water purification issues will go beyond the rust belt if it hasn’t emerged already.
- borkt 3y agomost issues with failing water infrastructure involve non-biological contaminants like lead.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]